Friday, February 06, 2009

I know what Sultan Azlan did last March ...

DO YOU? But first, it is quite obvious that Anwar Ibrahnim and Mohd Nizar Jamaluddin are trying to push the issue to the streets. All the ingredients seem to be there: disregard the Sultan's wishes, to hell with the state's Constitution! This morning, Nizar reported for duty as usual despite the Sultan having asked him to step down and pave way for a new state government.
NST 10.07 am Nizar and exco members have entered state secretariat building after minor scuffle, Nizar says he will remain in office
BH 09:58 pagi Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin dan Exco masuk ke pejabatnya di SUK jam 9.43 pagi. Katanya tiada arahan tinggalkan pejabat dan kediaman rasmi.
Nizar is fighting "till the last drop of his blood". So the police had to come in.
NST 10:27:21 MB's office taken over by police who receive orders to escort Nizar and exco members out. Press conference interrupted by state secretary
STAR 10:27:47 Nizar was escorted out of his now emptied room at the state secretariat at 10:15am by Ipoh OCPD who stopped Nizar press conference
What now? Another mammoth rally to show the Sultan the might of "Ketuanan Rakyat"?

What the Sultan did last March. I was reliably informed of this story only yesterday. So, before anyone thinks of burning down Ipoh and Kuala Kangsar or fight till the last drop of blood, listen up. This was how it was told to me:

"I know that you do not know what Sultan Azlan Shah did last March when UMNO, the party with the biggest number of ADUN seats, sought his consent to re-form the state government of Perak. Not many people know. I'm going to tell you so that you will know that the Sultan has acted in the best interest of his State and his Rakyat in the case of Nizar.

"You see, on the night of March 8, after securing more Adun seats than the other parties, UMNO made a representation to the Sultan to form a new state government.

"But Sultan Azlan is a wise Sultan. He knows the law and he could read the situation well. He did not accede to UMNO's request even though UMNO had won the most number of seats compared with DAP, PAS, or PKR.

"So the Sultan told UMNO that he had a feeling that DAP, PAS and PKR would join hands and if they do so UMNO will not have the support of the majority in the state assembly. He requested that UMNO wait until had had mete the reps from DAP, PAS and PKR.

"That was how the Sultan called in all the DAP, PAS, and PKR state assemblymen. He decided after that to allow Pakatan Rakyat to form the new state government in Perak. The rest is history. Or, rather, was history.

"You see, Sultan Azlan, our former Yang diPertuan Agong, is a professional and he knows his law better than you and I, Nizar or Anwar. He was the former Lord President."

In Malaysian cyberspace, "reliably informed" could mean a tall story, so don't just take my word for it. Read also what constituional law expert Prof Dr Shad Saleem Faruqi had to say here [Not in Constitution, but Sultan can dismiss MB].

And Big Dog writes about "ingkar", which is the correct Malay translation for defiance against one's Sultan.
.


261 comments:

  1. after the march 2008, the BN tried to form government with PAS but failed...
    so don't blame Keadialan for playing the game OK...
    But for BN (who said their always have ppl behind them) to takeover Perak this way is playing dirty.
    No wonder ppl were angry and willing to standout while being called with all names (derhaka / treason etc etc etc by the UMNO).
    Wouldn't you if you waited for years to get rid of a parasite, you suceed but it came back due to 'technicality'

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous6:48 am

    Bro Rocky...
    I wakeop early to play football today. B4 that I stop a while at your site just to say:
    Our culture should instil a thinking that is always rational and analytical in nature so that an issue can be looked at from various perspectives. There should also be a positive attitude to immediately resolve a problem in an exact manner. In this way, we can prevent a mentality among the people that is easily depressive and confused by Permanent Residence = PR (Pakatan Rakyat).
    In fact, The universal wave of democratisation is getting stronger. Indeed, we can be proud that Umno and Barisan Nasional is a body of system and policy that is most democratic among political parties in the developing countries. Not like PR )DAP, Pas and PKR), Umno and BN democracy is a practice that plucks feudalism from its roots. Democracy gives rights to every Umno member in a collective way to determine the direction of its struggle. Thus, Umno does not make any distinction among its members based on descent, social status or wealth.
    Every member is free to be heard and the party accepts any view based on truth and accuracy. And the practice of democracy had also made Umno to always be the rakyat, to be aware of their sufferings and their hopes. This is the secret of Umno strength - Umno is not merely carried by its members. What has made Umno invincible is its strength which is derived from the people's support.
    Thanks a lot and may God bless you and family.
    Dah nak siap pegi main bola nih...

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous6:55 am

    Ramai orang PR ingat kalau ada pilihanraya semula kat Perak, PR sure akan menang besar ker?

    Ramai orang melayu yg undi DAP(sampai dapat 17 kerusi DUN) PRU lepas, aku bet mereka takkan undi DAP lagi. Mereka dah cukup tengok dan lihat apa telah jadi pada tanah-tanah orang melayu kat sana.

    Aku sokong pilihanraya semula, walau sebanyak mana pun duit akan habis, kalau itu diperlukan untuk buat penyokong PR tu tutup mulut terus, maka pilihanraya patut diadakan semula.

    Aku nak tengok melayu Perak mana yg sanggup pangkah DAP kali kedua!!!

    Come on BN, tak perlu takut, buat pilihanraya semula kat Perak. Ramai tak sabar nak memangkah niee...

    orang jauh.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous6:57 am

    Brother Melayu,
    Yang sibuk berdemonstrasi tu orang melayu aje. Mana orang lain. Orang lain pandai. They are smart people coz they work through their puppets and nominess.Beratus tahun melayu dianggap bodoh dan malas. Hari ini bukti tersebut masih ada dan jelas. Eloklah hangpa semua jadi dreber dan tukang kebun.Paling aku tak boleh percaya, ada yang sanggup baring tengah jalan. Ni bangsa apa ni? Yang baring tengah jalan tu tak dapat apa-apa pun.Hangpa nak tunjuk apa? Kepandaian atau kebodohan? Yang dapat benefit orang lain. Nak tolak BN pun mesti ada cara yang bijak. Mungkin sifat melayu seperti mengamuk (sebab tu salah satu perkataan inggeris dicedok dari bahasa melayu - run amok) sudah tertanam kuat dalam jiwa dan fikiran orang melayu. Nampaknya Melayu perlu 500 tahun lagi untuk maju.Itupun kalau Melayu masih ada 500 tahun lagi.

    Awang Senior

    ReplyDelete
  5. Melayu di tanah airku
    kini begitu bercelaru dan haru biru
    akibat berpuak dan semakin keliru
    yang mana politik, yang mana ketuanan mu?
    maka sanggup mencabar raja Melayu
    Raja sebangsa mu!
    Raja seagama mu!
    yang jadi tunggak kekuasaan Melayu!
    di manakan maruah mu?

    Tidak pernah Melayu
    mencabar dan derhaka seperti kamu
    di manakah nilai keislaman mu?
    akibat hasutan iblis dan kafir keparat
    maka kamu sanggup menjadi bangsat!
    hinanya kamu yang telah diangkat Raja dan diberi pangkat
    kini kamu anjing maka tuan digigit!

    Wahai Melayu
    sedarlah kamu
    kamu dipergunakan untuk tujuan tertentu
    perhatikan keliling kamu
    bukankah yang terpekik di jalanan hanya bangsa kamu?
    bukankan yang emosi terbaring juga bangsa kamu?
    di mana mereka yang kamu perjuangkan itu?
    apa sebenarnya perjuangan kamu?
    Islam? Melayu?
    Lalu di mana jati dirimu?

    Janganlah kerana emosi
    kamu derhaka kepada Sultan
    ingatlah!
    Raja Melayu akan tetap dipertahan
    Raja Melayu adalah Raja berdaulat
    selagi Melayu tidak hilang di dunia
    selagi itu Raja Melayu akan terus bertakhta di hati rakyat!

    DAULAT TUANKU! DAULAT TUANKU!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous7:17 am

    Hot!!! PANAS!!!! BERITA TErgempar!!

    Tengku Razaleigh berkata Nizar adalah Menteri Besar yang sah!:

    Dato’ Seri Nizar Jamaluddin adalah Menteri Besar Perak yang sah dari aspek perundangan dan perlembagaan melainkan jika beliau meletak jawatan atau disingkirkan melalui undi tidak percaya di persidangan Dewan Undangan Negeri. Tiada sebarang “provision” atau keizinan dalam perlembagaan boleh menyingkirkannya dari jawatan tersebut dengan apa cara sekalipun termasuklah melalui “petitions” atau tindakan di mahkamah mahupun melalui arahan dari mana-mana pihak berkuasa.

    http://razaleigh.com/2009/02/05/shameful-scene/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Melayu di tanah airku
    kini begitu bercelaru dan haru biru
    akibat berpuak dan semakin keliru
    yang mana politik, yang mana ketuanan mu?
    maka sanggup mencabar raja Melayu
    Raja sebangsa mu!
    Raja seagama mu!
    yang jadi tunggak kekuasaan Melayu!
    di manakan maruah mu?

    Tidak pernah Melayu
    mencabar dan derhaka seperti kamu
    di manakah nilai keislaman mu?
    akibat hasutan iblis dan kafir keparat
    maka kamu sanggup menjadi bangsat!
    hinanya kamu yang telah diangkat Raja dan diberi pangkat
    kini kamu anjing maka tuan digigit!

    Wahai Melayu
    sedarlah kamu
    kamu dipergunakan untuk tujuan tertentu
    perhatikan keliling kamu
    bukankah yang terpekik di jalanan hanya bangsa kamu?
    bukankan yang emosi terbaring juga bangsa kamu?
    di mana mereka yang kamu perjuangkan itu?
    apa sebenarnya perjuangan kamu?
    Islam? Melayu?
    Lalu di mana jati dirimu?

    Janganlah kerana emosi
    kamu derhaka kepada Sultan
    ingatlah!
    Raja Melayu akan tetap dipertahan
    Raja Melayu adalah Raja berdaulat
    selagi Melayu tidak hilang di dunia
    selagi itu Raja Melayu akan terus bertakhta di hati rakyat!

    DAULAT TUANKU! DAULAT TUANKU!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anonymous7:27 am

    COMPARE TO AMNO, JEWS ARE BLARDY SAINTS.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous7:33 am

    Ramai orang Cina, Melayu dan India membantah terhadap perampasan kuasa UMNO di Perak -- tengok video!!:

    http://tinyurl.com/bantahanrakyat

    Siapa cakap hanya satu kaum saja yang protest? Semua kaum protest beb!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Anonymous7:37 am

    Siapa dia sebenarnya YB Nizar Jamaluddin?

    INI RAHSIA YANG DAH TERBONGKAR

    TENGOK VIDEO NI!!!!

    http://tinyurl.com/siapanizar

    ReplyDelete
  11. Anonymous7:51 am

    PR supporters please read and reread Rocky's posting on Perak Fiasco. Check the law. As per prescedent in UK that is applicable to Malaysia, a commonwealth country, the first party to cross the line ie the single largest majority (word is single largest) could be legally invited to form the govt. In Perak's case it was BN. PKR wasnt a coalation because they were not incorporated as a party like BN. Which means they are collection of seperate parties working together. In Europe and elsewhere, there were parties allowed to form minority government so long as they can garner support of independence and any other small parties. Thus, Sultan Azlan Shah could have legally sworn in BN government in March 2008. Sultan, being far sighted and not wanting a state election did otherwise. He invited all the non BN (repeat non BN) state assemblymen and asked them one by one whether they agree to form a government together(PR was not registered as a coalation and Sutn was not obligd to call them one by one if he were partial towards BN) . Having got an affirmative Yes, he allows them to form the government.Likewise, now that Sultan knows three assemblymen had defected, he did not act by the newspaper report. he called all the three independents and asked them one by one whether they have now decided to throw support to BN Government. Having obtained affirmative Yes, Sultan now invites BN to form government. What Sultan Azlan Shah did was consistent a) He want to avoid State Election. This is his state and he has the right to do so by not dissolving State Assembly. ii) And he did the same thing ie do a head count of supporters to a particular group before concluding that he is satisfied that those with the most numbers could be invited to form a government. NIZAR FAILED THE TEST OF CRISIS MANAGEMENT. HE COULD HAVE ASKED THE SULTAN FOR TIME TO PROVE TO THE SULTAN THAT HE STILL COMMAND MAJORITY SUPPORT. HAVING OBTAINED THE TIME, HE COULD HAVE MAKE AN ATTEMPT TO NEGOTIATE AND RECONCILE WITH THE THREE INDEPENDANTS TO TURN OVER . BUT HE DID NOT DO THAT AND INSTEAD CHOSE TO SEEK SULTANS ASSENT TO DISSOLVE STATE ASSSEMBLY. BY CONSTITUTION, SULTAN CAN REFUSE TO DISSOLVE THE STATE ASSEMBLY BECAUSE HE BELIEVE BN CAN FORM THE GOVERNMENT. Nizar has second chance now. Go back to challenge BN to convene the state assembly. Call for vote of no confident against new MB. If he succeeds, The new MB has to go back to Sultan and either ask Sultan to invite Nizar back as MB or seek Sultan's assent to dissolve State Assembly for a new state election to be held. If that happens, I am sure Sultan would be convinced that both parties are now given a chance to form government but they cant hold their support together - thus Sultan would definitely grant assent for State Assembly to be dissolved. This is democracy maa,play it in accordance to democratic principles. State Assembly is your supreme playground not the courthouse! By the way, I may reconsider my support for PKR if you dont behave)
    Paul yap

    ReplyDelete
  12. Anonymous9:13 am

    dun simply say if u ain't knoe nutin about constitution..Nizar as Perak MB can only removed until he resigns of his own accord, or is removed by a vote of no-confidence in a formal sitting of the State Assembly. In other words, The Sultan itself can't ask the MB to resigns. And that is y Karpal Singh mentioned about legal act under the terms of "ultravires"
    - drakuzz Teluk Intan

    ReplyDelete
  13. Anonymous9:35 am

    Padai sungguh Bung Anwar ni mengajar orang Melayu menderhaka kepada Sultan. Apa yang lebih menyedihkan bila melihat orang ramai yang tak bersalah (termasuk Kanak-kanak) dan Mantan Menteri Besar Perak dipergunakan untuk mempertahankan kepentingan DAP.

    Dimana semangat orang Melayu yang terkenal dengan kesetiaannya ? Apakah tindakan Mantan Menteri Besar Perak akan mengajar rakyat menjadi pengkianat bangsa? Demonstari jalanan bukan cara menghalalkan tindakan walaupun umum tahu hanya seorang pemimpin sahaja yang tidak segan silu menghalalkan cara tersebut untuk kepentingan diri sendiri.

    Walau apa pun pendirian atau gesaan yang dibuat, biarlah Baginda Sultan Perak yang menentukan apa yang penting untuk rakyat baginda Sultan. Jangan ada pihak yang memperlekehkan titah Sultan kerana rakyat tidak pekak dan bisu. DAULAT TUANKU

    ReplyDelete
  14. Anonymous9:44 am

    Rocky, I'm also anak Perak and I love my Sultan, who I think is arguably the most learned of all the current rulers in Malaysia. But learned people can also sometimes act like idiots under certain circumstances.

    Meanwhile, like many I'm wondering how much this "exercise" actually cost UMNO. They must still be so flush with cash despite the bearish economy.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Anonymous9:45 am

    nampaknya sultan perak sengaja memperbodohkan rakyat dengan melantik nizar sebagai mb dan sekarang melantik adun pangkor yg ternyata kurang berpengalaman,agaknya sultan perak bekas ketua hakim zaman mamakkutty ni ada agenda sendiri ....

    ReplyDelete
  16. Anonymous10:36 am

    can't blame nizar derhaka for being so buddy with ngeh and nga.. he is half-half anyways..if my source is correct..mama chinese papa malay.. most of my friends with mix blood like these are quite confused.

    on one post about from mr richguy

    "I think some of them have failed to understand the actual situation here. It is not about PR being out power or position. It's about us the people, the voters who are angered by the power grabbing situation created by BN. "

    Sorry mr rich, you must have forgotten wat anwar ibrahim wanted to do on 16th sept last year; I was really angry with him that he wanted to take over the nation that way. He, of all people, who talked about justice and all, want to oust the ruling government chosen by the rakyat, through lompat party.. now, this BN is also looking desperate.. we rakyat all have one common unhappiness, the way it is being done looked like our say is not involved here.

    But being in a situation like wat we have right now, I would rather BN takeover and start making amends to their ways to be able to make us give them the real mandate in the next election. To me, BN or BA, they are just politicians who are greedy. But if they lower down their appetite and start thinking about the people needs i.e food on the table, work, education, health etc needs...nobody cares wat the hell they do up there..coz in the end, if you are a a leader, you are bound to have to answer to God one day for whatever you do. Now, we need to move on and together improve the nation.

    and again to azizah wife of anwar ibrahim , pls advise your husband to stop being a traitor to his own race and religion. to nizar, stop denying yourself, we accept you are brave to fight it, but just go with some dignity.

    Aku yg amat bosan

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anonymous11:00 am

    Well.. BN is now like Israel... devil is the eyes of some Malaysian.... so doesn't matter if PR hit BN, BN is still evil. So if you support Palestine, why not PR? Even if PR have to terrorize,,,

    KC

    ReplyDelete
  18. Dear Rocky,

    The title of post is "I know what Sultan Azlan did last March..." so let us stick to just that.

    1. Yes, what he did in March was to deny UMNO to rule the state on their claims that they have 28 or so seats. But, 28 seats does not make a simple majority, 30 is. So HRH was tied in his decision because a simple arithmetic check reveals that.

    2. I am more interested to know did HRH stay awake the night of 308 to follow the election results as they came streaming in? Was HRH in Perak at that time. So dear Rocky, pls do some digging in enlightened me. If u can confirm "Yes" to both then I can safely deduced that HRH benar2 berjiwa rakyat...

    3. At the same time, did HRH knew what the majority of Perakians did on 308? Perakians showed the door to Samy Vellu, Rafidah Aziz et al where Malays, Indians, Chinese etc collectively acted as 1 force - that of Bangsa Malaysia. Did HRH knew this?

    So, before putting someone high on the pedestal, pls acknowledged the sacrifice Perakians did on 308, including kicking Samy Vellu out when Tun MM, AAB failed to show the door to Samy.

    In the meantime, do cool down once in a while...

    Till then...G'nite M'sia...wherever u are...

    ReplyDelete
  19. Anonymous11:16 am

    Dear all,
    Sultan asked to respect new MB, where people lost respect of the Sultan....joke of the day.

    The proclaimation is by his ORANG KAYA......no wonder the kaya become more kaya...because they like roti kaya.

    http://www.nst.com.my/Current_News/NST/Saturday/National/2473318/Article/index_html

    Respect is earned, shame is brought by ownself. That includes the Sultan, he is not God.

    Lost Respect

    ReplyDelete
  20. Anonymous11:25 am

    Rock,

    This simple issue has been made complicated....umno lah ni.The right thing to do is just pass it to the electorate to decide through democratic system that we have....do you think Im going to beleive what azlan did last....1511Last and not least itu pendekar perak...yene POOOOOdah.

    ORANG ASLI.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Our wise Sultan had to do what he had to do. Nizar can file a suit in court and move on. What Dr M did last time?

    I think the voters in Perak have a right to be disaapointed as they voted the Opposition - not the person. It all depends what BN does, for now. Let the voters decide come next election.

    Anyway as an opposition supporter, I did not like it abt the pelting of prince's car. Maybe politician, a bit ok, lah - lol.

    Look what happened to Nizar OFFICE, no decency to wait for hime to hand over the stuff - Personal & Public. Have we actually learned for this experience.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Anonymous12:00 pm

    5 MINS WITH 2 GREEDY CROOKS & A CRIPPLE LIAR, HE IS CONVINCED THEY ARE THRUSTWORTHY?

    35 MINS WITH A FAT WOMANISER & KAKI TIDUR HE ALSO CONVINCED THE MOST CORRUPT PARTY (BY THEIR OWN ADMISSION) CAN RUN THE STATE.

    HELLO, WE NOT BORN YESTERDAY... SO WHAT HAPPEN, HUH?

    ReplyDelete
  23. Anonymous12:06 pm

    NOW BEWARE AND BE VERY AFRAID OF ANYONE WITH THE SURNAME...

    HEE!

    HEE!

    HEE!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Rocky,

    Your spin compared to what Art Harun has written stinks to kingdom come. You don't have the interpretative ability and don't even try to only list stuff that seems favourable to you. go read, http://art-harun.blogspot.com/2009/02/perak-crisis-unsolicited-legal-opinion.html and if at all there is any working brain cells left in you, you may just understand.

    Oh, by the way, it would seem The Sultan may not have had the authority to dismiss the MB after all. So how now?

    ReplyDelete
  25. Anonymous12:24 pm

    The root of the entire Perak crisis now is Anwar Ibrahim.

    He is very impatient wanting to be PM by hook or by crook.

    If he is really a seasoned politician, all he need to do is be a gentleman and accept this "temporary" defeat and start the real work now. I mean NOW.

    For the last 11 months, Anwar wasted all the time he has by concentrating his froggy mission. That is utter non-productive and nonsense to the Rakyat who were willing to give PR the votes then. With that froggy mission, the entire PR partners are shaky , each protectin their constituent, eg the Hudud issue, racial matter (PKNS GM), the Kulim MP at Bar Council forum, etc.

    PR also did not do anything concrete to enhance their internal relationship among DAP, PKR, DAP. How can you go to war with UMNO when your own team is not ready?

    The reasons why the 2 PKR and DAP leaving the party must be found out, in order to strengthen PR.

    I am very sure, if PR demonstrate its sincerity, commitment to the Pakyat, Perak will fall back to PR. But the big question is , will Anwar want to "invest" the time and effort? Unfortunately, the current blaming the defeat on BN and the wisdom of Sultan does not indicate Anwar want to do that. So in the end, Anwar will dig his own grave!!

    Why Anwar cannot wait? Anwar must explain that? Is it because he fear that when Najib assume to be PM, his (Anwar) opportunity will be gone forever? And could it be this reason why certain pro-Pakatan bloggers only focus the attack and "assasination" of Najib (instead on Abdullah Badawi).

    If this is a game btw Anwar vs Najid, then do not misled us to the extent we derhaka to the Sultan.

    Remember respect is earned and not by demand!!!

    Look at the arrogance of Nizar, Nga and Ngeh, it is pathetic!!! Please grow up if you really want the Rakyat to give you the suport.
    If I am Sultan, I will remember what Anwar is doing.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Anonymous12:55 pm

    ape ke bengap sgt la korang ni..adeke Sultan nak dilawannya?betul2 kemaruk la ..
    korang ni betul tk paham la konsep Raja Berpelembagaan..ko ingt Sultan n Raja tu duk tcanguk kt istana tu skdar boneka ke?aduhh..

    UMNO mmg patut memerintah Perak n smua negeri yg skrg ni d perintah d so-called Barisan Rakyat (or whatever it is) sebab die dpt krusi plg banyak atas tiket BN.tp si PKR+PAS+DAP ni lps dh dpt kptsn election br nak tubuhkan Pakatan Rakyat kononnya..pdhal betanding atas tiket parti masing2..tk ke rugi rakyat Perak dibodohkan?

    PKR..baik korang cermin diri..jgn bile ko baling taik kt org ko melompat suke,tp bile ko tpijak taik ko plak melenting..

    ReplyDelete
  27. Anonymous1:05 pm

    the way BN is doing really makes them look like pirates. They will suffer greatly in the next election. Meanwhile there shall be little peace in Perak. The people feel like they have been treated like a bag of shit, thrown onto the road.

    Ghost of Onn Jaafar.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Anonymous1:06 pm

    hallo to those people still think Sultan cannot fire MB... just imagine if all adun lompat and only left MB... SO sultan still cannot fire MB eh!! Don't be so emotional...

    Another, if PR win in next election.. Nizar will not be MB anymore... he has disgraced himself.. remember terengganu fiasco last year? Sultan can decide which MB he wants... now, please NIzar , go minta ampun...and be gentleman.. think through.. ask Tok Guru for advice, and doa to Allah for guidance.. don;t follow buta tuli ....

    ReplyDelete
  29. Anonymous1:07 pm

    Satu benda yg saya tak faham sampai sekarang. Kenapa orang2 melayu yg bagi komen di sini suka mencarut? Islamic ke tu? Tak kisah lah kalau tak suka org bangsa lain ke tak suka DSAI ke tak tapi tak perlulah guna bahasa2 kesat. Kalau macam ni lah perangai Rasullulah S.A.W pun malu nak mengaku umat. Nak mencarut dalam bahasa orang putih tapi bila suruh cakap english tak boleh pulak. Dah lah tu, jangan buat malu orang2 melayu lain. Sorry to say but I think we malays have no reason to feel superior because who are we in this world? Do we change world history? Do we contribute to new discoveries? Do we have a nobel prize winner? Do we play important role in world events? NO! the answer is a big NO! For the whites they have all the reason in the world to feel superior but not us, malays, because we did nothing that is of importance to humankind. But as with all bigots, there's no way to make sense to these people. Bet you even the Prophet will not be able to change the racist attitude of some of the malays here.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Anonymous1:13 pm

    rocky..

    so can Prof Saleem Faruqi explain this :

    “Didalam keadaan biasa, Yang DiPertuan Agong tidak boleh menghalang permintaan untuk pembubaran Parlimen. Tanggungjawab Baginda hanyalah untuk mengesahkan.” Raja Azlan Shah…didalam bukunya yang bertaju, “Constitutional Monarchy, Rule of Law and Good Governance .”

    ReplyDelete
  31. Anonymous1:23 pm

    Bro Rocky

    Your blogger turned MP friend, Jeff Ooi in his latest posting in Screenshots wrote:

    " Elsewhere in the cyberspace, if you are resourceful and I am not willing to publish the URL, you can read forum postings that derogate Sultan Azlan Shah, the former Lord President of Malaysia"

    Jeff, did you read the comments by readers of Rocky'sBru???
    How, many of them detest PR's eleven months of governing. How they hated the way your DAP twisted the hands of Nizar the MB?
    How they hated the PKR Chief's way of streets mobster? How they detest the way PAS and PKR Malays DERHAKA towards Tuanku???

    Come on Jeff, please don't insult your own wisdom.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Anonymous1:26 pm

    ... dont think like UMNO, think like PKR, cannot jump to BN, but can jump to PR, BN have a lot of "rasuah", PR is clean, Sultan have been bribed by UMNO by a billions, PR dont want money only to work for people (the only thing I heard up to now is Camry car and BABI), Najib kills Altantuya, Anwar is hero...

    all this rubbish! you all guys just know how to throw rubbish and when the same thing happen to you, no... it cannot happen to you, why? because your are "the Rakyat", the "Adil" one, FUCK YOU! You know, you, yes you! (PKR/PAS/DAP people) have turn to more arrogant and corrupt than BN only because of those small winning after March 08. I wonder what happen if you win the whole country.

    FYI, I voted PKR last GE, and how sorry I am.

    oko

    ReplyDelete
  33. Anonymous1:26 pm

    well, i dont know what is your slunting and angling towards this issue or how much reliable the information was.

    and why juat opinion of Prof Saleem only?Is it there is no qualified law expertise rather than this Prof?Like Azmi shahrom,Aziz Bari, etc?

    why not you take the opinion of two side :

    1)BN
    2)PR

    yeah..you're veteran journalist..well..

    i suggest you put also question that arise from PR also

    a)the Statutory Declaration (RM 50 Million offer by BN)

    b)the effect if doin the election

    c)why dont do the vote no confidence in Dewan Undangan Negeri as happened during time of Stephen Kalong Ningkan.

    d)Ingkar?to what extend?How bout the history of Malay Sultan in : Perjanjian Pangkor?Kejatuhan kerajaan Melayu Islam Patani?Malayan Union in the early stage?Singapore to stamford raffles?

    It just nice if you show the argument from both side and let people judge it...

    ReplyDelete
  34. Anonymous1:28 pm

    PR = Israel to the core!

    Koku

    ReplyDelete
  35. Anonymous1:31 pm

    errrr..do you know about GAMUDA that some hearsay being claimed it own by Sultan Azlan's doughter.Heard it need injection 1-2 billion..

    ReplyDelete
  36. Anonymous1:47 pm

    Those who said that respect is earn, certainly you want the Sultan to be respected by you, then again, at the cost of Sultan following your fancies and mood. That kind of Sultan certainly cannot be respected. I respect the Sultan because he dare to do what he think is right, no matter what you all guys(PR people) think.

    Kuku

    ReplyDelete
  37. Anonymous2:10 pm

    sick & am tired.......rocky had the balls to put your postings but do you have the balls not to stay anonymous and show yourself instead of hiding.....now who has and who dont have balls.....real arsehole you are!!

    anwar, started the orchestra going and barisan played the same tune....and they bn won....period.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Anonymous2:18 pm

    I want to respond to what Prof Faruqi said abt the existence of a law that enables the Sultan to fire an MB. I'm not sure if that article was actually written by him. As a prof of law he must know that the constitution is supreme. Other laws are void to the extent of the inconsistency. So Perak constitution vs Interpretation act, the Perak constitution must prevail.

    frm: non-lawyer

    ReplyDelete
  39. Anonymous2:21 pm

    everybody blaming the sultan and BN.....but nobody blame the defectors...anwar started the game and BN is just doing the same so apa hal orang nak marah ni.....kentut betul.

    ReplyDelete
  40. funny that I too heard the exact same story about what Sultan Azlan did last March.

    no one made a big thing when Sultan Azlan decided rightfully in March.
    why now, right?

    ReplyDelete
  41. Anonymous2:32 pm

    I wonder why the Sultan being highly qualified in law can blatantly ignore the law, in this case not an ordinary law but the state constitution. When he became Sultan his oath is to respect the law...Another thing is we ought to revisit his decisions while on the Bench coz the latest development showed he can be swayed...

    frm: non-lawyer

    ReplyDelete
  42. Anonymous2:42 pm

    For every one malay (many are from outside Perak) who choose to demonstarate at Kuala Kangsar there a hundred more malays from perak who are grateful to Paduka Sultan for relieving Perak of the shackle of evil DAP, fronted by superpuppet Nizar.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Anonymous2:42 pm

    Dear all,
    Lanun Somalia found in Malaysia....

    BN bagai lanun rampas kerajaan Perak, tidak hormati perlembagaan negeri
    Saidah Hairan
    Sat | Feb 07, 09 | 12:39:00 pm MYT

    KUALA LUMPUR, 7 Feb (Hrkh) - Lanun adalah sejenis kumpulan manusia yang tidak mengikuti undang-undang dan mana- mana pihak yang tidak mengikuti undang-undang pada asasnya mereka adalah lanun.
    Iklan




    Rampasan kuasa yang berlaku di Perak membuktikan bahawa pimpinan Umno-BN termasuk dalam golongan lanun kerana tidak menghormati dan mengikuti Perlembagaan negeri Perak.

    Demikian menurut Naib Presiden PAS, Dato' Paduka Husam Musa ketika ditemui selepas merasmikan seminar Kebajikan Nasional anjuran Lajnah Kebajikan dan Kemasyarakatan PAS Pusat, di Taman Melewar.

    Beliau menegaskan, Umno-BN tahu bahawa mengikut perlembagaan negeri Perak perlu ada undinya tidak percaya barulah kerusi Menteri Besar kosong dan pimpinan Umno-BN boleh mengangkat sumpah.

    Katanya, mereka mengambil orang yang dituduh terlibat dengan rasuah sebagai orang yang menyokong pembentukan kerajaan (BN) sebagai tekanan dan cara yang mereka lakukan betul-betul lanun.

    "Lanun ini tidak ada hati perut dan tidak ada undang-undang dan Adun Pakatan Rakyat adalah wakil rakyat yang telah dipilih oleh rakyat, jadi kalau orang itu ada hati perut mereka tidak akan buat kerja seperti ini kerana ia melukakan perasaan rakyat," tegasnya.

    Tetapi kata beliau Umno-BN merupakan lanun tidak ada hati perut jadi mereka tidak peduli perasaan rakyat.

    Beliau turut berharap rakyat di negeri Perak terus mendesak Sultan Perak supaya membubarkan Dewan Undangan Negeri Perak (DUN) yang masih sah dikuasai Pakatan Rakyat.

    Katanya, bantahan itu perlu berterusan jika tidak Malaysia tidak mempunyai kedaulatan undang-undang dan rakyat perlu pertahankan kedaulatan undang-undang.

    "Kita mahu pertahankan kedaulatan undang-undang dan Menteri Besar, Dato' Nizar Jamaluddin adalah lambang mempertahankan kedaulatan undang-undang," jelasnya._
    *

    From
    Ketua Lanun Pangkat C4: Najis

    ReplyDelete
  44. Anonymous2:48 pm

    The constitution does not mention political parties. It just mentions that the Sultan is to appoint an MB who in his opinion is likely to have majority support. So any single party which has the most no of seats has no right to form a minority govt just because of that. Other parties can combine & outnumber the party. What the Sultan did in Mar was no big deal. It's something that's ought to be done. Anyway I didn't read abt the Sultan himself doing it. It's done by the Regent. This conduct (of not willing to personally handle the "crisis") on the part of the Sultan is suspicious or even unbecoming.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Anonymous3:04 pm

    For the 999 years Kampung Baru land it is the value of the land that made the issue. Nowdays the kg baru located at the town and it should be given as free of charge.

    .. please identified the real owner of the land. The goverment took the land from the original owner and made the detention camp a.k.a kampung baru.

    Just give back to the real owner or their son/grandson that deserved it. And it they want to sell it to the Kampung baru folks it is the owner problem and not PR or Nizar problem anymore..

    ReplyDelete
  46. Why then is he in such great haste to kick Nizar out of his office when PR is doing such a good job governing Perak with transparency?? A fresh state election may be costly but it wouldn't it be more costly to have corrupted politicians siphoning off state funds??

    ReplyDelete
  47. Anonymous3:36 pm

    Hmm..

    I fail to understand how this piece has anything to do with the situation today, as some other commenter has pointed out.

    And I fail to understand why Nizar's last drop of blood is such a big deal. After all, the non-malays have heard their blood being mentioned a lot of times too by certain BN people.

    Regards,
    Cipha

    ReplyDelete
  48. Anonymous3:48 pm

    Dear Rocky,

    As I rea some of the comments below I am more inclined to agree with you.

    2. Despite the fact that there is a coalition of parties i.e PAS, DAP & PKR but it was not made formally. An easy example of these parties contested under different flag could be given thought. Indeed, it seems that Pakatan Rakyat is yet another loose coalition.

    3. Sultan of Perak had acted in accordance to law and morality when he refused to the formation of an UMNO led government, despite being a single party with most seats in the DUN, as Tuanku t\had then yet to meet all the so-called PR party leaders.

    4. Talking about selecting a leader of a non majority party - does anyone realise that YB Nizar is not even a leader of a party having majority in the DUN? Shoud the MB be YB Ngeh? Anyway, Perak's constitution disallow a non Malay Muslim to be MB.

    5. There is no such thing like party hoping there in Perak. The two PKR and one DAP ADUNs were only declared themselves as Independents. To me there was no party hoping but a mere transformation. Therefore it would make BN having 28 seats. Three seats are never BN members but they have given their support to BN, that woul make BN a majority, in principle.

    6. There is no such provisions in the State Constitution to say about majority party in DUN. Tell me where do some blogers here get the impression that there must be a majority party.

    Citytour

    ReplyDelete
  49. Anonymous4:14 pm

    Ask to choose between Expired MB-Nizar, Anwar Ibrahim, Karpal Singh, Lim Kit Singh, Nik Aziz , Hadi Awang, I will put my best bet on Paduka Tuanku Sultan Perak.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Anonymous4:57 pm

    The PAS demonstrators in Perak were the BODOHEST people. Why are they demonstrating for DAP? Hey Melayu Bodoh, u guys kena diperbodohkan oleh DAP.

    Where are the Chinese? Indians? Kenapa you PAS people don't use yr head? Nizar is a PUPPET for DAP. How come the Chinese in Perak are given a freehold land 999 yrs man? Even in Singapore, you don't get 999 years.

    Now, DERHAKA lagi. Betul bodoh punya Melayu......

    What do the Chinese DAP give you? What do they do for the Malays of perak? Can't u see the moment they got the power, they started to distribute 'wealth' to their kind. And BODOH, to give land is to give wealth.

    DAP is racist. You PR people are just stupidheads. Now, want to sue the Sultan some more. Kurang ajar! Go and die lah!

    DAULAT TUANKU!

    ReplyDelete
  51. Anonymous6:13 pm

    u guys just don't get it eh??

    PKR,PAS,DAP dah dberi 11bulan utk cube memrintah Perak..
    tapi apa yg rakyat Melayu Perak dapat?
    tanah diberi pada org cina..
    duit dbelanja beli Camry (bile EXCO ngeri lain bwh BN nk beli kete luar suatu masa dlu dorg gk bising)
    Cina dapt mcm2 faedah..melayu?
    bangkitlah wahai MELAYU..bangun la dri lena yg panjang..

    Sultan Azlan Shah tentunye tk nk rakyatnya sengsara..
    Takkan si Najib tu nk pegi sogok pulak Sultan Azlan Shah tu..
    brp trilion die bw dlm poket letak menghadap depan mata Tuanku?
    hahaha..Sultan tu pnya harta yg tk habis dimakan smpai 7kturunan pom..

    Bayangkan keadaan kalau piliahnraya tu tjadi..DAP pasti akan letak calon die merata negeri n org yg tk reti apa ni pangkah la DAP tu..then sluruh negeri Perak jd milik DAP(PKR n PAS hny boneka).

    dan kat mana yg korg smua bljar yg Sultan tkda kuasa nk pecat MB dan exco kerajaan?Kalau gitu,tk guna la Tuanku mnjdi Sultan krana tiada fungsi.smua ni mcm lawak jnaka yg akan tcatat dlm sjarah.

    Anwar..berhentilah porak perandakan negara..
    Azizah..jgn kmaruk nk jd first lady plak..
    Nurul Izzah..malu tk kmu ada ayah sbg pengkhianat bangsa?

    ReplyDelete
  52. Anonymous9:14 pm

    The Sultan needs BN in the state. Who is paying for their daily expenses? BN. So it makes sense.

    ReplyDelete
  53. Anonymous9:16 pm

    After all the chaos and demos in Perak, I wonder why the Sultan's office has not issued any statement on this. Why the silence? Very very fishy. Must have been a very good deal, isn't it Rocky?

    ipohmali

    ReplyDelete
  54. Anonymous8:51 am

    @JAAC: I did read the article. It said something about an Act that amounts to "the power to appoint includes the power to dismiss". The Constitution states in the Eighth Schedule that "a member of the Executive Council other than the Menteri Besar shall hold office at the Ruler's pleasure [emphasis mine]": it makes an exception in the case of a Menteri Besar in that he does not hold his office "at the Ruler's pleasure" i.e. the Sultan CANNOT fire him. It is my understanding that if a law contradicts the Constitution then that law is invalid which makes whatever Prof Dr Shad Saleem Faruqi says a whole load of nothing.

    Also read this article at Malaysiakini which says 'Constitutional expert: Sultan can't sack Nizar' - note the "contitutional expert" tag. It appears that there is disagreement. This is why the matter needs to be brought to court so that the law can be tested.

    ReplyDelete
  55. Anonymous2:15 pm

    Rocky,
    You're losing respect from the masses...! tone has changed lately huh..
    -bch-

    ReplyDelete
  56. Anonymous5:13 pm

    If one look at SPR website, ther is no pakatan rakyat!

    There were only BN, DAP, PKR, PAS and Bebas.

    So the Sultan was right to want to listen to DAP, PAS & PKR instead of passing on to BN

    MM

    ReplyDelete
  57. Anonymous10:04 pm

    Apa yang gagal diceritakan pemimpin Umno negeri kepada umum adalah selain 134 kampung BARU (yang sebenarnya turut diduduki oleh kaum Melayu dan India), kerajaan negeri turut memberikan hak milik kekal kepada 349 KAMPUNG TERSUSUN yang kesemuanya diduduki oleh orang Melayu!

    Adakah keputusan memberikan hak milik kekal kepada kampung tersusun ini juga boleh dianggap sebagai "mengkhianati hak Melayu"? Lebih 100,000 hakmilik diberikan untuk kampung tersusun. The MALAYS would benefit most from the titles because they made up the MOST number of people to obtain the titles.

    Penganugerahan hak milik tanah kepada 47,000 penduduk kampung baru hanya membabitkan 3,000 ekar tanah sedangkan ketika Perak di bawah penguasaan BN, lebih banyak tanah negeri itu telah tergadai kepada orang bukan Melayu.

    Antaranya penganugerahan lebih 10,000 ekar tanah kepada MCA untuk membina kampus Universiti Tun Abdul Razak (Unitar).

    Dakwaan kononnya kerajaan negeri memberikan hak milik tanah selama 999 tahun kepada kampung baru turut dinafikan Menteri Besar, tetapi terus dicanangkan 'sebagai betul' oleh pemimpin Umno negeri.

    Dan jika penduduk kampung baru tidak layak diberikan geran hak milik untuk tapak kediaman semata-mata kerana mereka berbangsa Cina, mengapakah kerajaan BN pimpinan Umno sanggup memberi peluang kepada rakyat Singapura yang majoritinya berbangsa Cina membeli hartanah di negara ini termasuk di Wilayah Pembangunan Iskandar (WPI) yang terletak di selatan Johor - negeri paling kuat pengaruh Umno dalam dunia?

    Umno juga perlu menjelaskan beberapa isu berbangkit berhubung hak milik tanah termasuk penganugerahan puluhan ribu hektar tanah kepada taikun-taikun Cina oleh kerajaan BN pimpinan Umno antaranya Vincent Tan dan Lim Goh Tong.

    Umno juga tidak harus melupakan nasib malang yang menimpa orang Melayu di Kerpan, Kedah; Pantai Kundor dan Pantai Tanah Merah, Melaka dan beberapa negeri lain yang dihalau keluar daripada tanah tumpah darah mereka semata-mata untuk memberi laluan kepada projek-projek mega kerajaan BN.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Anonymous10:14 pm

    Ada beberapa komen yang menyebut mengenai "tanah diberi kepada Cina di Perak".

    Ini sebenarnya ialah kerja propaganda UMNO/BN yang hanya menimbulkan 'mengapa Cina dapat tanah'. Sungguh racist.

    Apa yang sengaja ditutup dari pengetahuan umum ialah, Orang Melayu dapat lebih banyak tanah dari kaum2 lain.

    Pemberian titles tanah itu ialah untuk Kg Tersusun (kira kira 102,000 titles). Kampung tersusun ini dihuni oleh orang Melayu. Dari segi keluasannya pula lebih besar.

    Kampung Cina pula dihuni oleh majoriti Cina, sedikit Melayu dan India. Bilangan titles ialah 47,000. Dari segi keluasan, jauh lebih kecil dari keluasan tanah kg tersusun.

    Jelas isu ini telah diputarbelit oleh media massa UMNO/BN manakala jentera penerangan Pakatan Rakyat pula telah gagal menerangkan isu ini yang dikira akan disambut baik sebenarnya oleh orang Melayu Perak jika mereka faham keadaanya sebenarnya.

    mat Ali, KK

    ReplyDelete
  59. Anonymous11:34 pm

    Rocky,

    Untuk Mat Ali dari Kampung Baru,
    mesej yg awak tulis ni kalau benar amat lah menyedihkan, kiranya benar perkara ni berlaku maknanya pihak BA pun tak cukup smart.

    Kalau pun tak dapat menceritakan hal kebenaran ini dalam mass media, harap dapat di gunakan kaedah moden aka melalui internet. Bukankah ada peluang utk directly explain kpd umum. Kenapa baru sekarang nak explain? Bukankah ada harakah, dan macam2 akhbar? Bukan ke org BA pandai guna blog? Mana pernah blog2 BA di blocked?

    Minta maaf la, tapi you are not convincing enough.

    Aku yg bosan

    ReplyDelete
  60. Anonymous2:12 pm

    Salam...
    Takkan bila keputusan Sultan tidak memihak kepada PR maka Sultan dikatakan di'beli' oleh BN? Padahal keputusan Sultan adalah adil untuk semua, bukan berpihak pada mana parti...

    ReplyDelete
  61. I agree with you Rocky..

    By the end of the day PR is not a Party.. By the consitution it says that party with the confidence of majority..
    so the sultan make the right decision by appointing DAP,PKR & PAS..

    but when it turn upside down on them PR.. they tremble & riot ..

    p/s: so shamefull & disrespect..
    there goes Nizar as last MB (i dont think he will be re-elected again on if PR wins the next election)

    ReplyDelete