KESETIAAN KEPADA RAJA DAN NEGARA
- the second pillar of our Rukunegara
Is this the Ketuanan Rakyat that we've been promised?
The right to give the Sultan your middle finger and pelt his prince's official car when you don't agree with them. Is that your idea of Ketuanan Rakyat? The right to accuse the HRH of "failing in thinking as a Ruler of his subjects"? [Who the duck is K. Kabilan to pass that kind of judgment on a Sultan, anyway? Read here]. Does Ketuanan Rakyat mean that you leave it to the Sultan to decide but defy him if his decision goes against you? And profess "Daulat Tuanku" only if you think you can use the Sultan to fight for your political battles?
This is no Ketuanan Rakyat.
This is what I'd call Ketuanan Pakatan Rakyat. You are either with them or against them!
I am placing the Daulat Tuanku logo up there for an indefinite period. I'm asking you to do so, if you have a blog or on your Facebook, etc. It's not in support of any political party; it's about preserving an Institution that is part and parcel of the Rakyat and the Negara.
If Karpal or Nizar or Anwar or Hadi want to drag the Sultan to Court to defend what you think is the right of your political party, that's their right so go ahead. I only ask for one thing: Biar beradab, jangan biadap dan tak payah derhaka.
And remind ourselves of the nuances: it's not just Kesetiaan Kepada Raja; it's Kesetiaan Kepada Raja dan Negara.
p.s And I hope no one resorts to hanging the Perak flag or the portrait of HRH Sultan Azlan Shah upside down to counter this blog campaignMust read:
1. Ketuanan Rakyat Anwar Ibrahim by Zakhir
2. Pas kena kuda lagi by Shamsul
3. Perak Politics: Reality of Realpolitik by A Voice
4. Despicable Act! by Ong Chong Tek @ DSAI's
5. Implikasi Tumbangnya Kerajaan PR Perak by A. Kadir Jasin
6. Puisi untuk Sultan by Ron
7. Perak, a Constitutional Crisis by Malik Imtiaz
8. Sultan can Dismiss MB @ mySinChew
Updates 1.40am 8/2
Early support for this campaign:
An act of Treason by Barking Magpie
Nizar sacked himself (Stop blaiming the Sultan) by Shamsul Yunus
Jangan Derhaka by Ibrahim Tiger
Keep Tuanku out of Politics by Apanama
Daulat Tuanku by Hard T
Mad deposed MB ... by Big Dog
Rizal Hashim
Demi Negara
More support ...
This Finger is For You by Zainal A. Kasim
Retorik Pakatan Rakyat by Fosgate [Bonus: An old video on "The 31 Defectors"]
Kesetiaan Kepada Raja Dan Negara by Kembara Politik
A Piece of My Mind by Wei Liang Goh
Wassapening by Ajimsam
Daulat Tuanku [translated into 5 languages] by PPC
CTanggang by Si Tanggang
Sinatra Z - Dua Sen Saya by Sinatra Z
Budak Raban by DNL
Khalifah yang tak Berakal by Kalam Jauhari
Juruterer Malaya
Daulat Tuanku by Cucu Tok Selampit
Mat Cendana's Blog Review
Bujai's Just Read!
Jebat Must Die's The Crybabies of Pakatan Rakyat
Pesanan Untuk Nizar by Parpukari
Not supporting the campaign but read you must:
What more to say? by RPK
salam,
ReplyDeletesedih hati bila melihat bangsa Melayu berkelakuan biadap begini.
taksub dengan ideologi sendiri hingga lupa menjaga pekerti sendiri,hatta d depan pemerintah yang kita hormati..kita mudah lupa.. dulu bila pilihan sehati dengannya kita daulati..tapi bila sebaliknya sewenangnya kita derhakai...
Bila BN hilang kuasa seAmannya kuasa mereka serahkan,kenapa bila tiba giliran kita perlu berbaring dijalanan?kononya perhimpunan AMAN? Bila keadaan diluar kawalan,emosi menguasai perbuatan..habis harta dirosakkan.kayu dan batu dilontarkan kepada mereka yang ditugaskan..dan kenapa bila keadaaan diluar kawalan.penjaga keamanan yang disalahkan?
Kanak-kanak dan wanita yang dibentengkan, kononya mencari keadilan?
Lihatlah saudaraku..saudara sebangsaku ...seagamaku..
tolehlah dikiri kananmu..
Tarikh keramat itu..siapakah yang menjadi hero bacul?
menderhaka kepada Raja?
kaum lain bertepuk tangan..
melihat Melayu semakin kurang ajar..
Politik rentak mereka telah kita belajar..
Biadap pada pemerintah,
Tuih!Mukanya sanggup kamu ludah.
Renunglah kaumku..bangsaku..
Adakah kaum lain menjengok muka.
biarkan disembur gas pemedih mata?
dibalun ..diheret atas nama murka..
Kemana mereka semua..
bersembunyi disebalik tembok harta?
Ditolaknya kamu kehadapan biar tercedera?
Hahahaha riuhnya mereka bergelak ketawa,
Dengan menteri baru mereka bermuka-muka.
Sebab dah nampak rezeki yang luas terbuka..
Kitaaaa..
hanya sibuk berpolitik saja..
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteLeave your ivory tower (or UMNO tower) and walk the streets of Ipoh for a day or two. Throw Kuala Kangsar and Taiping in as well if you have the time.
Speak to the people in the coffee shop...ask what do they think of these developments? You will be enlightened. I have been enlightened. People who were politically indifferent have suddenly awoken to this day light robbery. Come and confirm this yourself.
In KK, ask why women in tudung were out in force protesting? Why were a good number of protestors old folks? Ask why were the majority of the protestors Malay? Analyse the crowd (Malaysiakini has footage), you will notice they aren't your typical urban rent a mob which you find in KL. These were rural folks from the kampong.
Lastly, to remind us about "Natang-Gate"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oYPKd1v5m0I
Mulder
Hi Rocky, its Cheah here.
ReplyDeletehttp://nocturnal-mind.blogspot.com/2009/02/almost-exact-two-months-before-day.html
Hi Rocky,
ReplyDelete@Fakatan Commentators,
Stop wanking here.
You are not going to change the BN's supporters mind nor are you going to strenghthen your cause.
And stop asking RPK or Anwar to "Do Dis or Do Dat".
Take you Camry or Bicycle and go seek and audience with the Sultan and state your case YOURSELF.
Be a Rakyat and don't Fakatan yourself further.
RakyatFakatanHarapRakyatLainBuatKerja.
Rocky, try ask the Pakatan Rakyat Members What is Rukun Negara and How many are there. I bet most of them will not able to answer it otherwise they will not act like a dog that bite the hand of the man who feed it!.PAS (Parti Auta Selama lama nya), DAP (Dunia aku pegang) and PKR (Pemerintah Kerajaan Kera) how many are there?Bro Anwar, Ish Nizar,Nikky Aziz and LKS and sons should be held responsible for not able to control and displin theiw own people. Action should be taken against them for not using their gifted brains. It seems anything favor them are ok otherwise its sucks.The Malays who demonstrate and those who show off by lying on the road,shame on you for being a CLOWN yes A CLOWN and thanks for the comedy!. Havent you learned anything from history!. Doesnt history teaches you that Most Empayars falls not because of the enemy, it falls becasue of clowns like you guys. Behave yourself doesnt your mama teaches you ANYTHING!. SHAME OF YOU MALAYS FOR DISFIGURING MALAYS REPUTATION!. PAS should be thankfull for the takeover otherwise more 999 years land will be given to the chinese. I not jealous but be reasonable 99 years are common but 999 years only the likes of NIZAR aka PAS AKA DAP will do it for the sake of their survival and not for the sake of the Perakians!. Early merdekas days has thought us about monopoly and yes like what DR M always says 'MELAYU MUDAH LUPA' not just lupa but also 'MELAYU MUDAH LUPD DIRI!. No wonder many histeria cases are confine to Malays comunity and blame it on the GHOST!.Perak Malays and the rest of the Malaysian malays should realise by now the mistake by giving our votes to DAP, PAS , PKR yes we did a big mistakes and its all because of BN (Beruk Negara) goons(MCA/MIC/GERAKAN/UMNO dll) ARROGENTS and being naive to the needs of the people.Zambry, please do the right thing and not the thing right by disolving the State assemby and return it to the people cause this time around you will be suprised the majority of seats you'll get. Say bye bye to PR (Pakatan Rubbish). Rocky glad that now you reallise what the meaning of 'VOTE WISELY' and BN it time to kick out those 'beruks'you are keeping hey it not woth man!
ReplyDeleteAt the beginning it's ok to jump because of kehendak rakyat. Even Nizar & Nik Aziz also said its a wise move to jump from UMNO. When everything backfire suddenly it become, jumping is wrong, immoral, we should listen to what people really want n the list keep on growing...
ReplyDeleteFollower of the ONE who kept on saying "we have the numbers and it growing by hour", please wake up.
To those who keep on saying so such thing as Raja and Raja is important in the 21st century and stuff, do your a small favour: please migrate yourself to the nearest republic that willing to accept you A.S.A.P.
DAULAT TUANKU
I used to have great respect for you rocky.But ever since u rant about how airasia CEO is such a great guy and how mahathir is still the man, face it dude.U had lost it.Now with your view on perak, you are way beyond the point of no return.I thought you are a fair open guy but guess you are just one of those berfikiran sempit ppl out there.....Mr Justice
ReplyDeleteOne more thing on this PAS and PKR Malays and sometime UMNO'S. Hey dont simply used ALLAH or Screaming ALLAH HU AKHBAR to justify your point or struggles. This is not PALESTIN neither am IRAQ or Afghan.This is nothing to do with defending ISLAM you fools!.
ReplyDeleteMerafak Sembah Menjunjung Kasih Tuanku,
ReplyDeleteDidalam penggulungan perintah Tuanku didalam kes
PENGARAH TANAH DAN GALIAN, WILAYAH PERSEKUTUAN V. SRI LEMPAH ENTERPRISE SDN BHD [CIVIL APPEAL NO. 94 OF 1978]
dan masih terpakai akan precedent tersebut hingga kini.
Ampun Tuanku,adapun tiada kesangsian akan taat setia patek yang hamba dina ini megutip akan inti pati hujah Tuanku yang amat-amat bernas itu.
'...unfettered discretion is a contradiction in terms...Every legal power must have legal limits,otherwise there is dictatorship...'
Ampun Tuanku,kurang lebih begitulah kutipan daripada pengulunggan penghakiman Tuanku yang penoh berhemah lagi bijaksana.
Adapun hamba rakyat menayong kasih,setia janji kesetiaan yang tidak berbelah bagi terhadap Tuanku Paduka Sri.
Ampun Tuanku.
Menjunjung Kasih Tuanku.
Bro
ReplyDeleteSAYA RASA SEDIH KENAPALAH DI ERA 21CENTURY NI PUN ORANG MELAYU MASIH LAGI KENA JAJAH PEMIKIRANNYA DAN EMOSINYA OLEH BANGSA LAIN?PATUTLAH BANGSA LAIN KATA MELAYU BODOH.TENGOK APA YANG BERLAKU SEKARANG DI PERAK,TIDAK KAH ORANG MELAYU BODOH??BANGSA CINA INDIA DAN DUA ORANG MELAYU(TERDESAK=GILA KUASA) YANG BERTOPENGKAN ISLAM DAN SUARA RAKYAT TU ACAH-ACAH,PROVOK-PROVOK,YANG SORANG LAGI TU PUN DENGAN GAYA BODOHNYA,MENGIKUT AJE APA YANG DI ARAH.YANG TUKANG ACAH TU SELAMAT,TAPI YANG TUKANG IKUT TU BODOH,MENANGGUNG RISIKO AIB DAN GELAP MASA DEPAN KERANA HILANG MARUAH DAN ROSAK PERSONALITINYA DI MATA RAKYAT.TAPI PADANLAH DENGAN BODOHNYA TU....!
Excerpt taken from Malaysian Insider;
ReplyDeleteKUALA LUMPUR, Dec 1 - Opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim is reaching out to Malaysia's powerful sultans in his latest strategy to try to wrest power from the government.
His wife, Dr Wan Azizah Ismail, the nominal president of Anwar's Keadilan party, has offered to restore their powers if the opposition seizes power. "We are willing to return royal immunity and power to veto laws in the spirit of constitutional monarchy," she said.
__________________________________
Just to show you what bunch of BIGOTS you have down there in Pakatan Rakyat. A party that thrives on empathizing on the rakyat's woes merely for the sake of achieving their political ambitions. That is just pure evil.
The recent developments shows that PR won't stop at any cause, not the Sultan, not even in the interest of the State or Rakyat.
Their unwillingness to rise above politics and to concede defeat in the game (Hop-Scotch) that they had fervently initiated shows that they do not have an ounce of the rakyat's plight in their mind.
PR followers, why not question why Anwar accepted Bota MP into PKR despite reservations made publicly about hopping by their component parties. Clearly it was bad judgement on his side that had led PR to this circumstances.
When Anwar declared 916, all of you went for it, waiting for Anwar to be sworn in as PM, even to the extent of referring to him as PM In Waiting.
As the leader of PR, Anwar should be made to be held accountable by PR for this turn of events. I don't see that happening and i don't think it will...
To the Rakyat, regardless of your political inclinations, do be more objective and critically assess the leaders which you seem to have place in the highest esteem. Blind loyalty derive purely from your own perception is foolish.
Do not abuse the freedom you have in voicing your opinion, Sdr. Rocky is entitled to voice his opinion, either you agree or disagree, is up to you. There is no need to be hurling insults and derogatory remarks.
No doubt, Sultan Azaln Shah is a highly respected sultan unlike others.
ReplyDeleteAs a good sultan, he should not accept political defectors' new promise in supporting BN.
These defectors were "angkat sumpah" before him at 11 months ago. How can Sultan Azlan Shah so forgetful about this?
What were happen if these defectors change their minds again?
I like Karpal Singh condemned Anwar and his gangs for taking power through defection.
The political correct way is to dissolve state assembly and call a snap election.
I have called up a campaign against Perak new state government in internet. I will do the same against pakatan rakyat if they wrist power with same dirty trick.
Feel free to download these banners and put in your website or blog.
http://www.nkkhoo.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/the-rakyats-say-no-to-zambry-250.jpg
Regards,
www.nkkhoo.com
Daulat Tuanku..
ReplyDeleteMr Ahiruddin Atan @ Rocky.
ReplyDeleteAntara ciri-ciri seorang Sultan yang berdaulat, I repeat, berdaulat, ia lah KARAMAH yang ada pada dirinya. Dia adalah pelindung dan pembela kepada rakyatnya. Menimbang yang mana betul dan yang mana bathil.
Seorang Sultan yang punya KARAMAH ialah seorang Sultan yang taat kepada agama anutannya, Islam.
Pastinya dia mempunyai kelebihan atau sedikit keajaiban kerana KARAMAHnya itu.
"Apabila Sultan Abdul Hamid (Kedah) bertanya kepada jurutera jambatan di Alor Star apoakah jambatan itu kukuh? Ya, jawab jurutera itu sedikit sombong.
"Baiklah, beta nak uji kuat kah atau tidak. Lalu dipijak baginda sebelah kaki dijambatan yang hendak diresmikan itu. Senget sampai hari ini.
Orang Kedah boleh sahkan cerita ini.
Sultan Abdul Hamid, tinggi KARAMAHnya, alim dan warak orangnya.
Berapa orang Sultan hari ini yang punya karamah?
Sultan-sultan hari ini tidak lebih seperti raja-raja kenangan seperti Albert of Monaco. Raja yang tak bernegeri.
Akhirnya saya ingin bertanya, susah sangatkah bagi Baginda Azlan Shah untuk meminta supaya dibuat undian tidak percaya atau kaedah lain yang lebih berperlembagaan.
Saya tidak percaya apa yang telah berlaku ini lantaran tingginya hormat saya pada Azlan Shah, The King of Perak.
Kecualilah jika ada Udang Sebalik Mee - kisah Gamuda dan lain-lain.Atau,
Kecualilah, dia ini tiada KARAMAH.
HEY ROCKY, NOT TOO LONG AGO YOUR MASTER CALLED YOUR KING 'NATANG...
ReplyDeleteWE DIDN'T SEE U COME OUT AND DEFEND HIS DIGNITY.
SO WHY NOW? SEEMS THAT YOUR AGENDA CLEARLY WRITTEN ALL OVER YOUR BLOG...
AND YOU OK FOR NAJID TO SEIZE THE STATE & TO HELL WITH THE PERAKIAN RIGHTS, RIGHT? JUST LIKE THE JEWS SAY, TO HELL WITH THE GAZAN RIGHTS?
COME ON, U USED TO BE APOLITICAL, WHY THE SUDDEN U-TURN.
Yeah? Why Rocky. Recently you cross swords with Harris Ibrahim.
By the way I respect your right of speech ang others too.
Rocky, kalau menulis kerana wang, saya juga pernah jadi penulis upahan, banyaklah dapat wang, ratusan ribu, tapi percayalah, kalau tak berkat tak jadi apa. Saya tak juga kaya.
Dear all,
ReplyDeleteDon't bash Rocky, to err is human also and so is Rocky. To do what is right and sometimes be humble.
How can you say Rocky defending Dr.M, remember during Dr.M era, even the Monarchy system also want to be abolish by Dr.M. Still remember the crisis.
People make all sorts of things and some people change idea. But in inherently I assume all we want is goodness, fairness and humility.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_Malaysian_constitutional_crisis
From,
Study History
So many sour grapes here.. Puppet Nizar has not approved these clowns' projects yet. Muahahahahahaha
ReplyDeleteKesiannnnnnn ngeh ngeh ngeh. Wait another 4 years. Get a job boys and girls.
*voter*
PAS - for ADUN
BN - for Parlimen
F*CK DAP & PKR
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletePenyapujagat menulis:
ReplyDeleteRocky, kalau menulis kerana wang, saya juga pernah jadi penulis upahan, banyaklah dapat wang, ratusan ribu, tapi percayalah, kalau tak berkat tak jadi apa. Saya tak juga kaya.
1:57 AM
------------------------------------
Penyapujagat!
Baguslah awak dah insaf. Jadi penulis upahan tu memang jijik. Dan kalau bayaran yang awak terima sampai ratusan ribu, dah tentu awak tulis yang bukan2, yang karut2, yang kotor2 ...
Jadi, baguslah awak dah insaf dan taubat, Penyapujagat.
Saya ni melawan arus. Memang guru2 saya akar begitu. Dan kalau berenang melawan arus tu, kadang2 kita terhuyung kekiri sikit, kadangkala kita terhayang kekanan sikit .. tapi tetap melawan arus.
Penulis upahan mana ada lawan arus ... sebagai ex-penulis upahan, Penyapujagat, awak tentu lebih maklum.
Terimakasih.
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteHave you ever picked up a copy of our federal constitution and try reading it? Do you have the slightest idea of what Parliamentary Democracy means?
Yes, it is paramount for the rakyat to respect and honour our King and Sultans. But what they have done is nothing less than tearing apart the tenets of our constitution. I have always respected the Perak Sultan for what he is. With due respect, but after this episode, I need to search for a good reason to continue doing this.
But if I do hear the sultan and the prince speak again about neutrality, democracy, rule of law or justice, I might as well roll over and laugh than to swallow any bit of their hypocrisies.
And don't bring in the Ketuanan Rakyat slogan in these context. Ketuanan Rakyat is slogan meant to defeat UMNO's outdated "Ketuanan Melayu" and certainly not to overshadow the sentence "Kesetiaan Kepada Raja & Negara" in our rukun negara.
Balan
I just want to tell bro Rocky one thing, Rukun Negara is not a law, neither a part of constitution.
ReplyDeleteAs for me as a Perakian, I always respect my HRH Sultan. But Sultan is also a human, he can make mistake.
Daulat Tuanku!
FEB 7 — Historically, before the existence of Malaysia, the Malay states fell into the hands of the imperialists due to greed and power. It was about the power struggle amongst the royalty which eventually led to the colonisation of the states.
ReplyDeletePre-Merdeka, with the emergence of the insurgencies by the left, a "deal" was struck among the capitalists, the royalty, the royalists and the imperialists with the sole purpose of maintaining and guarding "their" positions and influence in Malaya. The collateral outcome of the "deal" was the independence of Malaya. It was a decision motivated by the need to protect and safeguard the vested interests of these actors. It was not about the rakyat. It has never been!
Fast forward 52 years after independence, we see how the same actors have again colluded to stage a modern day "coup" in the state of Perak. Again, this was not done in the interests of the rakyat. Those who have heard about the true colours and the personality/ies of the various decision-maker(s) will not be surprised by the recent decision(s).
Ultimately, one important question that needs to be answered is "what's in it for me?". That was the question that Pakatan Rakyat could not answer.
No doubt there are several legal and moral issues that have arisen from the Perak fiasco. But the real issue that irks the rakyat is the fact that the capitalists and the royalty have robbed the state government from the rakyat.
Regarding the legality of the Sultan's decision to call for the resignation of the menteri besar, I am prepared to say that the decision is wrong in law. Based on the Perak Constitution, the MB does not hold office at the pleasure of the Sultan.
The only way the MB goes is by way of a no-confidence motion in the State Legislative Assembly. The Sultan cannot just ask MB to vacate his office.
Article 16(6) of the Perak Constitution states that:
If the Menteri Besar ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Legislative Assembly, then, unless at his request His Royal Highness dissolves the Legislative Assembly, he shall tender the resignation of the Executive Council.
The question then is: who decides whether the MB ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the State Legislative Assembly? Should it be the Sultan or the State Legislative Assembly? How and where should such issues be decided?
The answers to these questions are obvious. Matters of grave importance that affect the interests of the state should be decided in the hall of the State Legislative Assembly, NOT along the corridors or halls of the palace.
The next question then is: who holds the majority at the State Legislative Assembly?
To answer this question, one must first ascertain the status of the three so-called "independent" members who have tendered their resignations. There is a dispute in relation to their status as members of the State Legislative Assembly. Their views therefore should not be taken into account until their status have been definitely resolved.
Against this background, how can anyone say that the Barisan Nasional commands the majority?
Some have replied saying that since the Election Commission did not recognise the resignation letters of the three "independent" members, therefore they are still members of the State Legislative Assembly.
This throws up the further question whether the EC has the power and jurisdiction to adjudicate on the status of the resignations.
From the legal perspective, the EC has exceeded its jurisdiction. There is nothing under the Election Commission Act 1957 and the Elections Act 1958 that confers power to the EC to adjudicate on such matters. Consequently, the EC's decision on this matter is ultra vires and is of no effect. Unless the decision by the speaker to declare the seats vacant is set aside or overturned by a court of law, the EC must accept the decision of the speaker. However, we have witnessed how the EC has facilitated the "coup" by disregarding the speaker's decision.
Leaving aside the legal questions — on desirability — in view that the current political scenario in Perak is fragile and uncertain, coupled with the fact that there is no guarantee there will not be any further and sudden defections that may affect the composition of the State Legislative Assembly, the best decision to make is to have dissolved the State Legislative Assembly.
Unfortunately, wisdom may not be the virtue of some.
Who will benefit from this episode? The "decision-makers"? Those who "orchestrated" the situation?
Unless the question of "what's in it for me?" is fully answered, then no one will receive the truth.
The state of Perak was robbed by the capitalists and the monarchy.
The fate of the state should not lie in the hands of allegedly corrupted politicians and a Sultan. It should be in the hands of the rakyat! Let the people of Perak decide the fate of their state through fresh elections.
For the record, I am not a monarchist or a royalist. I have little admiration for slogans such as "Daulat Tuanku" and the related "mumbo-jumbo". Some may say that this article and the fact that I am doubting the wisdom of the Sultan of Perak may be construed as an act of "derhaka" (disloyalty). As far as I am concerned the issue of "menderhaka" does not arise.
And my reply is "derhaka terhadap siapa?" Can I "derhaka" towards an institution that I don't believe in? Can I "derhaka" towards an institution that ignores the will of the rakyat?
It is apt for us to be reminded of what Hang Jebat once said:
"Jangan! Jangan sembah aku. Aku bukan gila disembah. Aku bukan sebagai Sultan Melaka yang mengagung-agungkan pangkat dan kebesarannya. Aku Jebat, rakyat biasa. Pangkat aku untuk kepentingan rakyat. Bergerak aku untuk membuat jasa kepada rakyat, dan aku rela mati untuk rakyat.. kerana aku mahu keadilan, keadilan. Keadilan!"
The time is ripe for a revolution.
So are you game?
Salam revolusi! — www.loyarburok.com
Remembered Rakyat is the one who paid for the salary of PM,DPM and the rest.
ReplyDeleteRemembered, rakyat is the one who run the country, to build your house, to sell food and etc.
Without rakyat, there is no country. Got it?
Only god and my parents are above me as they guide and take care of me. The rest are just human being living on the earth.
I dont want to said whether the Sultan decision is right or wrong, but at least, give us the reason why the option is selected vs the majority people who want to have a fresh election .. .
As now, let the court decide...
As for my opinion,If the decision is going 4 election, all this issues will not arise as people can show the anger through the ballot box but now..we all stuck here wasting time,wasting money and condemn each other and just see how the people rob the states and we cant do anything in democractic ways...
No mater what is the outcome, we have lost our democracy .. people rights can be easily taken away by back door ...
10Q from Anakperak
Wow have to support Sultan 100%... any less is equal to derhaka, have to strip title la, die la, this and that...
ReplyDeleteBut weird... UMNO can defy ALLAH and commit in rasuah, adultery ...
confusing...
RUKUN NEGARA, RUKUN NEGARA, NOW YOU REMEMBER TO BRING IN THE SUBJECT TO SUBSTANTIATE YOUR VIEW POINTS, BUT AREN'T YOU FORGETTING, THE RUKUN UMNOBN THAT ALL OF US ARE SUPPOSE TO ABIDE. SO MUCH SO RUKUN NEGARA IS IN THE BOOKS,WHILE RUKUN UMNOBN IS IN OUR MIND SETS.
ReplyDeleteRukunIman
What kind of haprak spinning is this? Remember the UMNO natang thingy? Where were u Rocky that time around?
ReplyDeleteWhatever happened to "Keluhuran Perlembagaan"?
STEPHEN KALONG NINGKAN V. TUN ABANG HAJI OPENG AND TAWI SLI
Read all about it, Bapa borek anak rintik
Jangan sebab kau nak menang bicara kes kau tak lama lagi kau cuba ampu sana ampu sini.
ReplyDeleteHipokrit namanya.
Syahril
Bro,
ReplyDeleteIt is a joke that some people still defend the Sultan's decision and blame what happen squarely on PR.
The matter is as simple as 1+1=2. There is no two ways about it
A FAILED state is a state losing its ability to govern and exercise authority. Text-book examples include Sudan, Somalia, Zimbabwe, Iraq and Afghanistan, countries that we would never compare Malaysia to.
ReplyDeleteThe Fund for Peace, a US think tank, listed 12 indicators of state vulnerability.
Unfortunately, one of the state-vulnerability indicators, "criminalisation and/or delegitimisation of the state", is now emerging in the state of Perak. The resistance by certain elites to political representation, accountability and transparency, has led to widespread loss of popular confidence in the state's institutions and processes.
If police violence and political persecution are inflicted there on citizens defending democracy, then another indicator of state failure, "widespread violation of human rights", sets in.
Technically, Perak will never be a failed state because it is part of the federation of Malaysia and not a sovereign state. However, that is no comfort so long as there is a part of the Malaysian federal state that has failed.
This situation should not have happened in the first place. This year is not only the silver jubilee of Sultan Azlan Shah's reign, but also the golden jubilee of elected state government in Malaysia's second-oldest sultanate.
Regime change
Datuk Dr Zambry Abdul Kadir,
from BN, is the new Perak MB
(source: psuk-majlis.perak.gov.my)
As of 3.30pm on 6 Feb 2009, Perak now technically has two menteris besar — one democratically-elected, the other installed by the Barisan Nasional (BN) after claiming victory by defections.
An important principle to understand during such a political confrontation is that while it was the Sultan's prerogative to dissolve the legislature, this prerogative does not mean that the decision lies in his hands alone.
The royal prerogative is supposed to be a part of the larger constitutional check-and-balance mechanism between the executive and legislative in parliamentary democracies. The legislature, namely opposition members and government backbenchers, may bring down the government through no-confidence votes. In return, the government may seek dissolution of the legislature so that both sides face the judgment of voters.
The royal consent, or presidential/gubernatorial consent in republics, is merely supposed to prevent the chief executive from abusing this position. In other words, the discretion need not be exercised by the head of state — in Perak's case, the Sultan — when there is no abuse by the head of the government — the menteri besar.
Istana Iskandariah in Kuala Kangsar (© Pedro Plassen Lopes / flickr)
And who could be more authoritative in this matter than the former Lord President-turned-Ruler, Sultan Azlan Shah?
In his 2004 book Constitutional Monarchy, Rule of Law and Good Governance, the learned Sultan expressed his view categorically:
"Under normal circumstances, it is taken for granted that the Yang diPertuan Agong would not withhold his consent to a request for the dissolution of Parliament. His role is purely formal." (Emphasis mine).
Power to hire, not fire
Another principle to understand during the current public confusion is this: a menteri besar can only be removed by a vote of no-confidence in the assembly. The Ruler has only the power to hire but not to fire.
Not unlike what Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak has done in Perak in 2009, Prime Minister Tunku Abdul Rahman orchestrated a revolt of Sarawak lawmakers against the outspoken Iban Chief Minister Datuk Stephen Kalong Ningkan in 1966.
Tunku Abdul Rahman
(public domain / wikipedia)
When the Sarawak state governor showed him a top-secret letter of no-confidence issued by 21 out of 42 legislators and asked Ningkan to resign, the chief minister refused. Ningkan said the letters were not tantamount to a vote of no-confidence in the state legislative assembly.
He was sacked by the governor but eventually reinstated by the Borneo High Court, which saw the necessity of a formal vote of no confidence.
In his judgement, Harley A-G OCJ ruled that the governor can only dismiss the chief minister when both these conditions are satisfied:
"(a) The chief minister has lost the confidence of the House, and
"(b) The chief minister has refused to resign and failed to advise a dissolution."
The principles about a no-confidence vote and royal consent are very much the core of parliamentary democracy and constitutional monarchy. Violating them is not merely changing the government of the day, it is changing the very political system we are in.
It then becomes regime change, not a mere government change.
Abusing Nizar for sticking to his guns will not do, for this is the exact circumstance the mechanism of dissolution is designed for.
And if the political system is changed via extra-constitutional means, it is effectively a coup against the current constitutional setting.
Crisis-turned-coup
Flowing from the principles discussed above, these are the facts:
1. Until and unless Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin is removed by a no-confidence vote or resigns of his own accord, he is the rightful and only menteri besar of Perak Darul Ridzuan. His executive council the only rightful government as per Article 16 of the State Constitution of Perak. This point has been categorically stated by the highly respected prince Tan Sri Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah.
2. Any act to vacate the office of menteri besar and the executive council, and any advice to that effect is extra-constitutional.
3. Even if sworn in, the new menteri besar and the new executive council are illegitimate.
All actions by all the actors have now become constitutionally significant, either for or against the highest law of the state.
Nizar and his executive council's attempt to carry out their business as usual is therefore the most patriotic and loyalist act in defending the state constitution, and by extension, parliamentary democracy and constitutional monarchy.
The Parliamentary Opposition Leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim is right that this is not a collision against the palace.
Nizar is being loyal to the rule of law
(© hussein / wikipedia)
On the contrary, Nizar will go down in history as a defender of parliamentary democracy and constitutional monarchy in the 481-year-old Sultanate of Perak, politically one of the most developed states since the 1950s. He is being loyal to the political system, to the rule of law.
The subjects of Perak and citizens of Malaysia who choose to stand by the loyal menteri besar are similarly upholding rule of law and the political system.
In 1984, the year that Sultan Azlan Shah succeeded the Perak throne, he aptly defined the rule of law when delivering the 11th Tunku Abdul Rahman lecture in November:
"The rule of law means literally what it says: The rule of the law.
"Taken in its broadest sense this means that people should obey the law and be ruled by it.
"But in political and legal theory it has come to be read in a narrow sense, that the government shall be ruled by law and be subject to it.
"The ideal of the Rule of Law in this sense is often expressed by the phrase 'government by law and not by man'."
The Sultan's refusal to dissolve the state legislative assembly upon request by the menteri besar was controversial. When the Sultan instructed the menteri besar to resign, the controversy became a constitutional crisis. But when the Sultan swore in the BN-installed menteri besar, he effectively conjured a new government to parallel the existing, democratically-elected one. This effectively turned the crisis into a "coup".
Pushing the constitutional crisis into a constitutional coup is disastrous both politically and economically.
(corrected) The last of such coups happened in Sabah in April 1985, half a year after Sultan Azlan Shah's speech. At that time, Datuk Seri Joseph Pairin Kitingan's Parti Bersatu Sabah won a slim majority. But in a dramatic development following the counting of votes, a delegation headed by Tun Mustapha Harun of the United Sabah National Organisation went to governor Tun Mohamed Adnan's official residence in the early hours of 22 April and got Adnan to swear Mustapha in as chief minister. Later the same morning, Adnan revoked the appointment and then swore in Pairin as chief minister due to huge public pressure.
The only democratic way out of this mess now is for the Pakatan Rakyat to challenge the legality of the BN government in court. The courts are the last resort to save democracy in Perak.
Ipoh, the next Bangkok
A growing crisis will not only reduce stable Perak in 2009 to a chaotic Sabah of 1985, but may also push Malaysia to become another Thailand.
The Government House in Bangkok during the siege by anti-government demonstrantors , August 2008 (© Craig Martell / flickr)
Constitutional crisis is costly. These are Thailand's estimated and expected losses from its 2008 crisis: a damage of USD8 billion in the entire economy in 2008; a 9% drop in tourist arrivals from 2008 to 2009; and possibly one million job cuts in the tourism industry in 2009.
A fresh poll will channel political passions into positive competition. So, why must we risk Ipoh becoming a Little Bangkok? Some may prefer a BN state government, but why at all costs? Why not just call for snap elections?
It's time for Sultan Azlan Shah's good sense from 1984 to prevail: "Government by law, not by man."
http://www.thenutgraph.com/perak-must-not-fail
Noksokmo said...
ReplyDeleteIt comes clear to me now that Mr. Rocky's Bru is just pretending to be a fair blogger/journalist.
Please stop hiding behind YM Sultan and the Perak's flag. It is not YM Sultan agenda, it is BN agenda, period.
The real issue to be discuss here is the status of that 3 frogs.
Rocky Bru orang UMNO ke???? I thought he voted for Keadilan last year.
ReplyDeleteWhat i'm saying here, his writing sometime favoured to BN but he is trying to be fair.This is how journalist mind work
Bye bye 'TO FLY WHEN I CAN FLY'
ReplyDeleteHave a nice life.
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteNever been a fan of the monarchy. Since the constitution says "kesetiaan kepada raja & negara", what to do...just had to keep my mouth shut.
But to express disgust with how Sultan Azlan had handled the issue is definitely not "derhaka".
In my book, there is no place for the concept of "derhaka". A Sultan is to me, a mere human being, like me and you. He's the Sultan because of his lineage, nothing else. And when he dies, he'll meet his creator, not as the Sultan, a mere person whose deeds are weighted just like the rest of us.
So, you go ahead and say that we "derhaka". That word does not mean anything to me and to many other Malaysians.
Ada tiga bentuk budaya politik Melayu berhubungan dengan kekuasaan. Yang pertama ditujukan oleh Hang Tuah, kesetiaan membuta tuli, menerima raja tidak melakukan kesalahan- rex non potest peccare-, kedua ditampilkan oleh Hang Jebat dengan ungkapan “raja adil raja disembah, raja zalim raja disanggah”, keadilan mesti ditegakan meskipun langit runtuh. Dan ditengah-tengah kedua kutub pendirian ini kita melihat sikap Tun Perak, orang yang tahu mana yang adil dan mana yang zalim dan untuk menegakkan keadilan terdapat cara-cara yang berbeda dan pilihan tersebut menuntut kebijaksanaan.
ReplyDeleteTetapi kita tidak hidup di zaman rex non potest peccare - raja tidak melakukan kesalahan, titah raja adalah hukum dan sentiasa benar. Tetapi kini raja diikat oleh perlembagaan. Nizar melakukan sesuatu yang terdapat dalam peruntukan perlembagaan, negeri Perak, perlembagaan yang sama mengikat Sultan Perak. Maka Nizar tidak derhaka. Tetapi Nizar bercakap dengan Sultan, maka laras bahasanya perlulah mengikut bahasa pertuturan rakyat bercakap dengan Sultan.
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteNever been a fan of the monarchy. Since the constitution says "kesetiaan kepada raja & negara", what to do...just had to keep my mouth shut.
But to express disgust with how Sultan Azlan had handled the issue is definitely not "derhaka".
In my book, there is no place for the concept of "derhaka". A Sultan is to me, a mere human being, like me and you. He's the Sultan because of his lineage, nothing else. And when he dies, he'll meet his creator, not as the Sultan, a mere person whose deeds are weighted just like the rest of us.
So, you go ahead and say that we "derhaka". That word does not mean anything to me and to many other Malaysians.
HOT HOT!! PANAS!! Hebat!!!
ReplyDeleteOrang Cina pun ramai yang bantah dan protes keras!!!! Bukan Orang Melayu dan India saja... Orang Cina pun ramai buat bantahan di Perak!!
Orang Cina Perak membuat "Kubur bagi Demokrasi" apabila Zambry datang jumpa mereka Kah kah kah!!
Bagus Orang Cina buat bantahan... penuh simbolisma!!!
Ini dia RAKYAT yang dah MEMBUKA MATA, TIDAK MENGIRA WARNA KULIT, DAH MEMINTA KEADILAN!
Tengoklah video pelbagai kaum membuat bantahan besar di Kuala Kangsar --->
Semua bangsa, bukan saja Melayu, menyuarakan bantahan kepada UMNO di Kuala Kangsar
Lagi video orang Melayu, Cina dan India bersama-sama membuat bantahan di Perak
Dilihat warga tua yang berkopiah dan makcik bertudung dan amoi amoi dan apek apek tua juga di dalam perarakan membuat bantahan!
No one is above the law and no one is above the God.These two things more than enough to guide your entire life in this 21st century.
ReplyDeleteThe rest is fake and selfishness in order to protect own self interest.
Citizen.
Why it is so difficult to dissolve the "DUN"? PR and "rakyat" just want a fresh election.Why BN afraid of the election?????Is it because they lose faith and no confidence after PP & KT election.This is a very good sign for next GE.....
ReplyDeleteCitizen
Rocky ni pandai nak memperdayakan orang sajer.
ReplyDeleteKau sebut pasai tiang kedua.... kesetiaan kepada raja dan negara. Tapi aku TAK PERNAH PUN JUAL NEGARA AKU KAT SINGAPURA MACAM UMNO. Ini dah tak setia kepada negara dah, UMNO ni.
Warga Perak pula memang setia kepada Raja selagi Raja adil dan sayang dan setia pada rakyat.... ini hubungan yang dua-hala, ya. Warga Perak juga setia kepada negara sebab Warga Perak tak mintak pecah BUAT NEGARA PERAK yang baru. Mereka setia penuh kepada Persekutuan Malaysia.
Dan mana pula tiang-tiang yang lain Rocky??
Ini dia...........
Keluhuran Perlembagaan.
KeDAULATan Undang-undang.
Kerana Perlembagaan adalah luhur, maka
DAULAT UNDANG UNDANG
DAULAT UNDANG UNDANG!
Paham tak Rocky?
Warga Perak memang bijak.
Mereka DAULAT kepada Undang Undang. Mereka mahu Undang Undang dipatuhi agar keadilan kepada rakyat dijamin. Bila UMNO merampas kuasa, rakyat mahu keadilan dikembalikan.
Paham Rocky?
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteYou want to move back to Ketuanan Melayu? Now umno has 27 out 28 members in the state government and that to you might be the best thing happening, what kind of government is that?
Real power is with the Rakyat and not the Sultan, this you and him cannot denial. The last thing we want to see the Sultan doing is for him scam the Rakyat together with umno and refuse to let the Rakyat to choose a new government. Looks like the Sultan is not with the Rakyat, he should do the honour thing.
Salam Rocky
ReplyDeleteWhat can Sultan do to those
"ingkar" to his "titah"?
As I see it, Nizar is not the only one but all the 28 assemblymen under the Pakatan Rakyat government as well!
Come BN! Do it in Kedah. We'll see what will happen.
ReplyDeleteIf you visit India,you can see so many great old palaces now is for exhibition.Same goes to China,PUYI is the last emperor.Here we have modern day palaces........Hmmm....my tax money gone with wind.
ReplyDelete=======
Pembayar cukai.
Come BN!!! Do it in Kedah. We'll see what will happen.
ReplyDeleteCome BN!!! Do it in Kedah. We'll see what will happen.
Come BN!!! Do it in Kedah. We'll see what will happen.
Come BN!!! Do it in Kedah. We'll see what will happen.
Salam. hmmm ntahla... for SABAHAN, this is not new.
ReplyDeleteI really feel AI has foreseen this is coming. He was there when UMNO took over Sabah from PBS. Same MO.
PBS supporters went BLANK, nobody to turn to@that time. The YB who LEAPED 1st was Lajim & his MANSION went under construction couple of months later.
Sabahan has no Sultan, we only have TYT but they are just the rubber stamp.
It's just not right.
my 2sen.
Isu macam ni buat aku terfikir.. apakah Sultan tidak biadap, tidak beradab atau derhaka terhadap rakyatnya...
ReplyDeleteHanunfa
Maybe Rocky, UMNO & the Sultan think that Perak should go the DPR Korea way where the Rakyat will love their beloved leader over time? If this can be done in this 21st century that might save UMNO and Ketuanan Melayu till the 22nd Century?
ReplyDeleteDon't forget UMNO need to show the report card for Wawasan 2020.
Western Orientated.....
ReplyDelete"An act of Treason by Barking Magpie"
ReplyDeleteya kah?
by who? when? where?
to all pakatan supporters
ReplyDeletelook what your beloved RPK summarise youself and your leaders
" When the Rulers of Perlis and Terengganu ‘interfered’ in Umno’s choice of Menteri Besar, we hailed them as great Rulers who are full of justice and wisdom. When the Rulers agreed to allow Pakatan Rakyat to form the Perak and Selangor state governments, they are the best Rulers in the world. Whenever things go our way we are full of praise. But as soon as the decision does not favour us they are haprak Rulers."
haha,
Hi Rocky,
ReplyDeleteI've been a Sultan Watcher all these years. I have removed Sultan Perak and his Oxford Trained son from AAA rating to Junk rating. He is now in the same basket as Sultan Kelantan, Pahang and Johor.
Sultan Watcher
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteDont listen to those fakatan supporter anonymous comment,
they are just sore loser, like nizar and anwar,
masa Nasaruddin masuk PKR, wah semua org PR cakap itu tindakan yang bijak,
bila org masuk BN.. then suddenly goal post has been shifted..immorallah, undemocraticlah..
even RPK is condemming you guys,
get a lifelah PR supporter
agak2 kalau dah menyampah tu, dipersilakan la ke negeri atau negara lain. habis cerita.
ReplyDeleteiskandar
This crisis shudn't have happened if everyone follows the constitution, no ordinary law. Under the consti the MB can be removed ONLY if he voluntarily resigns or if he loses the confidence of the State Assembly. The expression "we hv lost confidence in you, Nizar" must come frm the mouth of the Assembly and NOBODY's else. To do otherwise is a BLATANT disregard of the consti. Rocky had quoted Prof Faruqi as saying that the MB can be removed by the Sultan based on Interpretation Act. I'm not sure if the Prof actually said that and if he did then he seems to forget that the consti is to prevail over other laws.
ReplyDeletefrm: non-lawyer
Dear all,
ReplyDeleteThe only person to be BLAME is Anwar Ibrahim. Why?
1. Bringing the culture of street demonstration into Malaysian life
2. Anwar is not talking only about ketuanan Rakyat but worst still during the PC he did mentioned about Mahkamah Rakyat - Maybe he is suggesting the Rakyat to judge whether the sultan is wrong or right.
3. Teaching the crooks that if you are caught, then try to disqualify all those credible prosecuter and judges.
Laws and order should be enforce towards the offender who made offensive remarks to the rulers like what is done in Thailand.
All PR leader should be held FULLY RESPONSIBLES in the even that our country safety and security went into turmoils. To the young PR supporters, please do not do provocative adction or gesture like the funeral ceremony last night in Ipoh etc.
If we all believe in law and order, let us wait untill the judgement by the court.
Peace.
Warga Malaysia keturunan Tionghua.
Ampun Tuanku!
ReplyDeleteI have already foreseen the decision of HRH. Being a former judge, he is acting in accordance to the law. The law allowed party jumping without losing people's mandate. This is the fact.
If you have voted for a change, then blamed yourself for voting the wrong person, though there are not many choices. The PR leadership can only blamed themselves for fielding the wrong candidate. Simple as that.
Let's be graceful & admit defeat in this battle. But do not lose sight in the war.
Daulat Tuanku!
One Malaysian
Ok Rocky... I'm with you... already in my blog.
ReplyDeleteBismillaahirrohmaanirrohiim
ReplyDeleteKetahuilah wahai Malik (raja) bahwa saya mengangkat Anda sebagai gubernur pada sebuah negara yang pernah mengalami pemerintahan yang adil dan lalim di masa lampau. Masyarakat akan meneliti tindakan Anda dengan mata terbuka sebagaimana Anda dahulu meneliti orang-orang di depan Anda. Mereka akan meneliti hal-hal yang berkaiatn dengan Anda sebagaimana Anda dahulu membicarakan mereka. Masyarakat hanya akan berbicara baik tentang orang-orang yang berbuat baik. Merekalah yang akan melengkapi laporan tentang tindakan Anda. Oleh karena itu harta benda yang paling berharga yang patut Anda serakahi haruslah perbendaharaan amal yang baik. Kendalikan keinginan Anda dan tolaklah semua hawa nafsu yang telah diperingatkan pada Anda. Hanya dengan pematangan seperti ini Anda akan dapat membedakan kebenaran dan keburukan.
Kembangkanlah dalam hati Anda perasaan cinta kepada rakyat Anda dan jadikan itu sumber kebaikan dan karunia bagi mereka, dan jangan berlaku seperti orang biadab kepada mereka dan jangan mengambil sesuatu yang merupakan milik rakyat. Ingatlah bahwa warga negara itu terdiri dari dua golongan. Mereka adalah saudara seagama Anda atau saudara Anda sesama manusia. Mereka mengandung kelemahan dan kecendurangan berbuat kesalahan. Sebagian dari mereka ada melakukan kekeliruan, tetapi maafkan mereka sebagaimana Anda menghendaki Allah memaafkan kesalahan-kesalahan Anda. Ingatlah bahwa Anda di atas mereka sebagaimana saya di atas Anda, dan Allah bahkan di atas orang yang mengangkat Anda sebagai gubernur, agar Anda menjaga orang-orang di bawah Anda dan memuaskan mereka. Ingatlah ! Anda akan dinilai dengan perbuatan Anda bagi mereka.
Janganlah Anda menentang Allah karena Anda tidak mempunyai kekuatan untuk berlindung dari murka-Nya, Anda juga bakalan tidak lepas dari rahmat dan pengampunan-Nya. Janganlah menyesali tindakan memaafkan orang lain dan jangan bergembira atas hukuman yang Anda timpakan kepada seseorang. Janganlah murka karena tak akan ada kebaikan yang datang dari padanya.
Janganlah mengatakan, "Aku adalah penguasa dan penentu, oleh karena itu kalian harus tunduk pada perintahku," karena sikap seperti itu akan merusak hati dan melemahkan keyakinan Anda kepada agama serta menyebabkan kekacauan di muka bumi. Seandainya Anda bergembira atas kekuatan, atau dalam perasaan Anda menjlar sekelumit keangkuhan dan kesombongan, maka pandanglah kekuasaan dan keagungan pemerintah Ilahi atas alam semesta yang Anda tidak berdaya sedikitpun mengontrolnya. Hal itu akan memulihkan keseimbangan pada kecerdasan Anda yang membangkang dan memberikan kepada Anda ketenangan dan keramahan. Hati-hatilah! Jangan Anda menentang keagungan dan kebesaran Allah dan jangan meniru kemahakuasaan-Nya, karena Allah telah menghinakan para tiran yang memberontak kepada-Nya.
Hormatilah hak Allah dan hak manusia melalui tindakan Anda, dan yakinkanlah para sahabat dan kerabat Anda untuk bertindak serupa, karena apabila Anda melakukan hal sebaliknya maka Anda melakukan ketidakadilan pada diri Anda sendiri dan kepada umat manusia, sehingga Allah dan manusia akan menjadi musuh Anda. Orang yang menjadi musuh Allah tidak akan dihormati dimanapun dia berada. Ia akan dianggap sebagai orang yang berperang dengan Allah sebelum ia bertobat dan memohon ampun kepada-Nya. Tak satu hal pun dapat merampas karunia Allah atas diri seseorang dan tidak ada sesuatu pun yang lebih mudah mendorong kemurkaan Allah kepada-Nya daripada penindasan. Itu disebabkan karena Allah memperhatikan suara orang tertindas dan menaklukkan si penindaa.
Rakyat Umum
Peliharalah keadilan dalam pemerintahan dan wajibkanlah itu pada diri anda serta carilah kepuasan rakyat, karena kekecewaan rakyat banyak memandulkan kepuasan segelintir golongan khusus, dan kekesalan golongan kecil tertentu ini akan terkubur oleh kepuasan rakyat banyak.Ingatlah! Golongan yang mempunyai hak istimewa itu tidak akan membela Anda ketika Anda dalam kesulitan. Mereka akan berusaha menyelewengkan keadalian. Mereka meminta melebihi hak mereka dan tak berterima kasih atas kebaikan yang diberikan kepadanya. Mereka merasa gelisah di dalam menghadapi cobaan dan tak merasa menyesal atas kekurangannya. Rakyat umumlah yang memerangi musuh. Karena itu dekatilah mereka dan perhatikan kesejahteraannya.
Jauhilah orang yang membuka kelemahanorang lain. Bagaimanapun, rakyat tidak bebas dari kekurangan. Penguasa wajib melindungi mereka. Janganlah membeberkan sesuatu yang tersembunyi, tapi berusahalah menghilangkan kekurangan yang sudah terbuka. Allah mengawasi segala sesuatu yang tersembunyi dari Anda. Tutupilah kesalahan rakyat sedapat mungkin supaya Allah pun akan menutup kesalahan Anda yang Anda mau tetap tersembunyi dari pandangan umum. Lindungilah diri Anda dari tindakan seperti itu karena hal itu tidak layak bagi Anda. Jangan gegabah mempercayai berita dari penggunjing karena penggunjing adalah orang penipu yang tampil dalam pakaian seorang sahabat.
Penasihat
Jangan meminta nasehat dari orang kikir karena ia akan merusak ketulusan hati Anda dan menakut-nakuti Anda terhadap kemiskinan. Janganlah pula Anda meminta nasihat kepada orang pengecut karena ia akan melemahkan tekad Anda. Janganlah meminta nasihat kepada orang serakah karena ia akan menanamkan keserakahan pada diri Anda dan membuat Anda menjadi tiran. Sifat kikir, pengecut dan serakah akan melepaskan keyakinan seseorang pada Allah.
Penasihat yang terburuk adalah penasihat yang berperan sebagai pembantu penguasa yang tidak adil dan ikut serta dalam kejahatan. Karena itu janganlah menjadikan penasihat Anda orang yang telah menjadi sahabat para tiran atau yang bersekongkol dengan mereka. Anda dapat memperoleh orang-orang yang lebih baik dari orang-orang tersebut, orang yang dikaruniai kecerdasan dan wawasan jauh ke depan dan tidak tercemar oleh dosa, orang-orang yang tak pernah membantu para tiran dalam kejahatannya. Orang-orang seperti ini tidak akan menjadi beban. Sebaliknya, mereka bakalan menjadi sumber bagi pertolongan dan kekuatan Anda pada setiap kesempatan. Mereka menjadi teman Anda dan menjadi orang asing bagi musuh Anda. Pilihlah orang-orang semacam itu saja menjadi teman Anda secara pribadi maupun di hadapan umum. Bahkan dari anatara mereka, hendaklah Anda lebih menyukai orang yang mempunyai kebiasaan berbuat benar, walaupun kadang-kadang kebenaran mereka sangat pahit bagi Anda, dan tidak mendorong Anda untuk pamer yang tidak disukai Allah bagi para sahabat-Nya.
Dekatilah orang-orang yang tulus dan takwa dan jelaskanlah kepada mereka agar tidak merayu Anda atau memuji sesuatu yang tidak Anda kerjakan, karena sikaf pasif terhadap rayuan dan pujian yang tak sehat akan mendorong kepada kebanggaan dan membuat orang menjadi sombong.
Jangan menyamakan perlakuan kepada orang yang baik dengan orang yang jahat, karena hal ini akan mengenggankan orang baik dan menyemangati orang jahat. Ganjarilah setiap orang sesuai dengan yang patut baginya. Ingatlah bahwa saling percaya dan ikhlas antara penguasa dan rakyat akan berkembang melalui kebajikan, keadilan dan pelayanan. Oleh karena itu pupuklah kebaikan diantara rakyat karena hanya kebaikan merekalah yang akan menyelamatkan Anda dari kesukaran. Kebajikan Anda kepada mereka akan dibalas oleh kepercayaan mereka pada Anda, dan perlakuan buruk Anda akan dibalas oleh hasrat buruk mereka.
Janganlah meremehkan tradisi mulia yang telah dipraktekkan oleh pendahulu kita yang telah menciptakan keharmonisan dan kemajuan di anatara manusia. Janganlah memulai sesuatu yang meminimkan kemanfaatannya. Orang-orang yang menegakkan tradisi mulia itu telah mendapatkan pahala mereka, namun tanggung jawab akan menimpa Anda bila tradisi tersebut disia-siakan. Serukanlah selalu mendapatkan pelajaran dari pengalaman orang yang berilmu dan bijaksana dan sering-seringlah berkonsultasi dengan mereka mengenai masalah kenegaraan supaya Anda dapat memelihara perdamaian dan kebaikan yang sudah disusun oleh para pendahulu Anda.
Perbedaan Kelas Manusia
Ingatlah bahwa manusia terdiri dari kelompok yang berbeda-beda. Kemajuan dari yang satu bergantung pada kemajuan orang lain, dan tak seorang pun dapat terlepas dari orang lain. Kita mempunyai tenatara yang terbentuk dari prajurit-prajurit Allah. Kita punya pegawai sipil beserta lembaga-lembaganya, pengadilan, pengumpul pajak, dan petugas hubungan masyarakat. Masyarakat pun terdiri dari kaum Muslimin dan dzimmi, dan dianatara mereka ada yang berprofesi pedagang, para tukang, penganggu dan orang-orang miskin. Allah telah menentukan bagi mereka hak, tugas dan kewajiban. Semuanya telah ditetapkan dalam Al Qur'an dan hadis Nabi.
Angkatan bersenjata, dengan rahmat Allah, bagaikan benteng bagi rakyat dan memberikan kewibawaan negara. Ia mengangkat wibawa agama dan memelihara perdamaian negara. Tanpa tentara maka negara tak dapat berdiri. Disi lain tentara tak mungkin berdiri tanpa dukungan negara. Para prajurit kita terbukti tangguh di depan musuh karena mereka berperang dengan tujuan mencapai ridha Allah, namun mereka mempunyai kebutuhan materi yang harus dipenuhi dan oleh karena itu mereka bergantung pada pendapatan yang disediakan untuk mereka dari pajak negara. Tentara dan penduduk sipil yang membayar pajak membutuhkan kerjasama dengan orang lain: pejabat pengadilan, pegawai sipil dan lembaga-lembaga pemerintahan. Hakim melaksanakan hukum perdata dan pidana, pegawai sipil mengumpulkan pajak dan mengurus pemerinthan sipil dengan bantuan lembaga-lembaganya. Lalu ada pedagang dan saudagar yang menambah pendapatan pajak. Merekalah yang menyelenggarakan pasar dan yang dalam posisi lebih baik dalam menjalankan kewajiban sosialnya. Kemudian ada kalangan fakir miskin yang kewajiban pemeliharaannya berada pada golongan-golongan yang lain. Allah telah memberikan kesempatan pengkhidmatan yang sesuai untuk setiap dan semua orang, lalu ada hak-hak dari seluruh golongan ini terhadap pemerintah yang harus dipenuhi pemerintah demi kebaikan seluruh penduduk -- suatu tugas yang tak dapat ia penuhi dengan sempurna kecuali dengan mengorbankan kepentingan pribadi dalam pelaksanaannya dan dengan memohon pertolongan kepada Allah. Sesungguhnya adalah kewajibannya untuk memikul beban ini dan bersabar atas kesusahan dan kesulitan sehubungan dengan tugasnya.
Angkatan Bersenjata
Perhatikanlah secara khusus kesejahteraan angkatan bersenjata yang menurut Anda setia kepada Allah dan Nabi-Nya serta loyal kepada pimpinannya, yang pada saat marah bias mengendalikan diri dan mendengar bantahan yang layak secara tenang serta dapat membantu orang yang lemah dan mampu menghantam yang kuat, yang provokasi keras tidak akan membuatnya menjadi bengis dan yang tidak ragu pada setiap tahap.
Dekatilah keluarga yang reputasi dan integritasnya sudah terbukti baik dan masa lalu Yang cemerlang,libatkanlah orang-orang yang bersifat berani dan jujur serta yang berwatak baik dan murah hati, karena orang-orang semacam ini adalah golongan masyarakat yang terkemuka.
Bersikap lemah lembutlah kepada mereka sebagaimana Anda bersikap lemah lembut kepada anak-anak Anda dan jangan membicarakan hal-hal yang baik yang tidak Anda lakukan untuk mereka, jangan pula menyepelekan ungkapan cinta yang mereka tunjukkan sebagai tanda kebaikan dan kesetiaan mereka. Penuhilah setiap keperluan mereka walau pada kebutuhan yang sepele dan jangan merasa puas karena telah memberikan pertolongan yang umum kepada mereka, karena kadang-kadang perhatian yang tepat pada waktunya terhadap keperluan mereka yang kecil akan membawa kelegaan yang amat besar. Yakinkanlah bahwa orang-orang ini tidak akan melupakan Anda pada saat Anda sangat membutuhkan bantuan.
Anda harus memilih menjadi panglima tertinggi orang yang merasa berkewajiban untuk Menolong anak buahnya dan unggul dalam kebaikan atas setiap perwira lainnya,yang Harus memenuhi keperluan orang-orang yang ada di bawahnya dan menjaga keluarga Mereka tatkala mereka sedang pergi,sedemikian rupa ,sehingga seluruh angkatan Bersenjatan merasa bersatu dalam kesenangan dan kesedihan mereka. Kesatuan tujuan ini Akan memperkokoh kekuatan mereka melawan musuh.teruslah bersikap baik kepeada Mereka sehingga mereka benar-benar tertaut pada anda.nyatanya,kebahagiaan pelaksana pemerintahan dan kesenangan mereka terletak pada praktik pelaksanaan keadilan di Dalam negara dan memelihara hubungan cinta kasihdengan rakyat.ketulusan meraka diekspresikan dengan cinta dan penghargaan yang mereka tunjukan pada anda,yang Hanya dengan begitu keamanan pemerintahan akan tetap terpelihara.
Nasihat anda kepada angkatan bersenjata hanya akan bermanfaat bilamana anda menunjukkan rasa sayang kepada prajurit maupun para perwira sehingga mereka tidak menganggap pemerintah sebagai beban yang menekan atau berperan bagi kejatuhnnya.
Teruslah memuaskan kebutuhan mereka dan jangan segan-segan memuji jasa yang telah mereka lakukan.insya Allah sikap semacam itu akan menginspirasikan keberanian Kepada orang yang pemberani dan mendorong orang yang takut untuk bertindak berani
Berusahalah menyalami perasaan orang lain dan jangan menyebarkan kesalahan seseorang kepada orang lain dan jangan ragu memberikan penghargaan yang layak . Perhatikanlah jangan menunjukkan perlakuan khusus kepada orang yang tidak berprestasi ysemata-mata bergantung pada posisi keluarganya, dan jangan menyembunyikan ganjaran yang layak pada seseorang yang telah mengerjakan perbuatan yang besar hanya karena dia berposisi rendah.
Bimbingan Yang Sebenarnya
Berpalinglah kepada Allah dan rosulnya tatkala menghadapi keraguan.Allah berfirman kepada orang-orang yang hendak di pimpin-NYA ," hai orang-orang yang beriman! Taatlah kepada Allah , kepada rasul -NYA dan kepada ulil amri diantara kamu." Kembali kepada Allah artinya mencari petunjuk dari kitab suci dan kembali kepada Rasul artinya mengikuti hadis yang di terima secara abash
Kepala Makamah
Pilihlah ketua mahkamah dari orang-orang yang paling baik diantara mereka,yang bebas dari godaan urusan rumah tangga. Tidak dapat ditakut-takuti, tidak sering melakukan kesalahan , tidak memutarbalikkan kebenaran yang diketahui,tidak egois atau serakah Orang yang tidak pernah memutus kan sesuatu sebelum mengetahui seluru fakta , Orang yang akan menimbang dengan hati-hati setiap keraguan dan menetapkan keputusan yang jelas setelah mempertimbangkan segala sesuatu,yang tidak menjadi Gelisa atas argumen pengacara,yangakan memeriksa dengan sabar setiap penyingkapan Fakta yang baru ,dan yang benar-benar adil dalam keputusannya orang yang tidak akan Disesatkan oleh rayuan ,orang yang tidak bersuka ria atas kedudukannya.namun , Orang seperti itu amat jarang.
Bila anda telah mendapatkan orang yang tepat untuk jabatan itu maka bayarlah dia Dengan baik , izinkan dia hidup dengan senang sesuai dengan kedudukannya sehingga Ia tidakakan terpengaruh godaan . perlakukan dia dengan baik ,tempatkan iapada posisi yang amat tinggi di pengadilan anda sehingga tak ada seorang pun yang berkhayal akan mendapatkan kedudukan itu, sedemikian tingginya sehingga orang-orang tidak akan memfitnah dan persekongkolan tidak akan menyentuhnya .
Pengadilan Tingkat Rendah
Perhatikanlah! Anda harus melakukan pemilihan secara saksama karena jabatan ini Menjadi buruan para egois petualang yang ingin mendapatkannya dan memanfaatkannya Sesuai dengan keinginan pribadinya.setelah pemilihan kepala mahkamah,pilihlah dengan hati-hati para petugas lainnya. Kukuhkan pengangkatan mereka setelah mereka Melampaui masa percobaan.jangan menempatkan orang-orang di posisi yang penting Hanya karena hubungan pribadi atau karena suatu pengaruh,karena hal itu dapat menyebabkan ketidakadilan dan kerusakan.
Untuk kedudukan yang tinggi ,pilihlah orang yang berpengalaman ,saleh dan dari Keluarga yang baik .orang-orang semacam ini tidak akan mudah menjadi korban godaan dan mereka akan melaksanakan tugas mereka dengan memperhatikan kebaikan yang langgeng bagi orang lain. Naikkan gaji mereka agar mereka dapat hidup dengan puas. Kehidupan yang puas akan membantu orang mencapai kesucian. Mereka tidak akan bernafsu mengambil bagian dari penghasilan anak buahnya bagi kepentingan mereka sendiri. Dengan demikian mereka tidak beralasan untuk menyalahi instruksi atau menyalahgunakan dana negara. Awasi mereka secara diam-diam. Mudah-mudahan mereka dapat mengembangkan kejujuran dan perhatian yang sungguh-sungguh bagi kesejahteraan masyarakat. Tapi bila seseorang dari mereka dituduh berlaku tidak jujur, dan kesalahan itu dikukuhkan oleh pengawas rahasi Anda, maka konfirmasi ini patut dianggap sudah cukup untuk menjatuhkan hukuman padanya. Gelarlah hukuman badaniah di depan umum di tempat yang ditentukan.
All you joes and joets are a bunch of clowns. He done it, not because of love for BN or hatred towards Pakatan. This is the story.
ReplyDeleteTHE PKR Govt gives problems to Gamuda Bhd on land acquisition in Penang. Gamuda which has 50 per cent of the project, needs the issue setteled or its gona face cashflow problems.
One VERY senior company source tells me (the guy wanted to resign cpl ofmths ago), that a CERTAIN shareholder has been using Gamuda as their personal BANK.
In Perak, the Sultan dismises the MB, while UMNO's two veteran politician,Ku Li and former member Tun M says procedures were not followed.
PS, by the way, the PERAK royalty is the single largest and controlling shareholder in Gamuda.
Whats going to happen now? The Pahang-selangor water transfer project mite get the boot. Instead, a Sime Darby plan (Rocky cringing teeth) with a Sdn Bhd controlled by the royalty in Perak to supply water will be given the nod.
And so,it was all about the money... not race, not religion,not even morality, just the colour of Money.
Even Zimbawae Ahead of Malaysia (EZAM).
Dear Rocky,
ReplyDeleteI agree with you, "Let's Read the Quran" and living up to the great Book. We won't be able to get through Munkar and Nankir if we obey anything other than the Quran (Allah SWT) and Sunnah (Rasulullah SAW).
Rocky, i refer to the Al Quran:
164. Behold! In the creation of the heavens and the earth; in the alteration of the Night and the Day; in the sailing of the ships through the Ocean for the profit of mankind; in the rain which Allah sends down form the skies, and the life which He gives therewith to an earth that is dead; in the beast of all kinds that He scatters through the earth; in the change of the winds and the clouds which they taril like their slaves between the sky and the earth; (here) indeed are Signs for a people that are wise.
165. Yet there are men who take (for worship) others besides Allah as equal (with Allah); they love them as they should love Allah. But those of Faith are overflowing in their love for Allah. If only the unrighteous could see behold, they would see the punishment; that to Allah belongs all power and Allah will strongly enforce the punishment.
(Al Baqarah: 164-165)
Get your priorities straight Bro..
I'm an UMNO member. If I lose confidence in the President of UMNO (which I actually do), can I gather all the delegates in my house and if I manage to obtain their support there, will the Sec Gen of UMNO recognise that "decision" and act accordingly. Most likely the Sec Gen will issue press statement: "That gathering is unlawful as far as UMNO constitution is concerned. Any motion of no confidence must be tabled at a properly convened EGM to be called by the Sec Gen upon requisition from not less than ...delegates". With that I rest my case.
ReplyDeletefrm: observer
Kedaulatan Undang-Undang atau Kedaulatan UMNO?
ReplyDeletePilihlah.
Tron
ReplyDelete"And the non malays who have a degree in marketing/business studies from some obscure private college become experts in constitutional law and have a field day yet again for free malay bashing."
O yes yes...i like i like..you are so rite...you've hit the jackpot!
That's the problem nowadays. Too many idiots with illusions of grandeur.
Nizar being the chief.
Tg Razaleigh has described the scene in Perak as shameful. It indeed is. Anybody wants to label him derhaka? As far as I know amongst the mainstream papers, only the Star carried it. Whatever happens to that much talked about motto "bearer of news"? which I must hasten to add "bearer of one-sided news"
ReplyDeletefrm: newsworthy
All the opinions are just empty gases..
ReplyDeleteEver stop to wonder, how a few days ago, before the grab of power is made, how the Perakians respected their Sultan ? How,the general Malaysians sees a beacon of Royalty, shining through the Istana in Kuala Kangsar ?
Yet, today, all these lie in that filthy monsoon drain across the road. The place of worship was gased by tear bombs, ladies and children cried on the march of the FRU, and the men who laid on the road was trampled upon ! What made this happen ?
A very simple answer...the person whom they look upon as their saviour, as their beacon of hope for a fair governance, so that they can earn a livelihood under the son, was deemed betrayed them on self interest. Right or wrong, is not the issue here, as they had made a choice in march08, for whom to lead and take care of them, without prejudiced, without corruption, spending money on pelacur, or dangdut joint....
For those who think this is all about race, Melayu, Cina or Indian, etc...I have a suggestion here...go dip your numbskull in a pile of manure, the stink might just wake you up !
Derhaka??? There is no such word in modern dictionary.
ReplyDeleteWe are not living in zaman kebangkitan Melaka. Stop living in history la Bro.
Raja yang adil di sembah, raja yang zalim di ????
- Udig -
Bro Rocky,
ReplyDeletesuddenly, there are many commentators here are against what you wrote here! LOL.
i guess to them (these Fuckatan Rakyat sympathisers),
lying in the middle of the road with jubah on and just after friday prayers to demand the sultan's convoy to stop is ok,
only the melayu protested in the streets but let the dap cina voters have 999 years rights on government land + bigger land for cina schools in perak are ok,
let a benggali tua (kici-kici jaga lembu) insults the sultan is ok,
nizar defiance of the sultan's order is ok,
to let nga & ngeh determine the direction of the perak state by using nizar as their puppet is ok,
anything as long as its not in favor of umno or malay interests are ok,
let the malay show their displeasures via street demos as long as the dap cina benefits and don't show their faces is ok,
tak pa, depa dap ah chong kawan kita, dap samy kawan kita, that dap benggali loyar kawan kita - cuma satu hari nanti depa ni semua makan kita dan bersikap kurang ajar dengan kita, raja kita, agama kita, bangsa kita dan negara kita.
-fikirlah cendiri
From the postings here, it is very obvious that the people in Perak do not want the BN Government. God's will has been trampled on to let that of the evil men's rule.
ReplyDeleteBN like the Jews has done a GAZA on Pakatan. In the end God will prevail. You just wait and see. God will always prevail.
ghost of onn jaafar
The choice was obvious! Just let the bloody people decide! How hard was that! After the election, you can bloody swear the new MB who ever that would be.
ReplyDelete- Udig -
RPK's latest article "what more to say" says it all. For once -I couldnt agree more with him. A clear conscience man would say and accept the truth no matter how painful it is. For this he got my vote.
ReplyDeleteTo all PR leaders particularly AI, shame on you all for manipulating the rakyat. The mess on the street, the biadapness to the Sultan from your fanatic supporters are all credited to your thoughtless leadership and greed for power. All of you can only be "leaders" to those who didnt know better (pity them). Dont even dream of leading Malaysia. Your true colors have prevailed. Majority of rakyat know that BN is not a perfect government but now we also know that PR is the worst of two evils.
The UMPNOPUTRA has spoken!
ReplyDelete- UDig -
salam.
ReplyDeletesaya ada terjemah kepada 5 bahasa asing untuk artikel bro di atas..
ia disiarkan di blog saya http://penembak-tepat.blogspot.com/2009/02/bravo-brother-rocky-bru-kerana-lantang.html.
pendirian bebas non partisan bro dalam membela raja kita sangat sangat kami sebagai team BPN Blogger Pembela Negara hargai.
Saya mewakili BPN mengucapkan tahniah atas keberanian tersebut dan mendoakan ia satu momentum yang baik di dalam menyekat aura jahat sesetengah pihak yang ingin menjadikan Sultan / Raja mangsa dan alat 'perniagaan' politik mereka.
syabas....
Salam perjuangan!!
Yes brother. I agree with you.
ReplyDeleteThey said its all up to Sultan Perak to decide and he had made his decisions. Then, why did they disobey the Sultan and try to fined Sultan for making his decisions. It must be a solid reason why Sultan choose not to dissolve DUN in Perak. What Pakatan Rakyat could do is to start finding the core problems that causes their ADUN to quit their parties and become ADUN Bebas.
I found 1 video in youtube that shows Pakatan Rakyat request toward BN on 16 September. These request were made in order to stop BN from trying to do things that will hassle them in taking over Malaysia.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gTKLCZFnTjg
1 of the request was that BN shall not dissolve parliament response so the intention to form a new government.
I figure, that Pakatan Rakyat also must already prepare to do the same thing if it’s happen to them. Right?? I do not think that they will request/say something that they themselves are unable to cope??
The trust between the 3 MPs and the state rakyat is broken.
ReplyDeleteSo the 3 MPs are no longer representing the voice of rakyat.
So you can't say BN has got the majority.
Without trust BN can't go very far.
I still remember the person who hold Keris and said, 'Kill Chinese', and was not being detained during operasi Lalang, you know who?
ReplyDeleteI still remember,Atlantuya....you remember?
Oh...forget, A King is not subjected to Court of Law even if the commit criminal offense...kekeke...that's why they can not be SAMAN or CHallange...if not, UMNO will have rally with banner on the street!
Cuba fikir sejenak:
ReplyDeleteDaulat bermaksud (Takrifan Kamus Dewan) “Mempunyai kedudukan yang tinggi dan berkuasa, berwibawa”. Dalam hal ini RAKYAT juga mempunyai kuasa untuk menentukan sendiri siapakah pemimpin yang mereka inginkan melalui proses pilihan raya.
Siapa betul sekarang?
20 tahun lagi bangsa aku majority.
ReplyDeleteAku ingin berperang supaya bangsa aku jadi bangsa majority sekarang!!!!
Siapa Si Rajagopal?
ReplyDeleteDia tak lahir dari kalangan kita
Dia tak makan apa yang kita makan
Dia tak tinggal di rumah yang biasa kita tinggal
Dia tak belajar di sekolah yang kita belajar
Dia tak pakai apa yang kita pakai
Dia tak berbahasa melayu seperti kita
Dia tak bekereta seperti kereta kita
Dia tak ambil kisah pun ada antara kita yang merana...
Tiba-tiba dia yang membuat keputusan untuk kita????
Betul ke keputusan dia?
Tak boleh ke kita menyoal?
Benar ke biadap kalau kita menyoal walau dgn sopan?
Ini kurun ke-14 atau ke-21?
Monarki mutlak ke atau monarki berperlembagaan?
Buat masa sekarang kita lihat ada pengikut-pengikut parti PAS sanggup baring diatas jalan sebagai tanda mereka berani mati.
ReplyDeleteTukang-tukang karut propaganda PKR, DAP dan PAS dalam blog2 politik adalah penghasut yang paling bahaya sekali didalam negara kita. Mereka-mereka inilah yang meracuni pemikiran orang-orang awam yang mudah percaya kepada tipu-helah ahli-ahli politik sehingga banyak yang terpengaruh untuk berbuat apa saja yang disuruh.
Hari ini kita lihat penghasut-penghasut ini telah berjaya meracuni pemikiran pengikut-pengikut mereka sehingga ramai yang berani menderhaka kepada Raja dan sanggup mati.
Tidak hairanlah kalau esok sekiranya ada perhimpunan tunjuk perasaan anjuran blog-blog seperti Malaysia Today atau People’s Parliment kita dapat lihat ada yang sanggup menjadi “Suicide Bombers”.
Batu Nesan Untuk Barisan Nasional
ReplyDeleteITULAH REALITI YANG KINI DINAFIKAN SEMUA MEDIA PRO BN DAN MAKHLUK2 DALAM BN.
RAKYAT PERAK BERSATU HATI TIDAK KIRA MELAYU, TIONG HUA, INDIA DAN WARGA ASLI SEMUA MENOLAK KEPIMPINAN 'HARAM'.
MARI KITA TEGAKKAN KEDAULATAN UNDANG-UNDANG.
TETAPKAN HATI, JGN ENDAHKAN SEGALA TOHMAHAN BN TERMASUK SEMUA MEDIANYA YANG CUKUP MELUAT UTK DIDENGAR.
RAKYAT AKAN BANGKIT SECAR BERSAMA BERJUANG MENENTANG KEZALIMAN.
Tengku Razaleigh menyokong kedudukan YAB Nizar sebagai Menteri Besar Perak yg sah.
ReplyDeleteMaka, Tengku Razaleigh itu derhaka?
Tengku Razaleigh, anak raja juga -- derhaka ke beliau?
Fikir-fikirkanlah.
Jangan terjatuh ke dalam propaganda UMNO.
Tuanku Yg Maha Mulia Sultanku,
ReplyDeletePatik merayu kepada Tuanku bubarkan dan adakan pilihanraya, Tuanku.
Patik mohon maaf tapi patik tidak tahan melihat nama dan darjat Tuanku dicemari dengan gerombolan UMNO yang zalim, Tuanku.
Tolong Tuanku, bubarkan Dewan Undangan Negeri Perak dan kembalikan demokrasi, Tuanku dengan ampun-ampun sekali benarkanlah RAKYAT memilih siapa yang rakyat mahukan...
Ampun Tuanku Patik menghamba merayu depan Tuanku....
Warrior 231,
ReplyDeleteboleh kasi summarise kau punya thesis tu tak? after 3 para I got lost. Sorry ye..me no lowyar. No comprende. tapi kalau hang rupanya nak tunjuk tera oklah. after all internet ni free for all.
Oklah Cerdik Pandai ini intipatinya dalam Bahasa Melayu.Susah nak bagi ringkas kerana nak berasakan fakta. Mungkin panjang dan dicampuraduk dengan petikan BI tetapi kesuntukan masa tidak mengizinkan pacal untuk menterjemah semua. Tak ingin pun tunjuk tera cuma mencari kebenaran bersandarkan otak pak tani/bekas komando ini.............Ok, saya mulakan penjelasan:
1. Adakah Sultan betul dalam tidak membubarkan DUN Perak seperti yang dipinta mantan MB Nizar berdasarkan Artikel 16(6)
2. (a) Wujudkah keperluan bagi prosedur undi tidak percaya berkenaan dilakukan di dalam Majlis Perundangan Negeri bagi mengesahkan samada MB Nizar masih mendapat kepercayaan majoriti perwakilan atau
2 (b) Bolehkah prosedur lain dari undi diDUN boleh diterima pakai dalam menentukkan hal ketidakpercayaan tersebut?
2. c)Susulan dari atas, persoalan pokok 2 ialah adakah Duli Tuanku Sultan membuat keputusan tepat dalam mempelawa BN membentuk kerajaan baru memandangkan satu usul undi tidak percaya belum dibahaskan dalam Majlis Perundangan Negeri?
Soalan sampingan:
1. adakah SPR betrtindak betul dalam tidak menerima kekosongan kerusi ADUN Behrang dan CJ berdasarkan dua surat perletakkan jawatan yang didakwa ditandatangani oleh ADUN berkenaan.
Jawapan kepada persoalan pokok #1:
Berdasarkan Artikel 16(6): Duli Sultan mempunyai dua pilihan yakni ; membubarkan atau tidak membubarkan. Ini jelas tampak dalam konstruksi artikel berkenaan:
"If the MB ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Legislative Assembly, then, unless at his request His Royal Highness dissolves the Legislative Assembly, he shall tender the resignation of the Executive Council."
Jelas dari diatas, melainkan Sultan BERKENAN membubarkan ADUN, MB wajib meletakkan jawatan. Kekeliruan timbul kerana , he shall tender the resignation of the Executive Council merujuk kepada EXCO bukan MB. Tetapi logik akal yang sihat akan mengabsahkan bahawa EXCO dalam konteks ini merangkumi MB kerana MB adalah ketua EXCO. Dalam ertikata lain MB umpama kepala dan EXCO jasad. Bolehkah ditafsirkan yang keduanya saling tidak berkait dan tidak memerlukkan. Jawapannya tentunya tidak!!.
Kendatipun akan ada manusia baghal berpendirian tegar bahawa MB tidak perlu berbuat demikian, rujukan kepada Interpretation Act (1948) spt yang disarankan Profesor Shad sudah memadai bagi merungkai maslahat ini.
Jawapan kepada #2 (a)
2. a)Wujudkah keperluan bagi prosedur undi tidak percaya berkenaan dilakukan di dalam Majlis Perundangan Negeri bagi mengesahkan samada MB Nizar masih mendapat kepercayaan majoriti perwakilan?
Jawapannya : a) Tidak. Konvensi(Ingat ini konvensi SAHAJA BUKAN KETETAPAN MUTLAK) Parlimen Westminster (British) menetapkan bahawa prosedur yang harus digunapakai adalah undi tidak percaya dalam DUN dan keputusan mahkamah Persekutuan dalam Stephen Kalong Ningkan vs .Gabenor Sarawak (1966) SEOLAH-OLAH mengiakan prosedur berkenaan. Namun keputusan Mahkamah Persekutuan itu terbit dari kesangsian mahkamah tersebut kepada beberapa perkara.
Secara umumnya, barisan Hakim mahkamah Persekutuan mendapati bahawa Gabenor Sarawak telah silap dalam menggunakan surat menyuarakan tidak percaya yang ditandatangan oleh majoriti ADUN Sarawak dalam membuat keputusannya. Ini adalah kerana kesahihan surat2 berkenaan boleh di pertikaikan dan hal ini disuarakan oleh Hakim dalam kes Datuk Amir Kahar vs Tun Mohd Said Keruak:
The hard fact in that case (Ningkan) was that the alleged loss of confidence was highly suspect. There was a top secret representation made by persons outside the Council Negri which on the fact of it did not disclose that the representors were the majority of members in the Council Negri. Also, the fact represented was suspicious in the sense that the letter was not signed by all persons listed in the letter and even in respect of those who signed, one of them was represented only by a ‘chop’
Gamplang sudah dari diatas bahawa, Mahkamah Persekutuan menetapkan undi tidak percaya perlu dilakukan dalam Dewan Perundangan Negeri Sarawak BUKAN kerana ia satu prosedur mutlak tetapi kerana timbul syak wasangka jemaah hakim terhadap dalil ( dalam bentuk surat) yang digunakan oleh Gabenor dalam membubarkan ADUN Sarawak. Malah pandangan ini diperkuatkan lagi dalam pemerhatian Hakim Justice Harley (yang juga menganggotai Jemaah hakim dalam kes Ningkan) bahawa:
‘Men who put their names to a ‘top secret’ letter may well hesitate to vote publicly in support of their private views ... page193
Berdasarkan hujah diatas, prosedur yang digariskan dalam Stephen Kalong Ningkan vs Governor of Sarawak (1966) tidak boleh dijadikan asas kukuh dalam kes ini kerana factor-faktor yang unik yang menyelubungi kes tersebut.
2 b)Bolehkah prosedur lain dari undi dalam DUN boleh diterima pakai dalam menentukkan hal ketidakpercayaan tersebut?
YA. Ada cara lain yang boleh diguna pakai bagi menentukkan ‘kepercayaan’ berkenaan. Ini di perturunkan dengan jelas dalam kes Datuk Amir Kahar vs Tun Mohd Said Keruak dimana Hakim memutuskan bahawa undi tidak percaya terhadap Datuk Joseph Pairin Kitingan telah pun di putuskan di LUAR Majlis Perundangan Negeri :
“In this case, from the petition (which was incidentally telecast live on television the day before Pairin tendered his resignation), the 30 members not only said they no longer had confidence in Pairin as the chief minister but they also requested the first defendant to convene the assembly and to direct Pairin to table a motion of confidence. However, the assembly was not convened to enable the action to be taken. In addition to that, Pairin himself in his press statement stated he resigned because the ruling party, ie PBS of which he is the leader, no longer had the majority support of the assemblymen, for owing to the defection of the members of his party, the position was reversed with the BN having the majority, and thus paving the way for the BN to form the next government."
Tampak dari atas bahawa, Hakim menerima yang berikut sebagai ganti prosedur undi tidak percaya dalam DUN:
a.petisyen yang ditandatangani oleh yang berkenaan, yakni, 30 ADUN
b.Pengakuan peribadi Pairin.
Berdasarkan keputusan dalam kes Datuk Amir Kahar vs Tun Mohd Said Keruak , undi tidak percaya dalam Dun seperti yang di desak oleh Pakatan Rakyat adalah tidak perlu, cukup dengan hanya pengistiyaraan bertulis atau sebarang bentuk lain diLUAR DUN.
2. c)Susulan dari atas, adakah Duli Tuanku Sultan membuat keputusan tepat dalam mempelawa BN membentuk kerajaan baru memandangkan satu usul undi tidak percaya belum dibahaskan dalam Majlis Perundangan Negeri?
Ya. Saya telah menjelaskan berdalilkan keputusan dalam Datuk Amir Kahar vs Tun Mohd Said Keruak bahawa Persidangan DUN tidak perlu diadakan bagi menjalankan prosedur undi tidak percaya.
Jika keputusan kes ini dijadikan sandaran maka :
a.peristiyaraan keluar PKR dan menyokong kerajaan BN oleh ADUN Behrang, Jelapang dan CJ
b.pengumuman resmi yang dibuat melalui sidang akhbar dalam akhbar dan media elektronik oleh 31 ADUN Perak tempoh hari
c.tindakan mantan MB meminta perkenan Sultan membubarkan ADUN Perak
kesemuanya mengisyaratkan bahawa mantan MB Perak SUDAH pun “ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Legislative Assembly……..”artikel 16(6) dan dengan sebab itu wajar meletak jawatan bersama exco beliau.
Susulan dari itu Baginda Sultan berhak di bawah Artikel 16 untuk menggunakan budi bicara baginda melantik kerajaan baru:
Article 16 of the Perak Constitution says that the Sultan shall appoint the Executive Council ("EC"). He must first appoint as Menteri Besar from the members of the Legislative Assembly who "in his judgment is likely to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Assembly."
Jadi keputusan Baginda menobatkan BN sebagai kerajaan baru adalah sah mengikut lunas undang2. Ini berdasarkan pengamatan baginda akan:
a.peristiyaraan keluar PKR dan menyokong kerajaan BN oleh ADUN Behrang, Jelapang dan CJ
b.pengumuman resmi yang dibuat melalui sidang akhbar dalam akhbar dan media elektronik oleh 31 ADUN Perak (28=BN + 3 =Bebas) tempoh hari
Tetapi bagi tidak mengeruhkan keadaan dan mendapatkan kepastian hakiki, Baginda Sultan dengan penuh hikmah dan bijaksana mentitahkan bahawa 31 (28=BN + 3=Bebas) ADUN yang berkenaan menghadap baginda bagi mengesahkan pendirian mereka seperti yang tertera dalam kenyataan resmi Istana Perak:
On the order of the Duli Yang Maha Mulia to ascertain that the information given was accurate, all the 31 state assemblyman were to present themselves before Paduka Seri Sultan.
After meeting all the 31 assemblymen, DYMM Paduka Seri Sultan of Perak was convinced that YAB Datuk Seri Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin had ceased to command the confidence of the majority of the State Assembly members.
Source: http://www.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2009/2/6/nation/3209890&sec=nation
Nah, ini menyerlahkan kebijaksanaan Baginda Sultan sebagai seorang Raja berdaulat. Baginda tidak dipengaruhi faktor lain kecuali pengamatan baginda yang penuh hikmah semata2 dan kecermatan baginda dalam membuat keputusan yang membabitkan kepentingan rakyat tersirna jelas. Tindakan baginda juga dengan sendirinya menidakkan kemungkinan berulangnya kemelut yang membelenggu Sarawak 42 tahun yang silam. Keperibadian mulia dan gentleman baginda bukan suatu yang hanya ketara dalam kes ini. Malah ianya tampak sirna dalam kes perlantikan mantan MB Nizar dahulu seperti yang boleh dilihat dalam nukilan ini:
"Perak DAP secretary Nga Kor Ming said that Raja Nazrin wanted a letter of undertaking from all 31 opposition assemblymen indicating their support for the formation of the new DAP-PKR-PAS coalition government.“The letter should also state that all 31 of them supported the appointment of Pasir Panjang assemblyman Mohammad Nizar Jamaluddin as the new Mentri Besar,” said Nga, who is also Pantai Remis assemblyman". http://thestar.com.my/election/story.asp?file=/2008/3/14/election2008/20643379&sec=Election2008]
kendatipun ketika itu Pakatan Rakyat tidak wujud (hanya didaftar secara resmi pada 18 Mac... Nizar dilantik 14 Mac) seperi yang di nyatakan oleh Prof Shad:
“Perak result: The Perak assembly result posed fascinating possibilities. No party or coalition holds an absolute majority of the 59 seats. Barisan has 28; DAP captured 18; PKR won seven; and PAS holds six. The combined opposition vote is 31 to Barisan’s 28. But as the Opposition is not a formal coalition, we have a “hung assembly” – a chamber with no clear-cut leader.”
source:REFLECTING ON THE LAW
BY SHAD SALEEM FARUQI available at :http://www.garoweonline.com/artman2/publish/Opinion
Beralih kita kepada soalan sampingan.
Soalan sampingan:
1. adakah SPR bertindak betul dalam tidak menerima kekosongan kerusi ADUN Behrang dan CJ berdasarkan dua surat perletakkan jawatan yang didakwa ditandatangani oleh ADUN berkenaan.
Jawapan kepada Soalan sampingan
Ya. SPR bertanggungjawab mengesahkan MEMANG timbul kekosongan dalam kedua kerusi ADUN dan bukan bersandarkan dengan makluman Speaker DUN semata2. Artikel 36(5) Perlembagaan Perak menetapkan :
“A casual vacancy shall be filled within sixty days from the date on which it shall be established by the Election Commission that there is a vacancy…”
Nah kecuali kalau pembaca budiman seorang dunggu, kesemua tindakan SPR dalam memastikan wujudnya kekosongan memang selaras dengan “it shall be established by the Election Commission that there is a vacancy”. Tambahan pula, penggunaan kes Ong Kee Hui v. Sinyium anak Mutit (1982) sebagai sandaran bagi mengabsahkan keputusan SPR adalah tepat seperti yang diakui oleh Karpal Singh SENDIRI:
“Veteran lawyer and DAP national chairman Karpal Singh said the commission’s decision to recognise Jamaluddin and Mohd Osman as the assemblymen for Behrang and Changkat Jering respectively was based on a Federal Court case in 1982.“The legal advisers have likely advised them based on that,” he said.
The Federal Court had ruled in 1982 in the case of Sarawak United People’s Party member Datuk Ong Kee Hui v. the then party president Sinyium anak Mutit that the arrangement of submitting an undated resignation letter to the Speaker was contrary to public policy and therefore void.” http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2009/2/4/nation/3191396&sec=nation
Jelas, keputusan SPR adalah berdasarkan lunas undang-undang semata2 dan tidak berpaksikan nafsu serakah manusia bangsat yang kebejatan moral yang ingin mencetuskan kacau bilau di bumi Perak tercinta!!
Kesemua diatas jelas menzahirkan adab, hikmah dan kebijaksanaan Baginda Sultan dan Raja Nazrin dalam memutuskan sesuatu yang menyentuh kepentingan rakyat khususnya dan Perak umumnya.
Tetapi peribadi luhur Sultan dan keluarga diraja tidak diendah malah peribadi dan kemuliaan pekerti baginda berdua dicerca dan dinista oleh anjing2 jalanan yang mula menyalak, melolong untuk mengajak rakyat menderhaka. Apakah bangsat2 ini kurang siuman, kurang ajar atau adakah ini satu paparan umum sikap dan perangai hodoh dan bobrok pemuka2 gerombolan bangsat2 ini?
Ini bukan kali pertama, mereka menghina Sultan Perak! Malah semasa upacara angkat sumpah dan kes Pengarah MAIP perkara serupa terserlah. Memang bedebah bangsat2 ini. Untuk Palestin tidak berani menyerbu dan membakar kedutaan US tetapi untuk anjing tambatan US sanggup baring diatas jalan dan membaling batu...Keparat semua. Tidak segan silu bak pondan menggunakan kanak2 dan perempuan pulak itu.. Memang manusia bobrok dan goblok yang perlu diganyang dan di ngap sayot. Manusia bejat moral yang muflis maruah diri dan yang sanubarinya diselubungi hasad dengki dan dendam kesumat yang tergamak mengapi2kan khalayak bagi kepentingan diri.
Wahai bangsat dan keparat, kamu tidak ada hak menyuarakan yang hak dan batil. Kamu haprak sehapraknya dan manusia bacul!. Kamu binatang yang patut di sula. Jangan berdalih dan bermuka2 dengan tindak tanduk kalian. Kepala butuh pak hang berani mencerca Raja yang hanya berpandukan lunas undang2. Jubuh mak hang nak menista baginda Sultan apabila keputusan tidak memihak kalian. Puki mak hang kerana berani memutarbelitkan fakta.Kalau anda mengaku Islam, adakah dua wanita yang diadili Nabi Sulaiman (as) memaki baginda Nabi apabila keputusan Nabi Sulaiman(as) tidak memihak mereka kendatipun mereka berdua kebutuhan keputusan memihak diri masing2!.
Jelas anda maknusia hipokrit, munafik jalanan!! Memetik Professor Emiritus Shahnon Ahmad : Shit!!! (U ALL)
Warrior 231
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteSome questioned the decision made by The Sultan of Perak. I think those who commented against the decision must take note that the Sultan was the Lord President of this country previously.
I hope those yang pandai pandai tu must sedar that you have not achieved wha he had achieved, that is to be the utmost in the judiciary.
He is only human but he also has lots of legal experience in law as well interpreting it.
Thus, you all just shut up..
I am a Perakian and i voted in Perak.
rocky, hang pun penuh dgn hasat dengki..patut la blog ni pun jadi sampah pecacai UMNO..camna UMNO nak terus idup kalau semua ahli macam hang ni rocky..semua nya pecacaiii..citsss jadi la org melayu islam...jgn kuat sgt hampa nya taksub dgn melayu UMNO tu..nnti kat dlm kuboq dia tak tanya hang parti mana la rocky woiii...ALLAH tanya hang dok tulis apa selama hang dok hidup ni..ni bukan pasai derhaka.ni pasal rakyat yg perlukan keadilan dari seorang sultan yg dikasihi.
ReplyDeletePetikan dari TukarTiub:
ReplyDelete"Mat saheh Kuasa Lama tidak berpuas hati. Dendam kesumat berkobar-kobar. Lalu mereka memainkan rasa benci orang Melayu terhadap Orang Cina. Kuasa Lama berpropaganda bahawa geran tanah ini di beri kepada Orang Cina. Orang Cina dijadikan alasan untuk menunjukkan bahawa Kuasa Rakyat ini adalah Kuasa Cina. Para pemimpin politik Kuasa Rakyat di Perak di tuduh sebagai ‘hamba Cina’.
Ini TIDAK betul. Data-data dan angka-angka resmi dari Kerajaan Perak menunjukkan Orang Melayulah yang mendapat lebih banyak geran tanah dari Orang Cina. Dalam projek memperbaiki kampong tersusun jumlah Orang Melayu lebih ramai. Pekara ini sengaja di tutup lingkup. Ini kerana Kuasa Lama mahukan Orang Melayu membenci Kuasa Rakyat di Perak."
Q; why dint the PR dissolve the State government when they were tottering by the abyss before the 3rd of february? makes u wonder doesnt it?
ReplyDeleteManusia hipokrit yang bacul dengan bayang2 sendiri akan kelentong bermati2an untuk melenyapkan kebenaran sesuatu hakikat
anyway read this:http://syamil-revert.blogspot.com/2008/09/croaking-from-underneath-coconut-shell.html
In one short piece, this blogfella dissects the King of Frogs with cutting edge sarcasm!!...LOL
Warrior 231
Really lazy to read through all the comments. If not said before
ReplyDelete(1) When Mamak Mahatir(MM) literally severed the balls of the Royalty by amending the constitution - every single UMNO legislator was for it - in fact they were cheering for support. For all you apologists our there - stick it up yours and stick it in deep.
(2)HINDRAF must be really really happy - Perak has a new Indian MB. Please lah - with out a caption under his photo - you would mistake Zamry for Muniandy.
Anyways cheers - Wise words for today - "Money Talks"
Cheers
Devilsadvocate
Ingat! Di sisi Allah, darjat manusia semua sama sahaja. Yang membezakannya ialah iman dan taqwa.
ReplyDeleteYang benar tetap benar dan yang salah tetap salah.
Sebab tu YB Nizar bertegas kerana dia yakin yang dia berada di pihak yang benar. Tabik hormat pada beliau.
I think highly of the Sultan of Perak as a formerly Lord President of Malaysia however he is just human like all of us and is able to be influence by other people.
ReplyDeleteMy source said that Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi who was brought by Najib to see the Sultan was the one who influence the sultan with a few "promises".
It is said that Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid is the MB in waiting. He currently cannot be MB as he is Member of Parliament and not a state assemblymen. He is also Njib most trusted man.
Democracy for Perak. Let the People of Perak choose their government. When we vote , we vote for a party not the individual, so these three have betray the people that voted for them.
Now they are talking about leaving it to the courts to decide. If the court does not find it to their favour, do you think they will abide the judgement? History has shown that this group will only accept judgements favourable to them. Even if there is a dissolution and if the rakyat picked BN, do you think they will accept it? They will also cry foul and accuse phantom voters lah.. EC biased lah and whatever reasons thay could grab because the judgement does NOT FAVOUR them! To these kind of people democracy is only when it favours them, period. Remember how they rioted when PAS lost Terengganu? Remember how they boycotted the swearing in of the new Govt.? Remember how they demonstrated in Rhu Sila and Wisma Darul Iman when the PEOPLE voted them out? Remember how they slammed the EC when they lost Terengganu? Remember how they PRAISED the EC when they won Terengganu in 1999? AND THEY HAVE THE GALL TO CALL THEMSELVES KETUANAN RAKYAT, PEOPLE'S POWER,etc?? BULLS***
ReplyDelete-Kesetiaan Kepada RAJA dan NEGARA!
Dear all,
ReplyDeleteCan anyone of you solve this puzzle? Thanks.
"Apa yang berlaku di Perak bakal menjadi lambang kejatuhan sistem beraja yang kini dijulang melebihi ajaran Islam itu sendiri. Elaun kerabat yang bermula RM 500.00 sebulan hatta mencecah RM 70,000.00 sebulan ( Perbelanjaan Tahunan mencecah jutaan) adalah sama sekali bertentangan dengan Islam kerana keturunan Nabi Muhammad SAW perlu berkerja untuk mendapat wang sejak zaman Rasulllah hingga sekarang. Apakah darah kerabat adalah mulia mengakibatkan mereka tidak perlu bekerja hanya kerana kebetulan keturunan yang mulia... Apakah beza mereka dengan manusia lain yang cacat terpaksa merayu dan merangkak untuk untuk mendapatkan sesuap nasi???"
For the first time I agree with Old Fart: why take two weeks to decide after March 8 as to who should be MB and only 2 hours now?
ReplyDeleteRaja adil raja di sembah....
No blind loyalty for me
mat taib
Hasnul Razak , 23, from Kuala Kangsar said: “Dissolving the state assembly is the best option so that peace can return.
ReplyDelete“BN is afraid of elections because the mood of the people is with the Pakatan Rakyat. We, the people, are with one heart asking the Sultan for his permission to dissolve the state assembly so that we can have elections.
“Even if the BN wins, at least it is the according to the rule of law and the Constitution.
BN is also trying to play with public sentiment by saying that we are defying the Sultan. That is not true becuse what we really want is just to follow the law.”
http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/index.php/malaysia/17886-the-people-say-
hi rocky,
ReplyDeleteaku ni bukan politicians, tak minat nak masuk politik hanya rakyat biasa. mungkin kebanyakan org mcm aku. aku bukan buta2 sokong raja, sebab aku baca sejarah, ada juga raja yg tak pandai nak jaga kepentingan rakyat, sign agreement yg akhirnya membawa padah kpd negeri , buat onar dsb... ada la sume tu..
aku tak suka juga kes lompat parti ni, pada aku tak memberikan rakyat the power to vote.
TETAPI, aku lagi tak suka pembesar melayu yg beragama islam,tetapi jadi boneka org kafir. aku tak suka juga org kena beli utk lompat parti (jika ini terjadi)tapi aku rasa antara org2 politik yg ada hari ni, tak satu pun yg jujur dalam mendapatkan kedudukan mereka. Mereka hanya pkir kepentingan mereka.
Dan aku lagi tak suka jika agama aku terpinggir satu hari nanti hanya untuk mengggembirakan org lain. yang malang sekali, pemimpin (tak kira BN atau BA) takut nak membuat polisi yg berasas kan agama Allah, sedangkan mereka tahu, ia adalah asas utk umat yg lebih kuat.
Aku benci dgn keadaan org politik yg bangang dan tamak harta dunia ni, sedangkan di bumi kita ni masih byk yg susah dan mundur.
Kiranya satu hari nanti, jiran tetangga kita menyerang, mcm kes Gaza, jgn sedih bila kita kekurangan kemampuan untuk melawan, sebab antara kita sesama islam pun tak tentu arah, ini pula dgn kaum lain, utk bersatu menentang musuh..yg kita tak tahu mungkin sudah menyelinap di dalam selimut kita sekarang ini utk melemahkan bangsa dan agama.
So, fikir2 kan laa.. utk org BN kalau dah kira menang tu, buat la agenda utk rakyat. buktikan korang dah sedar diri dari mabuk sebelum PRU12 dulu. to BA, terutama nizar sila lah berundur secara gentleman. Kita tak anggap u kalah pun, kita anggap u berundur utk kepentingan agama. Niat kena betul
aku yg bosan
Exposed!!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteCili padi from DAP, Fong Poh Kuan speaks!!!!!!
http://www.thesundaily.com/article.cfm?id=29835
WEB EDITION :: Local News
DAP leadership must deal with internal conflicts
by Kong See Hoh
newsdesk@thesundaily.com
IPOH (Feb 5, 2009) : While accusing fingers are being pointed at DAP assemblyman for Jelapang Hee Yit Foong for deserting the party, DAP MP for Batu Gajah Fong Po Kuan(pix) says Hee's departure underlines the need for the party's central as well as state leadership to take a serious view of its internal conflicts.
She told Sin Chew Daily on Wednesday the party must deal with the internal problems of Perak DAP head-on, understand what has gone wrong and look for solutions.
Three-term Fong, dupped cili padi because of her fiery style, dropped a bombshell on the party before the general election last year with her announcement that she was not going to defend her Batu Gajah seat, but changed her mind after much persuasion from the party top leadership.
She told the daily that Perak DAP's internal problems were not taken seriously before the March 8 elections, and neither were they resolved after the elections, allowing members' discontent against party leaders to brew.
Fong said this was the reason she did not contest any post in the state in the last party elections.
It was also learnt that Hee quit the party mainly because she deemed the appointment of state exco members not transparent and because she could not get along with Perak DAP state chief and senior executive councillor, Datuk Ngeh Koo Ham, and his cousin Nga Kor Ming, who is DAP state secretary and a state exco member.
Hee, who is deputy state assembly speaker, had said the state exco should have a Chinese woman and that Ngeh and Nga, who are both lawyers, were best suited for the posts of speaker and deputy speaker respectively.
"Hee Yit Foong has been unhappy since. Her resignation from the party shows that the internal conflicts are coming to a boil," said Fong.
"The fact that the post of deputy speaker is ranked above an exco member does not help, as the exco members wield greater power and get bigger perks (than the Speaker and Deputy Speaker), the same way that ministers have more power than the parliament Speaker and Deputy Speakers."
Updated: 02:56PM Thu, 05 Feb 2009
mungkin hanya orang perak yang tahu kenapa begitu tindakan mereka dan kenapa hati mereka begitu tercalar. mereka mengundi lain, tapi lain yang sudahnya bentuk kerajaan. melayu perak ni masih mewarisi semangat nasionalisme melayu maharaja lela agaknya.
ReplyDeletecapri
It is so clear and crisp, neither emotional nor bombastic. To me this sane and honest view is worth reproducing, dengan izin:
ReplyDeletemat taib
FEB 7 — Historically, before the existence of Malaysia, the Malay states fell into the hands of the imperialists due to greed and power. It was about the power struggle amongst the royalty which eventually led to the colonisation of the states.
Pre-Merdeka, with the emergence of the insurgencies by the left, a "deal" was struck among the capitalists, the royalty, the royalists and the imperialists with the sole purpose of maintaining and guarding "their" positions and influence in Malaya. The collateral outcome of the "deal" was the independence of Malaya. It was a decision motivated by the need to protect and safeguard the vested interests of these actors. It was not about the rakyat. It has never been!
Fast forward 52 years after independence, we see how the same actors have again colluded to stage a modern day "coup" in the state of Perak. Again, this was not done in the interests of the rakyat. Those who have heard about the true colours and the personality/ies of the various decision-maker(s) will not be surprised by the recent decision(s).
Ultimately, one important question that needs to be answered is "what's in it for me?". That was the question that Pakatan Rakyat could not answer.
No doubt there are several legal and moral issues that have arisen from the Perak fiasco. But the real issue that irks the rakyat is the fact that the capitalists and the royalty have robbed the state government from the rakyat.
Regarding the legality of the Sultan's decision to call for the resignation of the menteri besar, I am prepared to say that the decision is wrong in law. Based on the Perak Constitution, the MB does not hold office at the pleasure of the Sultan.
The only way the MB goes is by way of a no-confidence motion in the State Legislative Assembly. The Sultan cannot just ask MB to vacate his office.
Article 16(6) of the Perak Constitution states that:
If the Menteri Besar ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Legislative Assembly, then, unless at his request His Royal Highness dissolves the Legislative Assembly, he shall tender the resignation of the Executive Council.
The question then is: who decides whether the MB ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the State Legislative Assembly? Should it be the Sultan or the State Legislative Assembly? How and where should such issues be decided?
The answers to these questions are obvious. Matters of grave importance that affect the interests of the state should be decided in the hall of the State Legislative Assembly, NOT along the corridors or halls of the palace.
The next question then is: who holds the majority at the State Legislative Assembly?
To answer this question, one must first ascertain the status of the three so-called "independent" members who have tendered their resignations. There is a dispute in relation to their status as members of the State Legislative Assembly. Their views therefore should not be taken into account until their status have been definitely resolved.
Against this background, how can anyone say that the Barisan Nasional commands the majority?
Some have replied saying that since the Election Commission did not recognise the resignation letters of the three "independent" members, therefore they are still members of the State Legislative Assembly.
This throws up the further question whether the EC has the power and jurisdiction to adjudicate on the status of the resignations.
From the legal perspective, the EC has exceeded its jurisdiction. There is nothing under the Election Commission Act 1957 and the Elections Act 1958 that confers power to the EC to adjudicate on such matters. Consequently, the EC's decision on this matter is ultra vires and is of no effect. Unless the decision by the speaker to declare the seats vacant is set aside or overturned by a court of law, the EC must accept the decision of the speaker. However, we have witnessed how the EC has facilitated the "coup" by disregarding the speaker's decision.
Leaving aside the legal questions — on desirability — in view that the current political scenario in Perak is fragile and uncertain, coupled with the fact that there is no guarantee there will not be any further and sudden defections that may affect the composition of the State Legislative Assembly, the best decision to make is to have dissolved the State Legislative Assembly.
Unfortunately, wisdom may not be the virtue of some.
Who will benefit from this episode? The "decision-makers"? Those who "orchestrated" the situation?
Unless the question of "what's in it for me?" is fully answered, then no one will receive the truth.
The state of Perak was robbed by the capitalists and the monarchy.
The fate of the state should not lie in the hands of allegedly corrupted politicians and a Sultan. It should be in the hands of the rakyat! Let the people of Perak decide the fate of their state through fresh elections.
For the record, I am not a monarchist or a royalist. I have little admiration for slogans such as "Daulat Tuanku" and the related "mumbo-jumbo". Some may say that this article and the fact that I am doubting the wisdom of the Sultan of Perak may be construed as an act of "derhaka" (disloyalty). As far as I am concerned the issue of "menderhaka" does not arise.
And my reply is "derhaka terhadap siapa?" Can I "derhaka" towards an institution that I don't believe in? Can I "derhaka" towards an institution that ignores the will of the rakyat?
It is apt for us to be reminded of what Hang Jebat once said:
"Jangan! Jangan sembah aku. Aku bukan gila disembah. Aku bukan sebagai Sultan Melaka yang mengagung-agungkan pangkat dan kebesarannya. Aku Jebat, rakyat biasa. Pangkat aku untuk kepentingan rakyat. Bergerak aku untuk membuat jasa kepada rakyat, dan aku rela mati untuk rakyat.. kerana aku mahu keadilan, keadilan. Keadilan!"
The time is ripe for a revolution.
So are you game?
Salam revolusi! — www.loyarburok.com
I thought BN could pull a stunt in Sabah in 1994 in taking over the State Government then because the leaders there were stupid and did not know how to protect their own turf from being ravaged upon. I did not know that in Perak itself, the BN could do the same thing. Sama sama lah stupid both East and West politicians sometimes.
ReplyDeleteBodoh Bodoh Jua
sekarang adalah time BN.. so suporter PR kutuk BN habis2an.
ReplyDeletemungkin 2-3 bulan lagi, si katak tu lompat balik ke PR. Pastu sultan kasi PR pegang balik jawatan MB.
agaknya masa tu mesti mereka kata sultan adalah adil, baik, bla bla bla....
pendek kata penyokong PR ni semua tak gentleman. they dont know how to accept lose.
tah apa-apa la korang...
yg benar
Orang Jauh.
## gua support re-election!
Old fart please read article by 'Voice' on real politic and power struggle.Jangan baca DSAI and Haris blog saja
ReplyDeleteYou don't subscribe to any political party and why u should insult the Sultan unless u are pro PR.U nak tunjuk yang u bagi nuetral opinion...sudah la
Sultan has to make decision because he has tanggungjawap therhadap rakyat.U don't have any tanggungjawab that why u can say anything to Sultan.
Sultan terpaksa membuat keputusan sebab Nizar tak berani untuk memanggil sidang tergempar Adun untuk undi tak percaya cause he know the outcome..he just want to buy time
Shamsul said the act of asking for 'pembubaran' menunjukkan dia hilang kepercayaan majoriti.
Everybody can give all the facts but as rakyat yang tidak memihak mana mana parti please don't insult Sultan.PR memerintah dengan BN memerintah sama saja...dah 50 tahun BN memerintah OLd Fart tak mati pun...dapat guna internet lagi..
Anyhow if u thing snap election is the best solution...my questions is if the outcome PR win on simple majority and once again berlaku deflection...so we going to have another election...
fikir fikir sama bro
Who knows if the Sultan is afraid Najib will C4 him and his son if the Sultan doesn't agree to stand with him?
ReplyDeleteJust my 2 cents.
saya amat hairan, kenapa PAS yang hanya mempunyai 2 kerusi ADUN yang begitu lantang membela kerajaan PR yang tumbang sedangkan DAP yang mempunyai majoriti dan menguasai kerajaan perak serta menentukan segala dasar tiada bersuara langsung. Tiada demontrasi jalanan oleh puak-puak DAP tetapi PAS yang mendokong ISLAM (Agama yang cintakan keamanan) dan yang bersultankan Sultan MELAYU garang memperjuangkan hak DAP. Dimanakah pakar-pakar agama, dimanakan semangat kemelayuan?? SULTAN kita di caci, agama kita dihina. Bayangkan benteng terakhir ini roboh, lagi mudahlah Karpal Singh menidakkan hak melayu, hak AGAMA kita. makin banyak lah tanah melayu tergadai, makin kurangla pembelaan orang melayu.
ReplyDeleteSaya tidak menyokong BN pada PRU yang lalu tetapi terpanggil untuk menegakkan hak melayu dan agama islam dalam kancah politik yang semakin sonsang ini. apabila perkara-perkara yang berkaitan dengan melayu dan agama di sentuh saya rasa semua orang melayu perlu bersatu mempertahankannya. Jangan jadi Melaka, akibatnya semua tergadai.
RENUNG-RENUNGKAN LAH.
Rocky
ReplyDeleteThis is a grand design to turn this country into a republic!
rocky,
ReplyDeletewhy was there no outcry when the people of trengganu insulated our our king over the appointmemt of the M.B. was it because UMNO was involved. why the double standards now. why was there no cry of treason then.
daulat tuanku, daulat tuanku.
ReplyDeletekalau sultan takde, hak orang melayu akan pupus.
Disebabkan oleh 4 ekor katak je, Perak jadi huru-hara..
ReplyDeleteBelalah katak 4 ekor tu elok2..
Tahniah BN..
-Seladang
Dear Rocky,
ReplyDeleteIntrerpretasi undang2 cenderung jika melihat apa objektif dan siapa yang menginterpretasikannya.
Kalau PR, mesti mahu memperlihatkan bahawa undang2 diterjemah agar memihak kpd PR.
Mungkin beberapa artikel dari Harakahdaily ini akan memulangkan paku buah keras kembali kepada PR. Artikel dan interpretasi undang2 yang dibuat di bawah adalah ketika Brader Anwar Bin Ibrahim mahu menumbangkan kerajaan Pusat:
Notis usul tidak perlu 14 hari - Prof Dr Aziz Bari
http://www.harakahdaily.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=15310&Itemid=1
Pembubaran Parlimen terletak di tangan Agong
http://www.harakahdaily.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=12222&Itemid=90
Yang di-Pertuan Agong boleh bertindak - Aziz Bari
http://www.harakahdaily.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=17063&Itemid=50
Agong tidak boleh bubar Parlimen sesuka hati
http://www.harakahdaily.net/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=12232&Itemid=50
Pilihan raya semula bertentangan dengan Perlembagaan - Aziz Bari
http://www.harakahdaily.net/bm/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=14797&Itemid=50
Tak perlu lagi berhujah panjang lebar menjustifikasikan apa yang sudah muktamad diputuskan oleh Sultan Perak. Ada suruh buat pilihanraya etc etc. Ada suruh bubar. Ada cakap Sultan perlu dibimbing. Untuk apa perdebatan sebegini? Akur & junjung titah Tuanku dengan rasa penuh keinsafan. Tutup mulut yang celupar. Kepada yang mempunyai latar belakang undang2 jgn berlagak pandai (sorry to say that) sehinggakan terlupa bahawa segala pendapat kita sebenarya menjatuhkan & mencalar imej baik Sultan Perak.
Yang pastinya, semua yg memberikan komen yang merendah2kan keputusan yang dibuat oleh Sultan Perak adalah biadap! (And again, sorry to say that).
Common guys! Manners! Its our Sultan Melayu! Have some respect pls!
Dengan izin:
http://kembarapolitik.blogspot.com/2009/02/kesetiaan-kepada-raja-dan-negara.html
I just could not believe that BN would provide PR with a maximum four year lead time to canvass for the next election that will see the end of BN and its outdated vision.
ReplyDeleteThis Perak episode is a fantastic showcase in favour of PR, I must say.
To hell with the proposed legal action involving the royalty and the pro-BN justifications from legal experts.
The simple 'rakyat' do not need such 'fluff' which does not help the ordinary folks at all.
PR now can develop long term strategies from now till the next elections, structured well with supporters well trained to speak up at ceramahs in Perak at regular PR gatherings.
PR establishment in other states can also use this 'shining' example to start telling the rakyat what to expect if the current DPM is allowed to hold office after AAB leaves.
Previously, PR had difficulty to give an example of how the DPM and his 'gang' can behave in politics. But now no need to try hard for a real example.
(no need things like ongoing 'scapegoat' court cases, Port Dickson drama etc).
And the BN friendly state assembly persons should be around, holding office, till the next elections.
They are the living examples of what the PR supporters SHOULD NOT ELECT. This is also the type of candidate that the PR team SHOULD NOT nominate.
And by the way, there is also a business opportunity for the creative ones as well.
How about designing toilet bowls and urinals with the area where discharge our stuff, designed as the mouth of any one of these three 'friendly' ADUNs? The remaining parts of these two toilet stuff can feature the faces of the two legged frogs who ceated history?
And can sell these at the 3 consitituencies first, with sales expansion to other DUN constituencies in Perak?
At least the rakyat can install these in their homes and have the satisfaction that everyday they are:
a. giving it back to the 'friendly' ADUNs
b. remembering everyday not to vite for such frogs.
Imagine the money one can make out of this situation. Those who benefit should also contribute part of the proceeds back to the 'friendly' ADUNs - goodwill money for showing a business opportunity? Have a press conference for such donations handover - invite the global TV stations operating in Malaysia for this event? Can go into the worldwide media easily and put 'Malaysian' politics in the international map?
By the way, no harm - getting petitions signed also. In fact in each of the consitituencies, the structured petition should have coloumns for names, IC no, DUN registration no (which the PR parties will have) and the signature of the voters.
Better still if the final tally is over and above (in fact very much in excess of) the actual people who voted for the 'friendly' ADUNs in March 2008.
Then post the outcome in the blogs and make sure extend a certified true copy to Rocky as well - for he believes in the power of the rakyat as well.
By the way, anyone paying attention to Kedah and negeri Sembilan - scouting for frogs?
It seems there has been a sharp increase of this amphibian (correct apelling?) in these two states after the encouraging 'lawful' change of government in Perak.
Views on the Perak Sultan's decision?
I can only say such things freely if I am from UMNO. Then I can take sides as I please - like in Terengganu and Perlis last year (March 2008) or in Perak this month. (It does not matter whether it is 'for' or 'aganist' as this is a self-created UMNO privilege - not for others, even the second class component parties of BN).
And how about a bit of history to top it up. Its about how 'outside' help restored the 'rightful' ruler and , subsequently his decendants as successors.
In 1871, when Sultan Ali, the ruler of Perak died the Raja Muda or the next in line ruler, should have been appointed as the next Sultan of Perak but Raja Bendahara Raja Ismail was elected instead.
The reason being, Raja Abdullah was not present during the burial of the late Sultan Ali.
To cut the short story shorter, through the Pangkor Treaty of 1874 (you should know the parties involved), Raja Abdullah was acknowledged as the legitimate Sultan to replace Sultan Ismail who would be given a title and a pension of 1000 Mexican pesos a month.
The Sultan would receive a British Resident whose advice had to be sought and adhered to in all matters except those pertaining to the religion and customs of the Malays.
Raja Ismail did not attend the meeting arranged between Sir Andrew Clarke and Raja Abdullah.
Raja Ismail obviously did not recognize the agreement but he had no choice against the alliance between Raja Abdullah and the British.
As a result, Raja Abdullah was made Sultan and Sir James W.W. Birch was appointed as Perak's first British Resident after the treaty came into force.
And by the way, you all know what happended to Birch after that?
History has a unique way of reminding us that there should be extra care when handling the current Perak situation, arising from the decision by the 3 to become BN friendly.
But the way it has been bulldozed 'legally'...... we are creating another history where the 'rakyat' will teach a lesson to those who did not follow correct procedures.
ANOTHER MALAYSIAN
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteWhat more to say? Yes, this time I sure agree with RPK...
Rocky, the problem does not lie in whether we respect or disrespect the sultan's decision. The problem lies in history repeats itself. Ketuanan rakyat means that rakyat has the right to choose. Not willing to dissolve means taking away our rights to do so. Over 50 yrs of BN in power, where is M'sia heading? Nonetheless there are worse countries compared to M'sia but comparing with the worst does not bring u any further ahead. We shld look forward and continually improve. Just because it has been doesn't mean that it should be.
ReplyDeleteRocky,
ReplyDeleteWelcome back. I guess when a push become a shove, the color of the skin, the sepet of the eyes, batang bersunat atau tidak, matters a lot.
Let just Nizar be the only one who return to his root.
Daulat Tuanku.
Datuk Seri Rocky (very soon),
ReplyDeleteLook what happens to so called Raja in India and Nepal.
Sooner or later all the kerabat -kerabat in all states will be looking for job. Curently we are sponsoring them evry thing.
Rasta
Just because The sultan did not call for election..PR supporters say The sultan has made a mistake..please laa that is his prerogrative..u like or u dont like, accept laa in good faith..bodoh punya olang PR
ReplyDeleteprbangang
Please view the bitmap on the webpage whose URL I give here:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.2shared.com/file/4827104/d24c5cae/pr_online.html
The bitmap contains the following text:
"We take care of citizens, residents and visitors; we work to enrich and improve their lives.": these words should be chiseled into the facade of every Malaysia government building. Whether in Selangor, Kedah or Penang, the primary occupation of a Pakatan Rakyat state administration should be wise management of land and territory, and the physical and spiritual welfare of people.
RAJA ADIL RAJA DISEMBAH.... RAJA ZALIM RAJA DI SANGGAH......
ReplyDeleteRocky:
ReplyDeleteYou brown-nosed Mamakthir, and now you brown-nose the Sultan of Perak. You sure you can breathe will all the brown stuff on your nose ?
Godfather
move on dick heads...
ReplyDeletebetter things to worry. for pakatantat - next time pls vet your hopeless MPs before putting them for rep rakyat. sorry to say all tak boleh harap and below average low class suckers out for $$$$$$..
same goes with chinaapek DAP. to NAJIBAN - well done. but make sure be prepared for a backlash in the next GE.
Mat Sontot-
KL Timur
Dear Bru
ReplyDeleteThe Law of Kinetics acting in Malaysia in the last year or so has not been in BN's favour. The energy generated by the people can be likened to Winds of Anger blowing against the BN and the winds have not abated, but rather has become stronger as shown at the PP and KT by elections.
I doubt that the UMNO MB for Perak can stop this ill provoked by BN's actions. I foresee him being blown away by this extraordinary anger mounting against the BN...The irony of it is that a Mamak is given the post of MB. How this will go with UMNO and the public will play out soon enough! Maybe only a Mamak can withstand the Headwind!
Lip services and outpouring of money and favours are seen as short term measures to placate this ill wind. Public Anger is harder to contain though, what with the mainstream media spin provoking further the Public's disappointment at losing their right to choose!!
DalaiLlama
I think RPK' comments are the most succint.
ReplyDeleteThe Sultan was acting within his rights and was trying to be as non-political as possible. he was according UMNO the same opportunity that he gave Pakatan last March. I think everyone needs to take a timeout - assess the situtation and work within the system to change things through the ballot box.
The issue is not the Sultan's decision but the fact that a couple of monkeys are making a lot of money manipulating UMNO and Pakatan.
In future Pakatan needs to ensure they pick more quality people whose interest is public service not greed.
Shariff
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteWhen Mahathir do it, it's all ok with you right?
But when PR do it, u write articles like this, your style never change, boring and taking sides.
Ali Yakob
Dear Rocky,
ReplyDeleteHow glad I am for what you did in this campain..
Daulat Tuanku! Daulat Tuanku! Daulat Tuanku!
I can see that sifat 'kesetiaan kpd Raja dan Negara' among non-malays are handful only even we can read it thru from the comments in your blog.
I was sad to see MB Nizar's action for the past few days. It is shameful to Malay, and I feel shame that I have voted for the CHANGE. He should have just let go the post, and advise all suppoters not to go against the Ruler as a good leader behavior, keep serving his rakyat regardless whether you are MB or not. Win again next election.. If he were to do this, he and the party will earn my respect. He should not be influenced by Anwar's or Karpal's , N&N's advice..
I am very disappointed with all the people and the party that I voted for..They are no differnce, just another power hungry people. Just cant imagine if they are to be in power for 50 years, may be worse than BN..
Disapponted Rakyat.
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteKita semua tahu bahawa cara yang baik untik menjatuhkan kerajaan Melayu ada lah dengan langkah pertama ia itu mengaibkan kesultanan Melayu. Kita semua tahu bahawa bangsa China dan India di negara ini senantiasa berdoa supaya suatu hari nanti "cengkaman" Melayu yang mereka anggapkan dan bedoa akan berakhir suatu hari nanti. Jadi kitul kitul saperti Anwar Ibrahim dan Nizar Jamaluddin kesemua nya mereka ini sedap dahulu, tetapi kesalan kemudian itu akan di terjemahkan di mana mereka akan lari dari negera ini jika berlaku tumpahan darah di antara kaum. Ini memang boleh dan akan berlaku jika extremist extremist tidak di bendung dari mula.
Kerajaan yang di terajui oleh pemimpin yang kuat dan teguh tahu bagaimana hendak membendung. Pada hemat says dollah badawi ada lah sudah menjadi makhluk perosak bangsa Melayu yang harus di singkirkan sebagai pemimpin Melayu dengan segera! Wassallam!
I am a Perakian Malaysian Chinese, rockybru.
ReplyDeleteAnd I find the acts of the Pakatan Rakyat absurd.
Although I am a Chinese, I respect my Sultan and especially Raja Nazrin Shah.
The acts of the Pakatan Rakyat supporters attacking the Raja Muda is certainly shameful.
I certainly would have defended and protected Raja Nazrin if I was there.
My advice to the Pakatan Rakyat - if they are unhappy, the only solution is to bring it to Court.
Leave my Sultan and Raja Muda out of this political struggle.
Jangan derhaka dan bertindak ganas terhadap Tuanku dan Raja Muda.
Regards,
Wei Liang Goh
Manifestogwl.blogspot.com
Forgive me. Tapi rakyat yang letih kerja untuk menyuap mereka. At least listen to the rakyat.
ReplyDeleteI am sorry, you have ignored the monarchy institution for a few times why is this different...it is because it is done by Pakatan Rakyat?
ReplyDeleteThe recent example is the Fatwa against yoga the BN goverment never respected the KINGS to consult them has Islamic heads of the states?
Siapakah yang memberi perkenan kepada najib, mewar-warkan 'kejatuhan Kerajaan Pakatan Rakyat Perak' kepada B'end, di Putra Jaya. Apakah tindakannya itu bukan menderhaka kepada DYMM Sultan namanya. Lebih-lebih lagi apabila kaedah beliau memperolehi kelebihan majoriti mengatasi Pakatan Rakyat adalah songsang, menyimpang jauh dari maksud sebenar dan menyalahi peraturan undang-undang tubuh dan perlembagaan negeri Perak.Suatu tindakan yang tidak bertanggungjawab dan mencabul kedaulatan dan kehormatan institusi Dewan perundangan Negeri Perak yang Mulia. Hakikat sebenar, seorang Menteri Besar hanya boleh melepaskan jawatan eksekutifnya dalam Kerajaan Negeri setelah beliau kehilangan kepercyaan dan sokongan dalam sidang Dewan Undangan Negeri yang resmi, melalui"vote of confidence" yang di tujukan terhadap beliau. Dengan itu bolehlah beliau membubar DUN/Legislative Assembly dan meletakakan jawatan, bagi diserahkan kembali kepada rakyat untuk pemilihan raya yang baru diadakan semula. Apa saja cara yang selain dari itu adalah sepatutnya dihukum sebagai suatu rampasan kuasa yang haram dan tidak sah.
ReplyDeleteTNYHRM
Dear Rocky,
ReplyDeletePlease lets focus on the really victims here DEMOCRACY and the People of perak.
The parents who are feeding duit haram to their children.
The riff of the poor and richer will further gain width.
The land , water and sooner will be air that will be monopolised by the BN goverment for the pockets of the few. I don't believe you all never fight for the WATER ISSUES....why!!Why does the federal government need to control the water.
a transparent govt. and bribe free govt.
Please focus back on the cause and stop the blame game and write a blog so people will focus more on the real victims.
PLEASE DON"T FALL INTO THE TRAP SET BY BN...to break the peoples spirit by fighting with each other.
FOCUS...FOCUS..victims PEOPLE OF PERAK.
From one of the pro-Pakatan blogger
ReplyDeletehttp://muststopthis.blogspot.com/2009/02/loyalty-to-king-and-country.html
Can you see it?
Sunday, February 08, 2009
Loyalty to King and Country
Given the circumstances, I stand by HRH Sultan of Perak. Though he is not my current King, he was years ago. I always saw him as one who is knowledgeable, and regal, of course.
When I took part in the bersih march, I honestly believed in the cause to ask the intervention from the royal household to ensure free and fair elections. On March 8, it was indeed free and fair. I was also told on that day, that the King did mobilise a mechanized division to the palace grounds to ensure the safety of the people gathered there. Though, today, I seriously doubt that it happened. In fact, those who would like you to think that the 'people power' that came about will be able to change the government from BN to PR. So to convince you, statements like this are made. Well, I was a happy camper then.
I was sure my King would protect his subjects. But to the extent of believing in the next guy just to convince yourself?
And now, given the turnaround in Perak, I stand by HRH Sultan of Perak in his decision. Though, again, you are lead to believe that HRH was 'co-erced' to make this decision, I have confidence in him to have made a knowledgeable one.
Let those who wish to commit treason carry on with their actions. I am sure if one thing, if HRH made the decisioin to dissolve the Perak assembly, he would have been hailed a hero by PR and thier supporters, and BN would have to accept it. Not stage a sit in, and not hold on to power, as in the case of the MB.
I still support change, but if BN changes to rule better, I am also in support of it.
Annuar has been beaten in his own game, one that he has convinced himself that he has mastered. He certainly did not see this coming, and is now as usual, singing the 'victim' song.
I don't support stone throwing and crowd incitement to obtain power.
Posted by muststopthis at 13:10 0 comments
Today these 2 top personalities of PR have given the last straw to the Anwar.
ReplyDelete1. pro-Pakatan blogger RPK has spoken, clear and loud against the leadership of PR.
http://mt.m2day.org/2008/content/view/17783/84/
What more to say?
Saturday, 07 February 2009 15:32
NO HOLDS BARRED
Raja Petra Kamarudin
2. Karpal Singh has asked Anwar Ibrahim to step down as PR leader.
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2009/2/8/nation/20090208160159&sec=nation
Published: Sunday February 8, 2009
Updated: Sunday February 8, 2009 MYT 6:50:44 PM
Karpal asks Anwar to step down (Update 2)
By MANJIT KAUR
GEORGE TOWN: Pakatan Rakyat de facto leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim should step down for causing trouble in the coalition, DAP national chairman Karpal Singh said.
The Bukit Gelugor MP is blaming Anwar for “creating trouble,” and said that the former deputy prime minister “needed to repent without further betraying the people and their trust.”
He said Pakatan Rakyat needed another leader, a good leader, and lashed out at PKR and DAP leaders who had fallen sway to Anwar’s rhetoric in supporting crossovers of elected representatives.
What's the issue here? The PR lost the support of the majority of the elected assemblymen, and someone else commanding the majority was appointed leader of the state. Does it matter whether this was done by the Sultan after veryfying majority support or by the state assembly after a vote of no confidence?
ReplyDeleteThe PR would have stalled a vote of no confidence and attempted a dissolution when they had no such power by virtue of their having lost the majority.
Further, the Sultan in his wisdom may have also considered sparing the people another round of elections to the assembly and probably would have been happy with any party commanding a simple majority to continue, even if only to give the PR some practice in the procedures of a democracy!
This episode and PR's blatant transgression of all the conventions and institutions of an advanced democracy only confirms our argument PR didn't win because of any great merit, but because people's disillusionment with BN. The fundamental issues of defection from Vision 2020 and lack of a credible leadership remains.
-PRAXIS
Haaa nak sangat main lompat2 kan.
ReplyDeleteSuke sangat nak suruh org lompat sana sini kan.
Dari tahun lepas dok sebok2 suh org lompat kan.
Skang nie org dah lompat.. sudah lah. ape lagi tak puas hati?
Sendiri punya Game terkene batang hidung sendiri.
Bila tak puas hati bawak, buat perhimpunan pi gaduh ngan polis.
Buat huru hara sana sini. Mana keamanan negara kita kalau mcm ni? kalau asyik nak berpolitik? Sampai kan kete Sultan pun kene blok.. isk isk isk. Kurang Hajar Tahap Melampau Langsung tidak menghormati Kuasa DIraja.
8 march dah lama berakhir, sudah2 la tuh berpolitik nak tarik sana tarik sini, lompat sana sini. tipu sana sini. Sudah2 lah tuh. kalau asyik nak politik kalau asyik nak gila kuasa bila nyaa nak buat kerja? Rakyat tetap kene carik makan, pk diri keluarga dan masa depan?
BUkan paklah atau anwar yg nak kasik rakyat makan. Rezki semua kami cari sendiri. Tapi kalau pemimpin tak adakan peluang meningkatkan peluang perniagaan, pembangunan ekonomi serta insan mcm mana rakyat dan negara nak maju?
Kalau asyik nak politik, kalau asyik nak undi, kalau asyik nak mandat. Mandat yg dah diberikan pun tatau jaga. Lepas tuh buat perhimunan resakser, lepas nih rusuhan, tak puas hati lagi buat mcm dulu kumpul ramai2 kat masjid negara mintak simpati.
BN dulu kalah 5 negeri takder pun buat perhimpunan? takde pun buat rusuhan? tapi kenapa PR suke benar mencipta rusuhan? menganggu ketenteraman org awam? Saya pun rakyat juga, saya pun ada hak juga untuk meminta semua keganasan dihentikan. Aku pun rakyat MALAYSIA juga. Saya tidak suka semua perkembangan ini. Nak lawan.. lawan di arena politik.
PR perak mula2 kata, Kerajaan mereka kukuh, tak kukuh pun.
mula2 jatuh mintak perkenan Sultan, Lepas tuh kata semuanya terpulang pada keputusan sultan, namun kini SUltan dah bagi keputusan. mereka Lawan pulak lagi.. ape punye jenis manusia kau org nih ha? Cakap tak pernahnya btol.
Semenjak kemunculan DSAI, ramai org telah mula kurang hajar terhapdap pemimpin serta undang2. Mereka buat secara suka hati mereka. Kalau dikutkan dari dulu pada PR polis salah, lawyer salah, hakim salah, menteri salah, ACA salah, EC salah, skang ni SUltan pun salah, dan mereka saje lah yg betol. (Mcm perangai yahudi buat sesuka hati, kekecohan sana sini tapi tuding jari kat org lain)
DSAI selalu berkata dalam ceramahnya, “Insyallah with gods willing mereka akan tubuh kerajaan baru” Namun kini Alhamdulillah dengan keizinan Ilahi semua ini telah berlaku. Apakah ini takdir, qada’ n qadar ketentuan ilahi.
Dan apakah ini spt ape yg mereka selalu katakan, kebenaran akan terbukti jua akhirnya. Marilah kita ambil iktibar dan memanfaat kan perkembangan yg positif ini ke arah pembangunan ummah dan negara
Namun ape yg boleh diperkatakan dengan senario ini oleh PR
YG DIKEJAR TAK DAPAT, YG DIKENDONG BERCICIRAN
P/s: Dulu DSAI nak merampas kerajaan dengan MP lompat takde sape pun cakap ape2. skang nih baru lah nak melatah bukan2.
oi sudah2 la politik tuh, bila mau buat kerja? Kami Rakyat Mau Cari Makan Utk diri keluar masyarakat dan masa depan. dengan ucapan main la lompat2 lagi.
Sarawak outta of Malaysia, We dont need sultan or agung. Kami nak merdeka dari kelemahan sistem monarki semenanjung!
ReplyDeleteI for one as any Perakian love my Sultan and the Raja Muda.
ReplyDeleteBro, we don't want the royalty to be taken for a ride by those BN leeches.
Karpal to Anwar: Step down as Pakatan head
ReplyDeleteFeb 8, 09 5:54pm
In an outburst that could have deep implications for the Pakatan Rakyat alliance, DAP chairperson Karpal Singh today openly urged Anwar Ibrahim to step down as the leader of the alliance.
He blamed Anwar for the disarray in Pakatan which was caused by the PKR leader's continuous rhetoric of forming government with the aid of defectors from Barisan Nasional.
malaysia is fast falling apart..especially wit the current regime..
ReplyDeleteKami tak setuju ,apabila sahaja BN berkuasa di Perak , menteri Besar di lantik oleh pihak tingkat empat putrajaya.
ReplyDeleteMana boleh? Sudahkah kita siasat siapa dia ni Dato? Bolehkah kita percaya Dr Zambry ? Sudah 48 tahun saya duduk di perak tak pernah pun mendengar nama dia , baru minggu lepas. Untuk menjadi ketua menteri atau wakil negeri , kenalah dicalunkan dan mendapat sokongan padu dalam BN diperingkat negeri barulah boleh diterima. Ini bukan pakai hentam saja!
Mudahnya kita lupa bahawa Dr Mahathir telah melantik DS Abdullah Badawi untuk menggantikan tempatnya dalam UMNO enam tahun yg lampau tanpa pengundian dan sokongan akar umbi.Lihatlah apakah nasib yang telah melanda arena politik negaraku? Tidakkah kita serik dengan perlantikkan yang membabi buta sebegini.Mahukah kita mengulangi kesilapan Dr Mahathir yang lepas?
ello Rocky,
ReplyDeleteKau jangan peduli apa dia org kat sini cakap pasal "kau kena bayar" atau tidak. They never see it any other way. Kalau kau cakap fasal puji PKR, DAP atau PAS dia org kata kau adil dan saksama. Tapi, bila kau puji UMNO atau BN , kau akan dituduh kena bayar. Jgn penat menyampaikan hujah kau.
p/s aku harap kau memang tak kena bayar hahaha..
Aku yg muak dan bosan
The patience and restraint of HRH has the limit. The last thing he wants to do is strip Nizar from his title and chase him out from the state.
ReplyDeleteDAULAT TUANKU AND LONG LIVE THE KING
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteTukar topic la bro..dah panjang menjela-jela comments kat sini...banyak takleh pakai pun..at least now we know where you stand. Congrats bro. Melayu sejati sanggup dicaci mempertahankan keDaulatan Negara. Admirable. Well done. Many of us are for your campaign too.
Ok, can we discuss Karpal against Anwar now? Terkejut badak kot orang PKR..Karpal dah karam and he's taking Anwar down with him.
penyapujagat said...
ReplyDeleteTuan Penyapu hang patut masuk raja lawak nanti lita orang undi mu yek...
STUPID AMNO, GETTING THE NEW MB GOING ROUND OPENLY BRIBING THE INDIANS & CHINESE TO SUPPORT HIM.
ReplyDelete$100K HERE, A FEW HUNDRED K THERE...
THINK THE INDIANS & CHINESE ARE BEGGARS KE?
GUESS AMNO WILL NEVER CHANGE, TO THEM ONLY MONEY WILL KAOTIM EVERYTHING.
'SIC' HOW THESE MALAYS COULD END UP TO BE SO CORRUPTED...
MAKES ONE WONDER IF THEY STILL BELIEVE IN GOD. NUH! DON'T THINK SO!
Finally RPK has woken up. His comments is fair weather stuff but he nailed some hard hitting facts about the stupid PKR leaders and their low calibre machais.
ReplyDeleteNow, this will make RPK a bad boy and the PKR thugs might want to sue him for that.
Wonder if Zorro realises what RPK said or will he still throw stones on the glass house?
And what is this? Karpal wants the saintly Anwar to resign? He must be nuts. Anwar will bring demons to demonSTRATE in front of his house and sue Karpal till he goes bankcrupt over this. Karpal should apologise for this blunder.
A GOOD MAN DOES NOTHING.
hello rocky,
ReplyDeletei'm a regular at yr blog though nvr post comments before.
I'm a Chinese born, bred and educated up to degree level in Perak. Yes, I think PR in Perak has make a good difference in the last 11 months or so.
But going against the Sultan and demonstrating like nobody business...I can't agree with that, it tarnished whatever good deeds they've done. In fact it's darn digusting.
I have utmost respect for Sultan and Regent of Perak. They are the epitome of what Raja Berpelembagaan is all about.
I will place the Daulat Tuanku logo in my facebook proudly!
Proud to be Perakian!!
-ach8323
Since everyone is stil blaming the Sultan, I just have this to say..
ReplyDeleteNizar sacked himself
This little clause below is what PKR quotes as the defining legal rampart from which they want to hurl accusations and abuses that the Sultan has overstepped his boundary.
"If the MB ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Legislative Assembly, then, unless at his request His Royal Highness dissolves the Legislative Assembly, he shall tender the resignation of the Executive Council."
Let us look at this sentence very carefully, first we will remove the bit between commas and see what we get
"If the MB ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Legislative Assembly he shall tender the resignation of the Executive Council."
Once the MB ceases to command majority, he is to tender his resignation.
Did he lose command of the majority? If he did not why on earth would he go and ask the Sultan for a dissolution.
The resignation here is for the whole executive council or Exco.
Here is where the Sultan's role comes in;
Once Nizar has come forward with request for dissolution, he has effectively put the Sultan on notice that he has lost command of the majority.
Remember this; at no point has anyone come up to say that he has lost command of the majority, all we had notice that BN was goign to hold a Press conference to announce that Bota has returned to the fold and three ADUNs have resigned from PKR and DAP to become independent.
If he did not ask for dissolution then it woudl be a different story, since there would still be room to wriggle and leaves little or no opening for BN to come in and make a claim of majority.
If Nizar HAD NOT asked for dissolution, it would be hard for the Sultan to entertain BN's request, at the most he may suggest that they should hold an emergency session to see who's got the bigger bat.
NIZAR's first course of action should have been to ask for an emergency session to sort it out like politicians but I guess he figured he woudl lose in an emergency session so he jumped the gun and asked for dissolution, If you follow the logic train, this route would also bring you to the conclusion that Nizar did not command the majority
But since Nizar has put the Sultan on notice that he no longer commands majority when he asked for a dissolution, there is every reason for the Sultan to receive BN's proposal for a new Government.
Once he has received assurance from all 28 Umno reps and three independent tha they are indeed in support fo the single largest party in the state assembly, the Sultan can now decide whether he should accept Nizar's request for dissolution.
All he did was deny that request for dissolution (this is the bit between the comma.
then, unless at his request His Royal Highness dissolves the Legislative Assembly
When the Sultan refused to entertain Nizar's request for dissolution, by virtue of the bits after the comma AND without any further action from the Sultan, Nizar is required to tender his resignation, failign which the seat becomes automatically vacant.
In effect Nizar sacked himself by asking for a dissolution of the state legislative, in fact he announced the dissolution even before getting consent from the Sultan ( which is, by the way, a departure from the rule ( ultra vires kata orang loyar - salah dari segi undang undang, melangaku had kuasa). but never mind that little anomaly, by annoucning the dissolution, Nizar told the world that he no logner commands majority.
So you see Nizar really did sack himself and he did publicly, without asking the Sultan, who had fought hard for his post to receive and accept his resignation by agreeing to a dissolution.
After the MB, requested for dissolution and the sultan declined, the MB's office automatically becomes vacant, (read the Sultan's office statement again for he articulated this legal point very clearly and at no time did he say that he sacked Nizar, it simply stated the cause and effect)
Faced with a vacant chair of the state executive, the Sultan has to move quickly to prevent a power vacuum.
At this point what the Pakatan people should have done is gone to present their case to the Sultan, that they still have command of over the legislative council, though it may be a minority Government...
Oh they may have vaguely mentioned it to us but never made this representation to the Sultan you see...
So, faced with only one representation from BN for forming a new Government despite Nizar coming for a second time before the Sultan, (Nizar went again to plead for dissolution - thus providing double confirmation that he has no majority to offer to the Sultan) he had no choice but to accept the BN's proposal.
What happened here is an example of a lack of understanding of how the law works,
If you tell the Sultan that you no longer command majority, by asking for dissolution then you have basically shot yourself in the foot
which is surprising because I am sure that Pakatan has an army of lawyers, Karpal is famous , I was told Kit Siang is legally qualified and many others....
In Conclusion, Nizar sacked himself publicly first then told the Sultan he wanted dissolution which effectively means he has lost comand of the majority, which means if the sultan does not agree to dissolution his seat becoems automatically vacant (sultan did not sack him), if the Sultan agreed to dissolution - it would also mean that the MB has lost his seat so you must be careful with request for dissolution because it is a very dangerous option.
Anwar tried this trick on Pak Lah on Sept 16 but Pak Lah did not fall for it, just sat it out until next session and nothing happened...
Stop blaming the Sultan for making the choice that he did, he is well within the law and a massive statewide election is an unnecessary distraction and expense at this point and a BN Government will likely get more support from the Federal Government, crucial during times of recession. He simply took the option that would better serve the people.
This is just plain stupid. How can u take a king to court and say that he is wrong? And i don't understand whats the deal whether BN or Pakatan holds Perak. We still have to work, Our pay won't be raised, and to normal people like me, it does nothing for me.Peace people.
ReplyDeleteA normal citizen
Rocky, forget my comment, i did not notice you already put a link to teh article in your entry.. sorry
ReplyDeleteWe Umno must unite all umno supporters to use Sultan as a Shield and Armor to defend ourselves.
ReplyDeleteDaulat Tuanku! Daulat Tuanku.
UmnoForSultan
IS Sultan really fair?
ReplyDeleteAfter March 8, 2008 The sultan choose PAS as MB because he wants a balance of power between all races. He wants stability so he choose a Malay as MB. All Pakatan Rakyat parties agreed.
As of the new state government, BN has more than 95% UMNO members. Is this balance? Does this represent racial composition of Perak state? Also, there are high possibility that corruption involved!
Wouldn't it be right to have another state election?
Also, I'll do not believe that we must be blindly loyal to any Sultan. He's just like me and you. He's a fellow human being. Needless to say, I'll not be rude to him.
Perakians
Terlebih dahulu saya memohon maaf serta mengucapkan terima kasih kepada saudara Rocky kerana membenarkan saya berhujah dengan panjang lebar mengenai isu ini walaupun ia “mengganggu”. Saya berharap saudara bersabar dengan tindakan saya “memeinjam” blog ini memandangkan blog anda menerima pembaca paling ramai dan saya ingin menyebarkan maklumat ini kepada umum khususnya masyarakat melayu marhaen agar tidak terpedaya dengan banjingan-banjingan PR.
ReplyDeleteKalau nukilan saya yang lepas kepada “CerdikPandai’ bertujuan memperjelaskan isu ini sebaik mungkin, nukilan ini pula bertujuan menguatkan hujah bahawa pemuka PR telah silap percaturan perundangan dan sengaja mengapi2kan suasana untuk kepentingan anjing jalanan tertentu.
Kesemua sumber yang diperturunkan dibawah bagi tujuan penghujahan berasal dari http://art-harun.blogspot.com/2009/02/perak-crisis-unsolicited-legal-opinion.html khususnya dari bahagian komentarnya.
PENGUPASAN HUJAH 1.
Dalam maklumbalas yang Art terima dari pembaca, tampak timbul kekeliruan mengenai frasa antara
1) ‘ the confidence of the majority of the legislative assembly”
Dan
2) the confidence of the majority of the members of the Legislative Assembly.."
Buktinya:
If it says "if the MB ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the Legislative assembly", it will take to mean that the determination of that confidence should be in the assembly.
Sumber: Michael, February 6, 2009 : 5.38pm
Saya telah memeriksa Perlembagaan Perak di http://www.digitalibrary.my/dmdocuments/malaysiakini/273_perak.pdf dan nyata versi 2 yang tepat. Ini diperakui oleh Art Harun disini dalam menjawab Michael serta seorang komentar lain :
Dear Michael and Thyechong,
The version which I have and quoted in my post has the word "members". I have also checked with Imtiaz. His version also contains the word "members".
Februari 6 : 7.54pm
Implikasi hakikat ini adalah amat penting kerana jika versi 1 diterima pakai maka nyata undi tidak percaya MESTI dibuat didalam persidangan DUN SAHAJA (sepertimana pendapat Chong diatas). TETAPI kalau kita bersandarkan kepada versi 2(yang tepat), maka, penilaian tahap kepercayaan boleh dilakukan di LUAR DUN sepertimana yang dilakukan oleh Baginda Sultan tempoh hari melalui pertemuan semuka dengan 31 ADUN (28=Bn + 3= Bebas). Nah, jelas sekali, baginda sultan tidak membelakangkan sebarang prosedur.
PENGHUJAHAN 2
Di sini saya memperturunkan artikel2 yang berkaitan yang terkandung dalam Perlembagaan Persekutuan (Exhibit 1) dan yang terkandung dalam Perlembagaan Perak (exhibit 2)
Exhibit 1
Federal constitution: Article 43 (4): If the Prime Minister ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the House of Representatives, then, unless at his request the Yang di-Pertuan Agong dissolves Parliament, the Prime Minister shall tender the resignation of the Cabinet.
Exhibit 2
Perak state constitution: Artikel XVI(6): If the Mentri Besar ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Legislative Assembly, then unless at his request His Royal Highness dissolves the Legislative Assembly, he shall tender the resignation of the Executive Council.
Kalau diselidik isi kandungan dan konstruksi kandungan adalah SEIRAS kecuali perbezaan terma di mana yang satu merjuk kepada Parlimen manakala satu merujuk kepada ADUN. Pembaca budiman, kita sedia maklum bahawa Anwar bin Ibrahim pernah berhujah bahawa usul undi tidak percaya terhadap Dollah bin Badawi jika berjaya akan menyebabkan kerajaan Dollah Bin Badawi tersungkur secara tidak langsung turut melucutkan kuasa dari Dollah bin Badawi kerana mana mungkin DBB mampu berkuasa bila sudah hilang kepercayaan!!!
Tidak dinafikan bahawa dakwaan prosedural sedemikian oleh Anwar bin Ibrahim adalah tepat dan disepakati oleh jumhur ulama perlembagaan sekular Malaysia. Sekarang, dengan bersandarkan hujah itu, bukankah hakikat yang serupa akan wujud di Perak, yakni hilang kepercayaan majoriti ADUN bermaksud hilang autoritas MB untuk memerintah dan secara automatik gugur sudahlah kuasa dari tangannya!! Gamplangkan kenyataan ini? Jadi kenapa awak Anwar bin Ibrahim tidak menasihati Nizar bin Jamaluddin akan hakikat ini?? Jawabbbbbbbbb.!! Kalau JANTAN!
Berhubung dengan ini, saya ingin mengutarakan bahawa tindakan (the act) memohon Baginda Sultan/Agong untuk membubar adalah suatu yang menyusul “If the Mentri Besar ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Legislative Assembly,……….., Bukankah ini bermaksud satu perakuan tersirat mantan MB Nizar bahawa beliau telah “ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Legislative Assembly……….” dan dengan yang demikian, harus meletakkan jawatan sekiranya (unless) permohonan pembubaran di tolak?
Jadi saya hendak bertanya kepada PR, terutama Nizar bin Jamaluddin kenapa masih angkuh, celupar dan bertegar dengan pendirian yang jelas melanggar ‘akidah”pendokong perlembagaan sekular!!!
PENGHUJAHAN 3
Art Harun dan konco2nya termasuk Malik Imtiaz bin Ghulam Sarwar, Karpal Singh bin??? bertegar bahawa perlantikan Datuk Dr Zambry bin Abdul Kadir adalah ultra vires kerana usul undi tidak percaya belum dibentangkan untuk penghujhan dan pengundian diDALAM ADUN, satunya tempat dimana ianya WAJIB dilakukan. Hujah mereka bersandarkan Stephen Kalong Ningkan vs Governor of Sarawak (1966). Mereka berhujah bahawa prosedur ini telah ditetapkan dalam penghakiman Harley CJ, hakim Besar Borneo.Lihat : (Stephen Kalong Ningkan v Tun Abang Haji Openg (1966) 2 MLJ 187, 193, as noted in (1966) 8 Malaya LR 283)
Saya telah berhujah bahawa Harley CJ membuat keputusan sedemikian berdasarkan, kesangsian beliau bahawa surat-surat yang dikemukakan oleh 30 pemetisyen mengandungi keraguan dan wujud unsur2 kecurigaan mengenai penandatangannya. Malah kesangsian ini dizahirkan melalui kenyataan beliau (Harley CJ) yang berbunyi:
Men who put their names to a ‘Top Secret’ letter may well hesitate to vote publicly in support of their private views." Pg:193
dan fleksibiliti mengenai kaedah menentukan kepercayaan itu jelas tampak dalam penggunaan perkataan “MAY” bukannya “MUST” dalam ekstrak ini:
It seems to me that by the provisions of the Sarawak Constitution, loss of confidence may be demonstrated only by a vote in Council Negri.
Malah dalam penghakiman beliau dalam kes Amir Kahar vs Tun Mohd Said Keruak, Yang Arif Justice Datuk Abdul Kadir Sulaiman juga menyentuh akan dilemma yang dihadapi Harley CJ berhubung kesahihan dokumen petisyen yang mendasari keputusan Gabenor Sarawak memecat Stephen Kalong Ningkan:
The hard fact in that case (Ningkan) was that the alleged loss of confidence was highly suspect. There was a top secret representation made by persons outside the Council Negri which on the fact of it did not disclose that the representors were the majority of members in the Council Negri. Also, the fact represented was suspicious in the sense that the letter was not signed by all persons listed in the letter and even in respect of those who signed, one of them was represented only by a ‘chop’
Sumber : Penghakiman Justice Datuk Abdul Kadir Sulaiman dalam Amir Kahar vs Tun Mohd Said Keruak(1994)
Maka tidak hairanlah sekiranya Harley CJ enggan mengesahkan pemecatan Stephen oleh Gabenor dan mencadangkan bahawa ketentuan kepercayaan dibuat di DALAM DUN. Seperti yang dihujah dalam nukilan saya kepada “Cerdikpandai” penetapan ini bukanlah sesuatu yang berdasarkan perundangan semata2 tetapi berdalilkan keraguan pada maklumat asal yang diterima Gabenor Sarawak. Perlu ingat, Art dan Malik Imtiaz tidak mendedahkan pemerhatian Hakim dalam kes Amir Kahar vs Tun Mohd Said Keruak. Mengapa? Tepuk batang dan tanya nafsu masing-masing.!!!
Malah Art terus berdalih dengan bermain silapkata apabila “diperangkap”:
Because the relevant article imposes an objective test, ie, it must be factually proven that the MB does not anymore command the confidence of the majority. Stepehn Kalong Ningkan's case has interpreted that to mean a vote of no confidence on the floor of the Assembly. It is a well reasoned judgment. It even distinguishes the Privy Council decision in Adegbenro v Akintola.
In Adegbenro's case, the Privy Council opined that lost of confidence may be shown by letters or some other way. But in that case, the provision of the Nigerian constitution under review says "if it appears" that the PM does not command the confidence of the assembly. That phrase gives a degree of subjectivity to the Ruler. But that phrase is not in the Perak Constitution.
Therefore, only a vote of no confidence could be relied by the Sultan in Perak.
Sumber: Art Harun Feb 7 : 4.53pm
Saya berpendapat bahawa Art Harun sepatutnya mengambil kes Amir Kahar vs Tun Mohd Said Keruak kerana persamaan yang ketara antara kes tersebut dengan peristiwa di Perak. Jika ini dilakukannya, sudah tentu pandangannya akan lebih mirip dengan pandangan saya pada pukul 2.08pm di atas. Lihat : http://www.bernama.com/bernama/v5/newspolitic.php?id=388236
Saya berharap bahawa penjelasan ini membantu merungkai kemelut yang kini melanda umat Melayu islam terutama mereka yang masih ingkar dan mempertikaikan keputusan bijaksana baginda Sultan.
Kepada Kembara Politik, saya setuju dengan pendapat anda dan pengupasan saya tidak berniat mengaib kerabat diraja Perak. Sama2lah kita bernaung dibawah paying Raja2 kita dan mempertahankan agama, bangsa dan tanahair dari dirobak robekkan oleh segelintir anjing jalanan keparat yang mahu menangguk air keruh!
Post script
And to those Fakatan scum who are still adamant and bestial in their reasoning, read this from one of your own and stick it deep into your arse for eternity:
http://shamsuliskandar.wordpress.com/2008/09/22/no-confidence-vote-not-the-only-way/
Warrior 231
"p.s And I hope no one resorts to hanging the Perak flag or the portrait of HRH Sultan Azlan Shah upside down to counter this blog campaign". Have you "kick" somebody? Poor Director! Not enough budget to make film. Only pentomin avalaible.
ReplyDeleteNgeh-Nga-Ngong
Bru,
ReplyDeleteDato Lat tak mahu buat sketches tentang pergolakan yang sedang berlaku ke?
Would be worth his witty preception.
Particular on todays famous phrase....
'......jangan main-main dengan saya....'
Anwar,
ReplyDeleteremember this, d same one u stuck up in your blog back in September:
http://www.malaysianbar.org.my/news_features/no_confidence_vote_not_the_only_way.html
are you playing a fucking game in Perak ala sacrificing a poisoned pawn so that you can get a Court Declaration and then signal your now fully grown tadpoles to leap out of their pond into your swamp of perfidity.
Dont waffle..give a straight answer..i have got u corneredlah hoodlum!
Warrior 231
rocky...
ReplyDeletethe sultan is just like any normal human being...he makes mistakes...so happens that the mistake he made last week was the biggest mistake he ever made in his life..if he's really a ruler of the people, why not get down from his throne and listen to the rants of the rakyat himself?? no use sitting up high and mighty talking about impartiality without walking the talk..but its still not late to rectify this mess by calling a state election..i really dont know why he listens to a murderer instead of his subjects..mind boggling!!!!
Raja Nazrin of Perak says that royals in this country should matter more because they represent the rakyat and they can make a difference in the direction of the country. I'm sure he aimed those at the politicians to remind them that the royals are still around and that the politicians can't just run around the country doing whatever they liked.
ReplyDeleteThat's good and fair. But I feel that the royals should exist to take care of the rakyat because they are in that position where they enjoy power and wealth because of the rakyat, because the rakyat agreed that they should be elevated to that level, to lead them, and generations later, they are treated as though they are saints or better human beings just because they are born in that family.
I don't mind, that's history. The royals' forefathers has set their family up for life, I can't do anything about it. I just wished that some of these royals would use their brains and be thankful that they are set for life, enjoying the good life because the people have given their consent for them to do so.
The least the royals could do was to appreciate the people by taking care of them. The royals could start by not wasting the people's money, then don't behave like assholes in public like slapping people, killing people, showing off, and all that nice royal behavior that we love so much.
Why can't our royals really take the peoples' welfare to heart like the royals of Jordan? The kings of Jordan (King Hussein and now his son King Abdullah) care about their subjects so much that they are willing to disguise themselves and walk around the fish markets and back alley shops to talk to the people, to ask them about their daily lives and the problems they face in dealing with the government.
After collecting all the information, the king would summon the government officers to sort things out for the betterment of the people. Here in Malaysia when the royals talk about doing things for the betterment of the people, that's what it is, just talk.
If they don't listen to the people and to the little righteous voice in their hearts, in 50 years time they'll be overthrown because we won't need them anymore.
what? you are telling us that we should simply shut up because the man that made a questionable decision happens to be titled as Sultan?
ReplyDeletedoes that lable mean that he is omnipotent? just like you would like your thoughts and words to be perceived as such - simply because you hang on to the label of being a journalist?
open your mind. you are not stupid but your ego is unchecked and it is blinding you.
turn coat or not, you are entitled to your opinions but stop being so condesending already.
your writing reeks of desperation for approval.
Agree with you Praxis. At the time YB Nizar went to Sultan Azlan to ask for dissolution, he already lost the confidence of majority of members of state assembly.
ReplyDeleteIf all you Pakatan supporters are care enough to read the Perak's constitution, you will find that the wording there state that 'members of state assembly' not just 'state assembly'. This implies that the lost of confidence of majority of the members of assembly can be proven not just from the vote of no confidence in state assembly, but also by other way and in this case by a letter shown by DS Najib. So the sultan is right in this situation because at the time DS Nizar sought for dissolution, he already lost the majority and therefore he had lost the right to ask for the dissolution
So in this case, it was DS Nizar own ignorance that played its part for the fallen of his own government. Should he asked for the dissolution earlier than that, I think the sultan will agree for the dissolution.
PR should just accept it, and withdraw with dignity. Don't be a sore loser man. Suing the sultan wouldn't bring you any good in the long term relationship of PR and the palace.
And to all the muslims/malay who bashed the sultan for thinking that the sultan was wrong, I am reminding you that it's ok to point the wrongs (I think he was right) but please make it in the framework of our religion. Just remember Allah doesn't like those who transgress.
Tak kira se'PAS' mana pun anda, anda belum dijamin untuk mendapat kebahagiaan yang dijanjikan oleh ALLAH untuk hamba-hamba Nya yang soleh.
Marilah kita sama-sama bermuhasabah.
PENYOKONG UMNO & RockyBru
bru,
ReplyDeleteintro nya , MAKA KAMI RAKYAT MALAYSIA ............YA RAKYAT ...
BRU,
ReplyDeleteBACA....MAKA KAMI RAKYAT MALAYSIA...
pada permulaan ikrar ini RAKYAT DISEBUT DULU..
MOYA.
NILAI
NEGERI SEMBILAN
Zambry was sworned in by the Sultan as the new 'MB' of Perak. If he is truly the ‘MB’ of all races as he professed, please give the Speaker’s post to MIC, as they requested, and see if his tongue speaks the truth. At least you appease some indians by giving them goodwill representation in Perak. Be brave, strong and not show your fear from any objections by UMNO, MCA or PPP. Show us you are an 'MB' of the rakyat. Walk the talk, Zambry.
ReplyDeleteAnak Malaysia
Ahh..tuanku!!!
ReplyDeleteAkan ku amuk pezalim rakyat spt kamu...
Kata mereka Jebat Derhaka!!!
Derhaka terhadap sultan!!!
Keramaian itu..
Berbondong-bondong umat manusia menuju untuk mendengar amanat..
barat,timur,utara dan juga selatan...
hanya dengan satu perjuangan dan kata keramat
Hanya dgn tekad & satu suara..
Ingat saudara-saudaraku.....
Mari kita bersupah keramat...
suara rakyat suara keramat!!
Keramaian itu..
ReplyDeleteBerbondong-bondong umat manusia menuju untuk mendengar amanat..
barat,timur,utara dan juga selatan...
hanya dengan satu perjuangan dan kata keramat
Hanya dgn tekad & satu suara..
Ingat saudara-saudaraku.....
Mari kita bersupah keramat...
suara rakyat suara keramat!!
DAULAT TUANKU!!
ReplyDeleteMaka kami RAKYAT Malaysia berikrar akan menumpukan seluruh tenaga dan usaha kami untuk mencapai cita-cita tersebut berdasarkan atas prinsip-prinsip yang berikut:
ReplyDeleteKamu telah berikrar at least selama 11-12 tahun yang akan menumpukan seluruh tenaga dan usaha untuk KESETIAAN kepada RAJA dan NEGARA.
Awat nak tanya2
"
BACA....MAKA KAMI RAKYAT MALAYSIA...
pada permulaan ikrar ini RAKYAT DISEBUT DULU.."
Tak malukah baca ikrar tak abis?
I read with hilarity here the following things:-
ReplyDelete(i) Calls for the sultan and his son to use their head. Well I am not sure about THAT, but then the ones who terbaring atas jalanraya and pelt the sultan's car with stones wear ketayap putih and kain pullikat cap gadjah. The sultan, on the other hand had his London law degree that pushed him to become Lord President, and his son studied up till the highest level until there are no more degrees that the university can confer him anymore. I am sure the ketayap guys use their heads better. No?
(ii) Pakatan Rakyat people had been telling us that the rakyat wants this and the rakyat wants that. Well you know, I am a rakyat. Along with like, millions others in Perak ... in fact the majority. I dont remember telling you that we, the rakyat, agree with you?
Ironic, is it not, that all these loyalists have suddenly surfaced and are crying "treason"?
ReplyDeleteIncluding International Trade & Industry Minister Muhyiddin who is famed for the accuracy of his forecasts for the Malaysian economy and his predecessor Rafidah of AP fame.
And people like Hishamuddin who has further messed up an already messed up national education system and assorted luminaries from the likes of Umno Youth (who never miss a chance to wave their little kerises around) and assorted Malay NGOs who go around proclaiming "treason" and dire consequences for all and sundry who dare to challenge the status quo.
I would include Warrior 231 in this unsavory agglomeration, but he seems to be suffering from a surfeit of orgiastic thinking and delusional fantasies - far removed from the realms of rational discourse.
All these avowedly patriotic "jokers" (and I use the term with due consideration) don't have even the faintest notions of how to address the dire economic situation that is facing the country. Do you think Najib knows how to fix the shortcomings in the Malaysian economy? Has any of the royalty come out with sensible and well thought-out suggestions on what Malaysia should do in the face of the global economic, financial and banking crisis?
Even the vaunted PR coalition (and its leading lights - DSAI, Kit Siang, Guan Eng, Karpal, etc) are seemingly only good for mouthing off. Nothing more.
The intellectual capacity and the political honesty of both the BN and PR coalitions is so dismally negative that I am compelled to think that no one has a clue what needs to be done.
All the more reason to choose the easy alternative of accusing people of "treason" and engineering political shifts of power through legitimately unsavoury means.
Because the biggest fear of these people (and I include royalty in this group) is that they will be exposed to the rakyat as "emperors without clothes".
By which time Malaysia will be a basket case economy.
your spin is getting stale, rocky.
ReplyDeleteAdrah
Nizar oh Nizar,
ReplyDeleteKamu ni kenapa ler bodoh sombong?
Perlantikan kamu dulu sebagai MB diperkenan oleh Sultan setelah percaturan antara geng-geng kamu dalam PR tu kan. Sultan juga tolong pastikan geng adun cina PR kamu tu akan tetap menyokong kamu dengan akujanji bertulis. Tengok ler tu betapa sayangnya Sultan pada kamu. Dan lepas tu bagi title Datuk Seri pulak tu! Sayang betul Sultan pada kamu ye.
Lepas tu kamu jadilah MB - tapi MB yang lemah! Kamu sebenarnya MB boneka. Hidung kamu dah dicucuk oleh kedua cina DAP Nga Nge tu! Rakyat Perak tahu yang jadi MB sebenarnye Nga Nge tu. Kamu tu dah di bodohkan oleh mereka. Tugas kamu ialah sebagai jurucakap kedua cina tu. Dan naik ler tocang cina!
Sakitnye hati orang melayu Perak.
Tapi bila timbul hal katak lompat melompat ni kamu dah kena checkmate! Adun BN pun pandai trick kamu. Sebabnye kamu tersalah langkah dengan gelabah kamu tu.
Dalam kemelut ni Sultan kamu tu pun lagi bijak membuat keputusan. Sultan meminta kamu berundur dengan cara terhormat - kamu berdegil dan menentangnya! Dengan cina DAP Nga Nge tu kamu takut dan sanggup dicucuk hidung, tapi tiba-tiba dengan Sultan yang sayangkan kamu dulu kamu lawan? Kamu ingat Sultan kamu bodoh ke? Kamu ingat dia tu tak tahu undang-undang? Kamu ingat Sultan kamu baru hidup kat dunia ni ke? Cuma geng-geng kamu tu jadi tongong nak lawan Sultan. Lawan lah!
Sekarang ni kesian campur kelakar tengok kamu tu meraban macam orang gila talak. Tengok ler muka kamu dalam cermin - muka kamu ke atau bayang muka orang lain? Perangai kamu sekarang ni macam copycat hal Anwar Al-jub ni dulu. Anwar Al-jub tu dulu kena pecat oleh PM masa tu. Sebelum dipecat dia pun diberi peluang berundur dengan cara terhormat. Tapi Anwar Al-jub tu degil dan tak mahu terima pemecatan tu dengan mengatakan hanya Agung saja boleh pecat dia. Lawan tetap lawan. Penyokong dia digerakkan untuk berdemo sana sini. Samalah macam kamu menggerakkan penyokong kamu berdemo juga. Tapi kebanyakannye orang luar Perak! Dan banyak lagi rakyat melayu KK dan Perak masih sayangkan Sultan mereka.
Anwar pun macam kamu jugalah. Mula-mula tak mahu keluar dari kediaman rasmi TPM. Tapi lama-lama bila api dan air dipotong oleh JKR barulah nak berpindah ke rumah sendiri di Damansara tu.
Diharap kamu tak serabutkan otak kamu lagi dengan lakunan tongong macam Anwar Al-jub tu. Sekarang ni kamu dah dijadikan kuda tunggangan Anwar Al-jub pulak. Kesian, setelah diperkudakan oleh cina DAP, sekarang ni ditunggang si Al-jub PKR pulak! Kesian....
-tukang perati
Assalamualaikum,
ReplyDeleteSaya sentiasa mengikuti politik negara, samada melalui medium Pakatan ataupun yang pro BN & kali ini saya cuba meluahkan pandangan saya melalui blog, kalau sebelum ini dgn kawan2 ada la.
Pada pandangan saya keputusan Sultan Perak amat bijaksana,
MENGAPA;
1. Ketika PRU12 baginda telah membuat keputusan untuk Pakatan Rakyat memerintah sedangkan Pakatan Rakyat sebenarnya masih belum didaftarkan sebagai pertubuhan yang sah mengikut undang2, gabungan (PAS,PKR & DAP) diwujudkan hanya ketika PRU12 tanpa didaftarkan mengikut undang2.
2. Baginda sebenarnya berhak dari segi undang2 utk mengistiharkan BN sebagai pemerintah walaupun dgn minoriti (Terdengar juga BN cuba meminta baginda berbuat demikian)tetapi dgn kebijaksanaan baginda ia tidak berlaku & BN menerima hakikat mereka sebagai pembangkang di Perak & tiada sebarang demontrasi dicetuskan yg boleh menggugat keselamatan negara.
3. Apabila 3 ADUN Pakatan telah keluar menjadi BEBAS serta menyatakan sokongan kepada BN maka baginda dgn kebijaksanaan baginda sekali lagi telah memanggil semua ADUN & mendengar sendiri pengakuan mereka & majoriti berpihak kepada BN. Jadi apa perlunya IR Nizar berkeras tidak meletak jawatan MB & memanggil mesyuarat exco utk undi tidak percaya sedangkan semua ADUN telah menyatakan pendirian masing2 & dan sekali lagi ditegaskan majoriti memihak BN walaupun pelbagai spekulasi menyatakan BN "merasuah" ketiga2 ADUN yg melompat itu dan sebagainya. Saya bukan utk menyatakan disini "matlamat menghalalkan cara" tetapi selalunya Pakatan akan cuba menarik perhatian rakyat dgn mewujudkan spekulasi begini termasuklah membuatkan rakyat membenci polis yang turut menjaga keselamatan mereka sekeluarga tetapi tiada bukti & bila mereka menang dalam sesuatu isu / pilihanraya semua itu akan tenggelam.
PERSOALAN UTAMA KENAPA SULTAN PERAK TIDAK MEMBUBARKAN DUN & SETERUSNYA MENGADAKAN PILIHANRAYA.
4. Bagi saya baginda tahu negara didalam krisis ekonomi global termasuklah ribuan pekerja kilang yang telah & akan dibuang kerja & tidak seperti krisis 1998, krisis kali ini dijangka benar2 dirasai rakyat bawahan & lebih panjang kerana sektor perkilangan paling teruk terjejas termasuk Singapura yang dulunya tidak terlalu merasa tempias krisis 1998. Ini tak termasuk krisis makan dunia & kenaikan harga minyak dunia yang lalu & tiba2 turun pulak mengejut ditambah pulak PM Pak Lah yang cepat melatah dgn turut menaikkan harga minyak di Malaysia dgn mendadak terus barang2 naik & susah dah nak turun.( Org kerja kerajaan kalau tak tau bersyukur tak tahu la sekurang2 nya masih dapat gaji bulan2 samada krisis atau tidak & utk simpanan hari tua dah ada pencen membantu ), yang kerja swasta macamana..??
5. Jadi baginda dgn bijaksana tidak membubarkan DUN Perak & kerajaan tidak perlu membazirkan duit mengadakan pilihanraya samada hanya di DUN yg melompat katak tu atau negeri keseluruhannya. Bagi saya 1 pilihanraya negeri mungkin akan menyebabkan duit dibazikan mungkin mencecah RM 100juta untuk SPR/POLIS termasuklah duit yang cuba dilaburkan BN kepada Perak dalam keadaan tergesa2 tanpa perancangan yang teliti kerana nak memancing undi @ Pakatan pun takkan nak buat semua persiapan pilihanraya mereka "free" sudah tentu banyak jugak duit yang akan dibazirkan sedangkan PRU13 hanya kurang dari 4 tahun.
6. Lagipun sekiranya pilihanraya negeri tetap diadakan & katakan keputusannya masih hampir sama spt PRU12 dimana BN atau Pakatan hanya berjaya dgn majoriti kecil tidak lebih 3 undi & lepas 2, 3 bulan ada pulak ADUN yang melompat tak ke lagi serabut dibuatnya...duit dah berjuta habis buat pilihanraya yang sepatutnya Pakatan rakyat bersabar & sekiranya tsunami politik ini berterusan mereka pasti akan dapat memerintah Perak dengan majoriti yang lebih kuat malah mungkin berjaya menubuhkan kerajaan pusat pada PRU13 nanti. PAS & DAP sebagai parti yang telah lama wujud & masih tetap dengan ideologi mereka pasti boleh bersabar. Tapi nampaknya DSAI & parti PKR nya seperti dah tak sabar. Kalau dulu (PRU12) kelihatan PKR lah yang berjaya membuatkan Pakatan menang besar tapi nampaknya sekarang kelihatan PKR lah yang telah menghancurkan gabungan ini. Sebab berita terkini menyatakan Karpal singh pun dah naik meluat kat DSAI & mahu beliau letak jawatan ketua pembangkang.
6. Kepada IR Nizar...ingatlah titah Sultan Perak seperti yang jugak ditulis dalam harakah supaya ""Inna-Allah ha ma'a sobirin,", beliau masih muda & Insya-Allah jika beliau benar2 ikhlas dalam perjuangan pasti kejayaan akan ada, tapi jika beliau tetap berkeras terus "menderhaka" kepada Sultan pasti beliau akan dikenang dalam sejarah malaysia moden sebagai "penderhaka" terutama dikalangan orang melayu kerana tidak seperti Hang Jebat yang membuat keputusan menderhaka secara bersendirian tetapi IR Nizar kelihatan menderhaka disebalik pengaruh DAP & PKR.
7. Kepada rakyat Perak bersabarlah & buat pertimbangan sewajarnya kerana lebih baik kita hidup dgn aman dan biarkan pemimpin kita samada BN atau Pakatan tidak terlalu memikirkan tentang politik sebaliknya bersama2 cuba berfikir menyelesaikan masalah crisis ekonomi utk memastikan rakyat tidak terlalu merasa tempiasnya.
PRU13 nanti buatlah keputusan. Perlembagaan dah jelas nak tak nak kurang dari 4 tahun lagi PRU 13 kena buat jugak. kalau negara dah kacau bilau apa yang kita dapat. Kepada kaum cina yang memang kebanyakkan berniaga pasti tak mahu ini berlaku. Kepada yang terlalu ahli2 parti yang terlalu taksub berpolitik nak buat macam mana, ingat sama masa depan diri & anak2 kita nanti.
Bro, I suggest you read Hannah Yeoh's piece in The Malaysian Insider. www.TheMalaysianInsider.com
ReplyDeleteFor that matter I invite all the commenters here to read it.
mat taib
Anwar (not the PKR leader) told Najib (not the DPM) that Dollah (not the PM) wants him (Najib) to resign from all his posts. Shud Najib resign based merely on what Anwar told him? Shudn't Najib meet Dollah and listen frm Dollah's mouth before thinking of resigning? Some people need analogy to even understand simple things.
ReplyDeletefrm: no need analogy
Bro Rocky,
ReplyDeletei. Dari komen-komen di sini jelas, pemahaman sebahagian mereka bahawa Raja itu adil apabila membuat keputusan yang memihak kepada mereka;
ii. Sekiranya keputusan itu tidak sama dengan hasrat mereka, Raja dianggap tidak adil;
iii. Bagaimana agaknya sekiranya mereka yang berada di tempat Sultan itu?
Rocky,
ReplyDeleteSetia pada Raja. Saya rasa semua orang setia dan hormat pada Raja Azlan Shah. Walaupun Nizar ingkar bukan bermakna beliau derhaka cuma berbeza pandangan dengan tuanku. Ini semua adalah kerana tafsiran undang2 tubuh negeri Perak yg ditafsirkan berbeza oleh pelbagai pihak. Jadi kita tunggu lah keputusan mahkamah. Samada sultan, raja, menteri, rocky, pengemis semua mesti bertindak ikut lunas undang2. Jadi sapa betul salah tunggu apa keputusan mahkamah.
Sementara tu tak payah nak bahas lebih2, nak provoke orang ramai , nak demonstrasi bantah raja, nak berarak kononnya setia pada raja,tak payah nak memperbodohkan diri dengan kenyataan2 bodoh, jangan jadi menteri bodoh, jangan jadi reporter bodoh dan jangan diperbodoh oleh orang2 bodoh.
Warrior 231,
ReplyDeleteMuch appreciate your attempt to enlighten. Panjang dan lebar but if I may summarise, what you're espousing is -" Cincang, sula, kacip, penggal, potong mereka2 yang menghina Sultan & Raja-raja kita.". Ok I agree but on one condition. Just make sure your execution list includes those that insulted Agong during last year's Terengganu crisis. And make sure nama Mahathir ada, Jgn lupa dia yang start offensive against Raja-raja. Kena consistent kalau tak nanti orang cakap kita munafiq.
Hang ni real warrior ke atau Internet warrior? aku admire hang punya conviction tapi jgn jadi macam tu Pasquale, fascist Melayu numero uno. Rocky & dia ngam tapi Rocky ni ada sikit 'style", trained journalist tapi kaki putar belit jugak. Aku komen pasal Pasquale ni sebab ternampak komen basi dia pasal komplot bangsa asing nak lenyapkan kuasa Melayu. Tak habis2. Sebenarnya kuasa Meayu makin berkurangan sebab Melayu sendiri yang salah, menngunakan kuasa untuk kepentingan diri sendiri. So paham2.
CerdikPandaiKL
Saya hanya akan menderhaka kpd yg menderhaka kpd undang2 tidak kira ianya dari kalangan kuli batak atau yang mengaku bukan dari kalangan kuli batak. Tetapi kuli batak selalunya takut kpd undang2. Yg mengaku bukan kuli batak ini yg ikut undang2 bila ada untung tapi dgn senang ketepikan undang2 bila tak untung. Daulat undang2!!! (bukan daulat yg lain).
ReplyDeletedpd: kuli batak
Reading abt Perak Royalty's involvement in this blog (anybody can check Bursa M'sia's announcement on this to confirm the truth of this involvement. It's not a wild allegation) we should review Azlan Shah's judgments when he was a judge last time (Datuk Harun's case is one) as it is quite clear now that he is capable of allowing himself to be manipulated!!! What a pity.
ReplyDeletefrm: great pity
Semua yang cakap sini insinuating Rocky terima duit lah, sell his soul lah dan macam-macam lagi semuanya karut, tiada bukti pun, cakap kosong tiada substance. Prove it or forever hold your peace. Jangan mengata dulang paku serpih. Mengata orang dia yang lebih.
ReplyDeleteYang mengadu pasal impartiality tu saya petik bidalan berikut untuk dijadikan pedoman anda:
"Our impartiality is kept for abstract merit and demerit, which none of us ever saw.” maksudnya boleh blah...
dari yang sudah nyanyuk. Oldies.
We in UMNO should use the Sultan to F#^% the PR do gooders
ReplyDeleteBlardy Hell!!!!!
ReplyDeletehttp://anotherbrickinwall.blogspot.com/2009/02/rocket-exploded-nger-nga-nuar-put-to.html
".....Nger and Nga have been holding a tight grip on Perak DAP, dominance on the previous Perak Government, and made puppets of former MB Nizar. Words within the business community in Perak is that they have lined the pockets of contractors, loggers and crony businessmen with projects, contracts and concessions....."
Setia pada Raja. Saya rasa semua orang setia dan hormat pada Raja Azlan Shah. Walaupun Nizar ingkar bukan bermakna beliau derhaka cuma berbeza pandangan dengan tuanku. Ini semua adalah kerana tafsiran undang2 tubuh negeri Perak yg ditafsirkan berbeza oleh pelbagai pihak. Jadi kita tunggu lah keputusan mahkamah. Samada sultan, raja, menteri, rocky, pengemis semua mesti bertindak ikut lunas undang2. Jadi sapa betul salah tunggu apa keputusan mahkamah.
ReplyDeleteDAULAT UNDANG-UNDANG DAN PERLEMBAGAAN!
~faridah~
Dengan nama Allah, Yang Maha Pemurah, lagi Maha Mengasihani.
ReplyDelete1. Segala yang ada di langit dan yang ada di bumi sentiasa mengucap tasbih kepada Allah; bagiNyalah kuasa pemerintahan dan bagiNyalah segala pujian dan Dia Maha Kuasa atas tiap-tiap sesuatu.
2. Dialah yang mengaturkan kejadian kamu; maka ada sebahagian dari kamu yang kafir dan ada sebahagian dari kamu yang beriman dan Allah Maha Melihat akan segala yang kamu kerjakan (serta membalas masing-masing).
3. Dia menciptakan langit dan bumi dengan cara yang sungguh layak dan berhikmat, dan Dia menentukan bentuk rupa kamu serta memperelokkan rupa kamu dan kepadaNyalah tempat kembali.
4. Dia mengetahui segala yang ada di langit dan di bumi dan Dia mengetahui segala yang kamu rahsiakan serta yang kamu zahirkan dan Allah sentiasa Mengetahui segala (isi hati) yang terkandung di dalam dada;
Ayat 64 - AT-TAGHAABUN
JHAD,Penang
Its getting Stale Bro,some englightment.
ReplyDeleteAyat yang akan kita pelajari hari ini adalah 'MAIN'
sebutannya
...m a ' i n
perkataan seerti dengan nya ialah senda.
dalam Bahasa Inggeris ialah 'play'
Konstructife Ayat :
1.Dia main kayu tiga
terjemahan nya
He play three stick.
2.En.Singh bermain-main.
terjemahannay:Mr.Singh play-play
3.Raju kena main.
terjemahannya: Raju was played atau Raju is f..k.
4.Mari kita main pondok-pondok?
terjemahannya: Lets play house-house?
5.Jangan main-main sama saya!
terjemahannya: Dont play-play with me.
oiii..what name?
whose name?
who give name?
since when you got name?
name the game?
what play?
who play where?,front or back?
when play?
why play?
kah.........kah.......kah
Ada betul tak tada betul.....!
Kalau betul cakap betul betul..
Apa main belakang.
Siapa belakang taruk?
The daughter of the Sultan of Perak owns 150.7 million Gamuda shares as at 15/5/08 based on the latest available announcement on Bursa M'sia (anybody can check). Even at the current low price of RM1.91 per share it still amounts to a whopping RM288 million. The share price has plummeted from RM5.30 a year ago to RM1.91 currently. Imagine the diminution in value from RM800 million to RM288 million. Its latest quarterly profit of RM72 million (for qtr ended Oct 08) was a far cry from RM106.5 million achieved in the corresponding qtr of 2007. Gamuda is now facing problems with Penang Govt on land matters. It seems the problem has now spread to Perak.
ReplyDeletefrm: accountant
Dumb PR supporters.
ReplyDeleteNow they blame the Sultan.
Who was promoting party jumping all the while?
Ass holes.
My king right or wrong? Poodah. melampau le u, Rocki. That is why we have the courts to adjudicate when there is a dispute. That is why it is ultra penting (pening?)we have an independent judiciary!
ReplyDeletesalam dari
Dahi.ketiak
I despise these Fuck-Ah-Tan supporters.
ReplyDeleteThrow tantrum elsewhere. Crying and whining like babies. Typical of sore losers who lost at their own game.
Be a grown up, will ya, pussies?
Rocky.... you sux!
ReplyDeleteZainal
Konon raja adil raja disembah, raja zalim raja disanggah.
ReplyDeleteAdil kalau ikut telunjuk kau?
Zalim kalau tak ikut apa yang nko nak?
Takbir.
- SayaModenTapiMasihPerluRaja
Pak Rocky
ReplyDeleteUsually reliable sources have claimed that certain members of the Malaysian royalty have been spotted on a number of occasions in Asia's New York/Zurich/Monaco-in-the-making.
What were they doing? Apart from staying in some of the most expensive suites in that country's super 5-star hotels?
Were they there to sample that country's well-advertised shopping and hospitality facilities? Or to avail themselves of that country's well-established private banking and wealth management institutions? Or maybe for a little harmless R&R? To blow off some steam away from the censorious eyes of purists and zealots in their home country?
A little side note to all the wanna-be royalists: no one is infallible, except The Almighty. Everyone else, from royalty downwards, can and will make mistakes and have errors of judgment. The question, of course, is whether these mistakes and errors of judgement are honest aberrations or something else.
thank you Rocky...ur articles, including this one, have a veiled intention. That is to induce opinions from both side of devide. So ppl, no need-la be angry, just take this as a platform to shape popular opinions. Am sure points would be taken by respecitive ppl.< NO-Masak-Masak >
ReplyDeletethank you Rocky...ur articles, including this one, have a veiled intention. That is to induce opinions from both side of devide. So ppl, no need-la be angry, just take this as a platform to shape popular opinions. Am sure points would be taken by respecitive ppl.< NO-Masak-Masak >
ReplyDeletethank you Rocky...ur articles, including this one, have a veiled intention. That is to induce opinions from both side of devide. So ppl, no need-la be angry, just take this as a platform to shape popular opinions. Am sure points would be taken by respecitive ppl.< NO-Masak-Masak >
ReplyDeleteThose Malays up there is Perak who protested the Sultan's decision number in the thousands. They braved tear gas and are willing to lay down their lives for their principles.
ReplyDeleteA pathetic 100-500 showed up to support the Sultan in Ipoh. Kua kua kua. They will run away at the first sign of any tear gas.
Rocky with his Singaporean background and his tendency to sell his soul is not even 10% as Malay as those thousands of Malays in Kuala Kangsar at the MB's residence and who have been willing to brave danger in defence of the people's right to choose.
Bro Rocky,
ReplyDelete"Biar beradab, jangan biadap dan tak payah derhaka."
I have nothing against DYMM Sultan Perak in this issue. In fact I posted the flag to show my support in my blog.
One thing though, being a Sultan or Raja to me is not just an inherited titles via blood. It also comes with tremendous responsibility.
Sultans, as heads of Ugama Islam of states. Yeah, ceremoniously you can see they do this and that. But, do they really behave like a true Ketua Agama Islam in their life, in public, in social dos? Do they (and their kaums kerabat) deserve the respect from the rakyats?
Just a question.
SHEMEQ
Dah habih dah?
ReplyDeleteTakkan la. Tak sampai 400 komen lagi.
Meh, aku tolong, meh.
Woi! Rocky tak best! Pasal tak attack kerajaan. Rocky hanya best bila attack kerajaan dan kalau jilat punggung Anwar. Kalu tak, tak best.
Rocky dan siapa saja lah, cuma best bila bersetuju dengan anak-anak Tuhan dalam Perasan Rakyat.
Ooooh. Perasan Rakyat! Nak pancutlah!
To Tuanku Sultan Perak,
ReplyDeleteIf a man approaches you to say that yr daughter had been divorced by her hubby and he now wants you to marry him off to your daughter, will you immediately grant his wish or you check with your daughter first to find out whether your daughter had indeed been divorced by her hubby?
frm: rakyat marhin
To DS Najib Tun Razak,
ReplyDeleteI heard one UMNO member (Mr Abdullah) managed to gather many UMNO delegates in a hotel and all of them had signed a petition losing confidence in you as Dy President. Mr Abdullah will submit the signed petition to UMNO Hq to have you removed accordingly. If you don't know what to do I wud advise that u reject it and ask them to submit requisition for an EGM to table the no confidence motion. Any other way wud be ultra vires the UMNO constitution. Tell them to please respect the constitution.
frm: loyal member
This episode reminds me of MCA crisis in early 80s where Tan Koon Swan had managed to obtain majority support from MCA delegates and wanted Dr Neo Yee Pan to resign as President as he has lost majority support. Dr Neo refused to resign until a vote of no confidence is passed against him. When Tan Koon Swan requisitioned for an EGM to table the motion MCA Sec Gen Chong Hon Nyan refused to convene one, and this sparked the crisis. I'm sure Perak Speaker is willing to convene a special sitting if there's a requisition, unlike his barbaric counterpart in Parliament who refused Anwar's request for one.
ReplyDeletefrm: not barbaric
Just read somewhere that Gamuda has a pending corruption charge yet to be investigated by the ACA. WHo heads Gamuda? The white haired man's daughter. SO now it makes sense. It was a deal all along. Perakians have to suffer now.
ReplyDeletekmodo
i dun agree with the sultan....biasness is soo obvious here...why not give a new state election? whats wrong?? it has always been unstable in perak anyways....we all have our opinions....ad yes i believe no matter wat ppl say abt anwar or opposition in general, BN is rejected....soo freaking rejected....sharkboy...
ReplyDelete